5 ms·
This makes me sick. I work in the corrections industry and regularly encounter people that use the "they are criminals" justification for any/everything they wa
by joshstrange 11y ago
This makes me sick. I work in the corrections industry and regularly encounter people that use the "they are criminals" justification for any/everything they want to do. People don't seem to understand the whole "paid debt to society" notion and it worries me because I was more or less brought up believing this and I worry for the future as more and more people seem to think this way...
I work in part in reentry, these people are trying to get their lives back together yet people want to treat them like bad behaving children instead of the adults that they are. I'm not saying they are fully functioning adults, most of them are just dumped out of the prison system and need a great deal of help to get back on their feet (find somewhere to live, a job, etc) but treating them as less-than... I can't think of a worse way to approach this problem. Thankfully the company I work for is largely part of the solution and not the problem or I couldn't bear to work in this industry.
- rdudek 11y agoThis is pretty bad, there is no way this law can be legal. If anything, I dare the folks who get fired to challenge the law and sue the county down to bankruptcy.
- the_ancient 11y agoPart of the problem is the "Debt to Society" crap. People who violate the law do not owe a debt to society, they owe a debt to their victim(s) and no one else. This "debt to society" was invented in order to justify the creation of 1000's of victimless "crimes" It should be very simple... No Victim, No Crime.
- Joky 11y agoTo be sure I understand you: you mean we can't prevent people from bringing an AK47 in school, as long as they don't shoot anyone? And one can drive as fast a she wants as long as there is no accident? One can sell outdated food as long as no client gets sick?
- the_ancient 11y ago>>>you mean we can't prevent people from bringing an AK47 in school, as long as they don't shoot anyone? As a matter of General Law, no. However if the property owner, in this case the school board, chooses on their own to disallow guns on their property then a person violating that would be guilty of criminal trespass. This is true for a Starbucks, Walmart, your personal home or any other property. That being said the issue gets a little more tricky when it comes to government run property, with government run property I tend to come down on what I think is a reasonable position of if you are not required by law to be there then the individual government agencies can restrict gun possession provided there is not a superior law preventing that.. an example would be many State governments preempt local parks depts from passing rules prohibiting carry in a public park. >>>And one can drive as fast a she wants as long as there is no accident? Generally speaking I believe in enforcement of Reckless Driving Laws and less on arbitrarily defined laws. For the most part speed limits are less about safety and more about revenue generation for local government. Even under todays law if you are driving the speed limit and a cops believes that is unsafe for the road conditions you can be ticketed and even arrested. >>>One can sell outdated food as long as no client gets sick? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i8xwLWb0lLY https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=i8xwLWb0lLY Relevant Part at ~9:35
- phkahler 11y ago>> However if the property owner, in this case the school board, chooses on their own to disallow guns on their property then a person violating that would be guilty of criminal trespass. But who is the victim then? What was the damage? How does that compare to the case where they didn't make that rule?
- the_ancient 11y agoThe property owner is the victim. Property owners have the right to deny entry/use of their property for any reason or no reason at all. They can say "No one wearing blue shirts", or "No entry after 5pm" or any other rule they want to impose, if you violate that you have violated their property rights.
- superuser2 11y agoI don't think this works for you. Most "victimless crimes" have victims, you just don't believe they should count as victims, or the punishment isn't proportional. I suppose you could say not every instance actually has a victim, just some of them, but then should I get to walk if I shoot at you and miss? Copyright: IP owners who lose money, everyone who no longer benefits from new content because making it is economically unsustainable. Regulation: consumers who buy defective and dangerous products (particularly drugs), people who drink contaminated water and breathe contaminated air, people whose radio electronics won't work anymore because some asshole is jamming them, people whose retirement accounts evaporate on irresponsible trades or investment in fraudulent businesses, people who become suddenly homeless on the whims of their landlords, people who get hit by speeding cars, drunk drivers, cars without working brakes, cars that don't properly signal their presence and intentions. War on Drugs: people whose friends and family members become unreliable and/or dead because of their addictions. Tax fraud: people whose economic and medical situations get worse when government is underfunded.
