5 ms·
We are currently completely rewriting the entire frontend of SMC using React.js, Flux, and RethinkDB ... ... I'm living on credit cards Are you sure a full re
by pavlov 11y ago
We are currently completely rewriting the entire frontend of SMC using React.js, Flux, and RethinkDB ...
... I'm living on credit cards
Are you sure a full rewrite of the front-end is a priority at this point?
I've been there. When your business is going down, it's easy to believe that a technically beautiful v2.0 is going to save the day. It didn't do anything for my business though, and in retrospect I should have spent the year on something else.
- edtechdev 11y agoThis holds back so many projects - how expensive hosting web applications eventually becomes. I'm hoping for more decentralized options to eventually emerge (like IPFS, etc.), but in the meantime, I'd probably recommend to this guy to perhaps offer a paid app version, or just charge for accounts on his site. Or else try a kickstarter or indiegogo campaign.
- strayptr 11y agoHow expensive would an application like this be? I don't know much about this, but I'd like to learn. What's an algorithm for figuring out a pretty good guess of any random application's hosting costs? Also, is there a way to figure out how large the expenses could become over time? Is there some way to relate number of users to cost? There's no upper bound for how much money one could spend, but let's use the midpoint between "extremely frugal" and "money isn't really a concern."
- williamstein 11y agoHosting on GCE costs about $1700/month right now, and at this moment we have $490/month in recurring revenue (we have 56 subscribers to various plans). I've put much work into making SMC more efficient, in order to bring the hosting price down, but there are limits. The reason it costs this much are: (1) there are often about 500 users signed in, every user is using at least one Linux account, and what users do is often very computationally and memory intensive (mathematics, number crunching, etc.), (2) I snapshot and backup all files both to Google Cloud Storage and also copy backups offsite. Doing offsite backups mainly costs bandwidth -- I spent about $20 in the last 3 days on downloading offsite backups of user data (to a USB drive on my desk). (3) In addition to compute nodes, there are database and web servers, which are redundant so that two can go down and things still work; this is very important since teachers often give lectures from SageMathCloud or run computers labs, so downtime is very bad. (4) I also snapshot all the disks images regular, which costs more, but reduces the chances of data loss. I care that users don't lose their data in case of a disaster (hackers or lightning striking Google four times), which just makes things cost more.
- sylvinus 11y agoFrom what you describe, shouldn't pricing be higher if users are costing you so much?
- aaronbrethorst 11y agoHow important is your tool to your users? teachers often give lectures from SageMathCloud or run computers labs OK, sounds important. I care that users don't lose their data in case of a disaster (hackers or lightning striking Google four times), which just makes things cost more. And it sounds like you care. So, how much do you charge for such an important tool? we have $490/month in recurring revenue (we have 56 subscribers to various plans) $8.75/month. Try tacking on an extra zero to all of your plans. Or, better yet, tack on an extra zero and ALSO let your customers decide whether or not they care about things like backups. I don't want to sound like an asshole, but your business is never going to succeed if you keep going down this path. And to be clear: I want to see you succeed. Here are a few things by patio11 you should go read right now: http://www.kalzumeus.com/2014/04/03/fantasy-tarsnap/ http://www.kalzumeus.com/2014/04/03/fantasy-tarsnap/ https://training.kalzumeus.com/newsletters/archive/saas_pricing https://training.kalzumeus.com/newsletters/archive/saas_pric... http://www.kalzumeus.com/2012/08/13/doubling-saas-revenue/ http://www.kalzumeus.com/2012/08/13/doubling-saas-revenue/
- vonklaus 11y agoWhat do you mean 56 subscribers, 500 people are using the app concurrently? Are the rest unpaid subscriptions? Or do the subscribers have numerous users?
- williamstein 11y agoAt this moment there are 585 people connected to SMC (a bit higher than usual due to Hacker New effect), and most are using it for free. We only introduced a fully automated paid plan about 10 days ago, and many of our sign-ups have been in the last week. Paying customers get enhanced support, the ability to upgrade project quotas, and can ask (it's not yet automated) to have projects moved to members-only servers. The members-only servers have an order of magnitude less users on them. There were also until recently obstructions to charging users due to IP and other issues involving University of Washington (my employer).
- mattzito 11y ago> This holds back so many projects - how expensive hosting web applications eventually becomes. Hosting web applications costs a fraction of what it did 5-10 years ago, both in terms of straight costs as well as operational expenses.
