2 ms·
See my other post; I actually think that a Monty Hall comparison argues in favor of an unbiased 1:2 guess, because of how the terms of the two problems differ.
by CamperBob2 11y ago
See my other post; I actually think that a Monty Hall comparison argues in favor of an unbiased 1:2 guess, because of how the terms of the two problems differ.
In the SB question, your odds of being asked the question are 1:1. You just don't know how many times you'll be asked. You didn't know the night before (and neither did the researchers), and you still don't know, even though the researchers now do.
In the MH game, you give the host some new information when you make your initial choice. He already knew what door not to open, but now he knows what door he must open, and the rules require him to communicate that to you. That's when you receive the new information (as you point out with the example of your mom walking into the room).
In the SB problem, you don't get any new information before the question is asked, including whether or not you're going to be put back to sleep. So the only answer you can rationally give is 1:2.
If the researchers used a d20 instead of a coin to determine how many times to wake you up, you could safely guess that any given awakening wasn't your first or your last. But you still can't give any answer about the number on the die, other than a random guess from 1-20. You need to store some information for later recall, and they're not letting you do that.