4 ms·
Doing a sensory deprivation experiment once gave me an OOBE. It was pretty wild, didn't have enough time to start doing research though. One of the experiments
by ChuckMcM 11y ago
Doing a sensory deprivation experiment once gave me an OOBE. It was pretty wild, didn't have enough time to start doing research though. One of the experiments I would run is have an assistant go into another room and write or draw something on a pad, then do your OOBE, go over to the room and read the pad, then come back into your body, wake up and tell them what they wrote (or reproduce it). That was a claim made by the Eckankar[1] people, back in the 70's, I wanted to test.
The interesting bit from this research is that it adds a bit of credence to the notion that you can at least perceive you are outside your body, given the right conditions. The question being then how you do this to yourself on demand without sticking an electrode into your head in order to do some research on it.
[1] http://www.eckankar.org/whatis.html http://www.eckankar.org/whatis.html
- zkhalique 11y agoYou can do this without paying an assistant. Just have a display show a random number in a room that changes every minute.
- declan 11y ago>That was a claim made by the Eckankar[1] people, back in the 70's, I wanted to test. I take it you were unable to reproduce any psychic claims! :) If you could, it would be a trivial way to win $1M: http://web.randi.org/the-million-dollar-challenge.html http://web.randi.org/the-million-dollar-challenge.html The fact that the James Randi challenge has existed (in one form or another) since 1964, and no psychic in over half a century has ever passed the challenge, well, that should speak volumes about psychic/paranormal/parapsychology claims.
- robertk 11y agoTo play devil's advocate, it could also indicate Randi is using a god of the gaps type play and psychics have given up knowing he won't part with the money.
- btilly 11y agoNope. He works with the psychic to agree on a test of what the psychic claims to be able to do, with low enough probability that you can't pass by chance. (I believe the threshold is somewhere below 1/million.) Doesn't matter what ability you think you have. A test can be set up and agreed to. A number of psychics have wound up concluding that their abilities won't work under the influence of unbelievers. But nobody that I know of has complained that Randi was not willing to set up a fair test.
- aussieindian 11y ago>> But nobody that I know of has complained that Randi was not willing to set up a fair test. I remember reading about how people who claimed that Randi would not test them. ref : 1. http://dailygrail.com/features/the-myth-of-james-randis-million-dollar-challenge http://dailygrail.com/features/the-myth-of-james-randis-mill... 2. https://weilerpsiblog.wordpress.com/randis-million-dollar-challenge/ https://weilerpsiblog.wordpress.com/randis-million-dollar-ch... I guess its his test, his rules.. pity rational people mischarecterise it as Scientific. In the words of Chris Carter, author of Parapsychology and the Skeptics: If Randi were genuinely interested in testing unusual claims, then he would also not insist upon odds of at least one million to one against chance for the results. Anyone familiar with scientific studies will be aware that experimental results against chance of say, 800,000 to one would be considered extraordinary; but results this high would be, according to Randi, a “failure.”
- mrob 11y agoDifferent disciplines accept different probabilities of Type I error. 8000000 to one against would not be considered worth reporting in particle physics. Any confirmed supernatural phenomenon would be a change in our understanding of the universe more dramatic than any particle physical discovery, so really it should be held to even stricter standards. Randi is being generous.
- seren 11y agoTo be fair most people who claims to have psychic power also claim that, even if not perfect, have a statically significant success rate. I mean if you really had a psychic power that worked 1 in 800,000 trials, a single life wouldn't be long enough to discover it. By comparison, we only live about 30,000 days. I would not hire a water diviner finding water with such low success rate.
- estefan 11y agoRobert Monroe wrote 3 books on OOBEs. He used to try to correlate his experiences out of body with things in the real world. He did one set of tests several times. His wife put a number of nails in a locked box next to his bed and he'd put his phantom hand inside and try feel the number that were inside. He never got it right enough to be statistically significant. He also tried something similar with an object downstairs, but he said he'd have such weird experiences even going downstairs OOB that repeated tests were impossible. He suggested the process of trying to test something skewed the results or made his subconscious resist in someway. On the other hand there were one or two things that were very unusual, specific events that correlated very strongly, so it's tricky to discount the phenomenon as completely fabricated. I think that whether they're objectively true experiences or not, if you could get deeper into your subconscious and look around it'd be fascinating.