- the_ancient 11y ago>>>Copyright: IP owners who lose money, everyone who no longer benefits from new content because making it is economically unsustainable. Setting aside the fact that I do not believe in the concept of IP. To the extent that the government grants such a privilege, there is a victim, the "owner" of the intellectual privilege. That person can raise their hand and say "I am a victim of Infringement on my government granted intellectual privilege" >>>Regulation: consumers who buy defective and dangerous products (particularly drugs), people who drink contaminated water and breathe contaminated air, people whose radio electronics won't work anymore because some asshole is jamming them, people whose retirement accounts evaporate on irresponsible trades or investment in fraudulent businesses, people who become suddenly homeless on the whims of their landlords, people who get hit by speeding cars, drunk drivers, cars without working brakes, cars that don't properly signal their presence and intentions. All of these are victims to some extent, I do not think you understand what the term victim means in this context. One does not have to be physically harmed to be a victim, you can be a victim of fraud, theft, negligence, these are all victims. >>>War on Drugs: people whose friends and family members become unreliable and/or dead because of their addictions. A person using drugs of their own free will can not be classified as a Victim, it is tragic yes but so is suicided, or countless other things. Family members are not being "victimized" by that. Further arresting a Drug abuser has been objectively proven to be about the worst thing you can do for them, and a sure fire way to turn a drug user into an abuser is to ruin their lives with criminal records and penalties. No Families are not "victims" when a family member uses drugs, any more than they are "victims" when a family member makes any other life choice that is poor. >>>Tax fraud: people whose economic and medical situations get worse when government is underfunded Setting aside the fact that I believe taxation to be theft, Taxation produces victims every day, every single taxpayer is a victim of unethical and immoral theft by government... Setting that aside no one is entitled to other peoples money, if a government program is underfunded that does not make a victim.
- fsloth 11y agoI fail to see what that has to do with a modern justice system. Crime can be personal, but law and justice are statistical, bureaucratic instruments that target societies, not individuals. They only produce as an accidental external factor occasional catharsis for the victim.
- clarkmoody 11y ago> paid debt to society Since society is not actually an entity that can be paid anything, it's not surprising that individuals want to treat ex-cons unfairly. I think we should scrap the notion of "paying your debt to society" altogether and instead focus on making victims whole. As it stands, victims of crime get minimal remuneration[1], and it varies by state. It's not the criminal who pays the victim, it's the taxpayer. And then the taxpayer gets to pay for the prison term as well. [1]: http://www.victimsofcrime.org/help-for-crime-victims/get-help-bulletins-for-crime-victims/crime-victim-compensation http://www.victimsofcrime.org/help-for-crime-victims/get-hel...
- bilbo0s 11y agoI'm a little confused by this ??? Why would you give the victim of, say, an assault... money ??? I thought the idea was to give that person justice ??? And for that reason, we put the perpetrator in a prison that, of course, we pay for. What exactly is wrong with that system ???
- the_ancient 11y agoThat is not justice, that is revenge. A base desire that civilized persons should attempt to overcome. A person should be in jail if they are proven to be a continuing danger to others. A person should not be put in a cage simply to give the victim an emotional release under the "Eye for an Eye" doctrine. Monetary compensation to victims is an attempt to make a person whole. Victims of all types of crime suffer actual damages such as medical bills, lost wages, damage to property. There is there are indirect damages for things like victim counseling. Often times it is simply not possible to fully make a person "whole" again after a crime, however monetary compensation is the best option we have today to ensure the victim can get the needed treatment, or aid they need to at-least move forward with their lives Locking persons in a cage does not help the victim, or the criminal. Prison should be used to separate persons from society to dangerous to be allowed to walk free... Nothing else.
- katbyte 11y ago>A person should be in jail if they are proven to be a continuing danger to others no. i'm sorry but just no. People are in prison because their actions have proven they are a danger to others and should only be released then they have PROVEN THEY ARE NOT a danger to others.
- milspec 11y agoIf the offender has only ever committed one crime, and they did so while a teen, then OK. Give them another chance, provided they have a workable budget that includes a non-criminal job. If the offender repeated the crime while being older than 25, then no. There is no realistic hope that the person will ever be non-harmful. Never let them free. (cases between those two extremes are questionable)
- abalashov 11y agoI would be extremely wary of making such cosmological, sweeping generalisations about anything. "Realistic hope that the person will ever be non-harmful" really depends on a gazillion other variables. And why start with a semantically negative presumption, anyway? A world of difference in attitude can be reaped from daring to ask whether a person might harm again, rather than if they will "ever be non-harmful".
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- the_ancient 11y agoSo you believe every crime after the age of 25 should come with a life sentence? Get in to a drunken fight at the bar on night... Life Shoplift a pack of gum.... Life WOW....
- milspec 11y agoYou missed the word "repeated". Also, some participants in drunken fights act in self-defense or as part of a fighting sport, and so would not be criminals. So it's actually like this: You reach 25. You assault somebody. You serve time in prison. (now a questionable case) We decide to give you a second chance. You feel no need to follow the law, and you enjoy assaulting people, so you do it again. OK, at this point we know what kind of person you are. You didn't just make a bad decision one day. Simply letting you out into society is pretty much the same as assaulting a random person, because that is clearly what you are going to do.
- icewater0 11y ago> regularly encounter people that use the "they are criminals" justification The inclination to enslave others is ingrained into certain strains of the human species and they will take them where it can find them.