4 ms·
The fact is, there aren't three volunteers, there's only one. Upon awakening, she has no information she didn't have when she went to sleep, which at first se
by CamperBob2 11y ago
The fact is, there aren't three volunteers, there's only one. Upon awakening, she has no information she didn't have when she went to sleep, which at first seems to be an unassailable argument in favor of the "halfers."
To me, the problem with the "no new information" argument is that there's another popular paradox in which it also seems to apply, but fails spectacularly. In the Monty Hall paradox (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monty_Hall_problem https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Monty_Hall_problem), you know in advance that the host is going to open a door at random and offer you a chance to change your initial guess. You're aware that the host knows what's behind the doors. You know that no matter what door you pick, one of the remaining ones has a goat behind it. And you know that the omniscient host will pick that door. So what new information do you gain when the host does what you knew he was going to do?
One way to resolve the Monty Hall paradox is to rephrase it such that there are a million doors and the host opens all of the remaining ones except one. Of course it makes sense to switch doors in that scenario, since you knew that the host would avoid opening your initially-chosen door as well as the one with the car behind it. Your initial door has 1:1000000 odds of winning, while the only other closed door has odds of 1/2.
So if you could find a way to transform the Sleeping Beauty problem into a Monty Hall problem, that could be a good way to settle the argument in favor of the "thirders."
Or, if with some logical sleight-of-hand, you could show that SB is not isomorphic to MH, that could potentially be used to strengthen the no-new-information argument made by the "halfer" side. I'm leaning that way, because SB does not know upon awakening, and will not remember, whether the experiment will result in her being awakened twice. For all she knows, she's playing the same Monty Hall game for the second time. It's this lack of an unbroken timeline of conscious awareness that settles the question in favor of the halfers.
To answer the thirders' rebuttal that SB would lose money if she were gambling on the coin toss with any odds other than 1:3, I'd say that's a completely different experiment. We aren't being asked to speculate on the set of events behind multiple awakenings, just one in isolation. The lack-of-new-information argument carries the day. Any arguments that involve repetition, clones, or gambling fail because they are responding to a different question.
TL,DR: Don't gamble if the game involves erasing the players' memories. You will lose a lot of money in a hurry, even if your strategy is mathematically optimal.
- URSpider94 11y agoHere's an amplification that might clarify it. If you flip heads, I'll wake you up zero times. If you flip tails, I'll wake you up once. Now what's the probability that you flipped tails. 100%, right? Why? The coin still has a 50% chance of giving either heads or tails. Here's another -- if you flip heads, I'll wake you up once. If you flip tails, I'll wake you up a million times. When I wake you up, is it more likely that you flipped tails or heads, remembering that you don't know which day it is. You are right, by the way, that there is no new information -- the tendency to answer "50%" the night before is the logical error. You are conflating the odds of flipping heads or tails with the odds of WHETHER you flipped heads or tails in light of the known outcome (which is not 1:1 with flipping heads or tails). Also, if you believe in statistics, the right answer in the continuous case (infinite repeats) is also the right answer in the singular case (one repeat). Your point about "there aren't three volunteers, only one" is fallacious.
- CamperBob2 11y agoHere's an amplification that might clarify it. If you flip heads, I'll wake you up zero times. If you flip tails, I'll wake you up once. Now what's the probability that you flipped tails. 100%, right? Why? The coin still has a 50% chance of giving either heads or tails. I do like that, it's a strong argument. But it still relies on monkeying with the participant's awareness in a way that is likely to (or in this case, will) keep them from making the right decision over time. You use the term "known outcome," but there isn't a known outcome if you're dead or asleep forever. Your point about "there aren't three volunteers, only one" is fallacious. But so is treating it as any other problem (like gambling) that only converges on an answer after multiple trials. The strength of your argument is that it doesn't rely on answering a different question, just changing a parameter in the question that was asked. But it's an awfully important parameter. Implicit in the question is the premise that you will be alive/aware at some point in the future, so that you can be asked what you think. Edit: another way to rebut your particular argument is by sticking with the original terms of the problem, except that if the coin lands on heads, they shoot you after you answer. That doesn't help you answer the question.
- 11y ago