4 ms·
Total lifetime earnings is a great way to measure success, from the perspective of how the 7 billion people on this planet, minus you, value your work. If you
by logfromblammo 11y ago
Total lifetime earnings is a great way to measure success, from the perspective of how the 7 billion people on this planet, minus you, value your work. If you value your own work differently, that's fine, but yours will be the minority opinion.
Overall low career pay to work difficulty ratio in comparison to other fields is a clear signal for young people to not pursue that option as a career. Despite the trope about falling education standards, the young people entering college and choosing their concentrations are not entirely stupid. They know that they won't get a job in the art field with that degree in art history. But they also know they won't get a job in the biology field with a biology degree, so they might as well study whatever they like, to qualify for that tier of mediocre jobs that just requires any 4-year degree.
I elected to stop at the bachelor's degree, because I could already tell that continuing beyond that in academia was very obviously not worth it. It wasn't just diminishing returns. After considering the money value of time, it was a negative return.
I am astonished at the huge number of supposedly smart people who will continue to suffer from institutional maltreatment for decades, willingly and without complaint, because they have somehow been brainwashed into thinking that they are lucky to have the opportunity to be worked like dogs without external recognition or remuneration.
Just don't do it. Get a bachelor's degree and go to work. If you wanted to be a doctor or lawyer, be a nurse or paralegal instead. Trade up later, if you can earn enough by working to pay for the extra degree, and you like doing that kind of work. My personal opinion is that nobody should be trying to pursue advanced degrees without ever doing any work in the real world first. When academia has to get its candidates to come back from the real world, rather than sinking its hooks into naive and gullible fresh graduates, a lot of the obvious problems would fix themselves.
Univ: Hey there, chief, how about you come back to school for a rewarding career in academia?
Dude: I have a job now. I can buy stuff like *actual* furniture and food with *nutrition and flavor*.
Univ: No worries. We'll give you a living stipend of $18000!
Dude: That is literally less than what my neighbor gets on welfare.
Univ: Does your neighbor get to work with prestigious professors on cutting edge research?
Dude: No. Is that what I'd be doing?
Univ: Yes! A little. And also doing most of the grunt work for the undergrad classes.
Dude: But after I finish, I would get to be one of those professors, right?
Univ: Welllllll.... possibly. You'd be an adjunct for a while. Maybe forever. [0]
Univ: It wouldn't be prestigious if we just hired everybody!
Dude: But they get paid well?
Univ: Our associate profs get paid a whopping $75000 per year! Full profs get $95000! [1]
Dude: So less than someone with a bachelor's degree in the right field [2], or public servants in certain places [3].
Dude: And that's if I even get a tenure-track job in the first place.
Univ: Discounted membership at the university athletic center?
Dude: Get lost.
[0] http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/04/the-adjunct-professor-crisis/361336/ http://www.theatlantic.com/business/archive/2014/04/the-adju...
[1] https://www.higheredjobs.com/salary/salaryDisplay.cfm?SurveyID=24 https://www.higheredjobs.com/salary/salaryDisplay.cfm?Survey...
[2] http://www.payscale.com/college-salary-report-2014/majors-that-pay-you-back http://www.payscale.com/college-salary-report-2014/majors-th...
[3] http://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes333051.htm http://www.bls.gov/oes/current/oes333051.htm
- ska 11y agoTotal lifetime earnings is a great way to measure success, from the perspective of how the 7 billion people on this planet, minus you, value your work. If you value your own work differently, that's fine, but yours will be the minority opinion. No, that approach largely misses the point. I agree with you about the problem of young people not knowing what they are getting into, and entirely agree that people should do other work before committing to a lot of education (the "real world" distinction is false). In fact the first advice I would give almost anyone considering graduate school is: do something else first. But lifetime earnings is a terrible metric for success. It's a pretty good metric for what other people are willing to pay for your time, sure. And it absolutely is something you should think about in how you structure your life. And it absolutely is something a lot of young people do not think about enough. Fundamentally, money is a tool that constrains the choices you have. For most people, acquiring it also constrains the choices you have. These things are unavoidably in some tension. Most people I know would be happy to get paid more for what they are currently doing. Far fewer would be nearly as happy to get paid significantly more for the types of significant changes it would make in their lives, considering only the real options they actually have. Most, if not all, of the people I know who are happiest with how things have worked out are not on track to anywhere near their maximum possible lifetime earnings. Several people I know who are near that track are miserable (not all, by any means). The reason for this is that most people will have or can make the opportunity at some time in their lives to earn more money in exchange for things like: much more responsibility, much more stress, much less "free" time, much more travel, much less interesting or rewarding work, etc. The reason this comes up so often is that one of the the things the 7 billion people on this planet often are willing to pay your for is to do stuff that they would really rather not have to, things that are fairly objectively not much fun. If you can find fulfillment in it, all the power too you. Trying to measure success this way ignores most of what is fundamentally important in a life. You're far better off looking at how you've managed to balance your own goals and your ability to make those happen. It can be hard when you are twenty-two and trying to figure this stuff out, but one part of growing up is realizing that there isn't any universal yardstick or best path, and you have to work out your own path.
- hunterloftis 11y ago