- sanderjd 11y agoI think what you said and what the parent comment said are both entirely true.
- curun1r 11y agoThe interesting thing, to me, is not the overall cost of hosting, but the new ways that we can host. I've got a current project that I'm working on. I have no idea how successful it will be and I'm not interested in putting a ton of my own money at risk to see if it will be successful. But using a model where I have zero of my own servers (Lambda, API Gateway, Static hosting) means my fixed costs are under $20/mo and my variable costs scale with usage. All I need to do is ensure that my per-user monetization is higher than my per-user cost and my application scales up without any effort on my part. In the era of hosted servers, capacity planning and scale out took a ton of my time and energy on projects like this. And while I might end up paying a bit less in the long run if I followed the same methodology today, not having to worry about that kind of stuff and being able to focus solely on the application is really nice.
- paulproteus 11y agoThis sort of thing would make a great Sandstorm app, for what it's worth. See https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10147774 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=10147774 for more about that.
- phatbyte 11y agox1000 this.
- dkersten 11y agoThis sounds depressingly familiar to me too!
- platz 11y agoThe goal appears to be to appeal to developers to entice them to contribute; not so much the end-users - although one could argue whether this is the correct business goal?
- williamstein 11y agoI also found that further development on SageMathCloud was becoming too slow and frustrating for me, even though I knew the system extremely well (certain important things turned out to be very hard using the original approach). In order to implement the features a lot of users demanded, it was necessary to use a better approach. It is starting to pay off.
- mbesto 11y agoAgreed. The author states: > There are much better approaches now, which are critical to dramatically improving the user experience with SMC, and also growing the developer base. I seriously urge William to, at the very least, survey developers before making this conclusion. I would expect something like "we spoke to 500 developers and at least 60% of them would use the application if it had a more robust dev stack". I find it amazing that extremely analytical and rational people (including myself!) tend to make generalized conclusions without informed data.
- pavlov 11y agoIt can be easy to justify uninformed decisions with vision. Did Steve Jobs ask people what they want? How about Henry Ford, who supposedly said that "they'd just ask for faster horses"? I don't love data myself either. It feels better to be right by divine vision, although it sure doesn't happen that often.
- davnicwil 11y agoHaving data is fine, but even the richest dataset is wide open to misinterpretation. This is even more true when the data is a snapshot of a compression of human opinion and feelings. The interpretation of information collected from a survey such as '60% of developers I asked say..', even assuming it's statistically valid and reasonably accurate (which is not trivial to achieve), still involves a lot of assumption, intuition, and frankly guesswork about the real problems and facts of the situation. It might provide slightly more of a hint towards the facts than just blindly following a strategy based on vision alone, and there are many success stories of data-driven approaches that vastly outperform the predictions of human 'experts', but implicitly trusting that this will always be the case is probably unwise. I'm for data-driven decision making in general, just saying that it's never a magic bullet and is often not even an advantage (could indeed be the opposite) if done naively.
- dantiberian 11y agoAs an outsider, here is my perspective on a number of things you could do: Segment your users into plans. Do some user research on the archetypes and Jobs To Be Done that different people are using your product for. Segment features according to this and charge accordingly. For example all of the high availability, redundant web servers and snapshotting should go only on the paid plans. You can make the reasonable assumption that if people aren't paying for your service then they don't value their data very highly, so why should you? Some rough plans I can imagine would be: Undergraduate, Graduate, Professor. These people have different needs, desires, and fears; cater to them. This might be a hard one, but dropping the free plan will make you cashflow positive immediately. For people who can't/won't pay, you can provide good instructions on how to set up the VM if people don't want to pay. Give people 30 days notice, and give them benefits for signing up, e.g. 20% discount for life of their account. Look at partnering with teaching institutions that are using your software. Offer them a discount on a class purchase of accounts, or sell them support running the VM on their own infrastructure (perhaps integrating with Moodle or their auth system for an additional fee?). Look at how people get value from SMC, your costs scale linearly with usage, so it may be good to scale your prices too. One option could be to replace the free tier with a pay-as-you-go tier where people pre-pay for x hours/month, and higher tiers get unlimited usage. On the homepage, remove the section about grants received as it sounds like that is no longer the case. Make the homepage a lot nicer and present the benefits of SMC much more clearly. As others have said, it's not clear at all what plans are available or what differentiates them until you put in a payment card. This is not a compelling prospect.
- williamstein 11y agoMany thanks for your feedback and for carefully looking over the site! I really appreciate it.