4 ms·
In context the Trojan part of the title is: Google’s smart home Trojan horse. It's a Trojan horse because it is their way of rolling out "connected-home" devic
by nl 11y ago
In context the Trojan part of the title is: Google’s smart home Trojan horse.
It's a Trojan horse because it is their way of rolling out "connected-home" devices without people having to decide to "move to a connected home". That's what all the non-enabled sensors and hardware are for.
It's a smart play on Google's part, and Ars is correct to note it.
It doesn't mean it is malicious in anyway.
- dragonwriter 11y agoSmart or connected home stuff has never been about moving to such a home, its always been ways to enhance an existing home, so its bizarre to describe what you put out as unusual in anyway. And, "Trojan horse" always implies malicious deception; its an inappropriate metaphor for any other intended message. So, I'd say this is doubly misguided.
- nl 11y ago>Smart or connected home stuff has never been about moving to such a home, its always been ways to enhance an existing home, so its bizarre to describe what you put out as unusual in anyway. [0] would disagree: "more elaborate systems could easily reach up to $1000 if you have a lot of hardware to install and don't shoot for the cheapest units you can get. Putting in a smart switch in three bedrooms, a living room and a kitchen can be $200-250 by itself, and that assumes a fairly spartan set up and excludes any power outlet installations. Be sure to tally up all of the parts you'll need before you start buying anything." >"Trojan horse" always implies malicious deception; its an inappropriate metaphor for any other intended message. It's commonly used in this way. [1][2][3] are good examples. [0] http://lifehacker.com/how-can-i-get-started-with-home-automation-510246491 http://lifehacker.com/how-can-i-get-started-with-home-automa... [1] http://www.taniaellis.com/blog/the-trojan-horse-changing-business-from-within/ http://www.taniaellis.com/blog/the-trojan-horse-changing-bus... [2] http://www.huffingtonpost.com/seth-schachner/a-trojan-horse-called-tidal_b_7163438.html http://www.huffingtonpost.com/seth-schachner/a-trojan-horse-... [3] http://www.techrepublic.com/article/microsofts-trojan-horse-strategy-to-rule-the-world/ http://www.techrepublic.com/article/microsofts-trojan-horse-...
- briandear 11y agoIt also doesn't mean it's not malicious. Google doesn't have the best track record on privacy. Spend some time on their advertising platforms and you can see just how deep they go. Full text email scanning with the ability to advertise to people not just in the content of their emails, but based on the content of their recipient's emails. They've cooperated on frequent occasions with warrant-less surveillance requests. Google makes some nice products but they have long since jumped the Don't be Evil shark. They don't make all of these "free" web products for nothing. It's all around one singular purpose: to gather information that they can sell about you. No matter how people want to frame it, Google is an advertising company. Buying a router from an advertising company.. Have fun with that. What is the motivation for Google to suddenly care about routers? Is that really a pain point that's profitable to solve? Not really, unless you have a long term plan to leverage that into something that serves the core business which is advertising.
- simoncion 11y ago> They've cooperated on frequent occasions with warrant-less surveillance requests. If you're not talking about NSLs, please provide a reliable citation for this claim. :) Every company that receives an NSL that passes the laugh test is more-or-less obligated to comply with it. It's my understanding that Google fights as hard as they legally can to protect the private information of their users. Fun fact: Did you know that from 1986 until very, very recently the law of the land in the US was that emails stored on third-party servers for longer than 180 days were considered abandoned and could be retrieved -in their entirety- by law enforcement with nothing more than what is effectively a note that declared that the information was relevant to a law enforcement investigation? It's true! [0] [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_Communications_Privacy_Act#Criticism https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Electronic_Communications_Priv... but also http://www.cnet.com/news/doj-we-dont-need-warrants-for-e-mail-facebook-chats/ http://www.cnet.com/news/doj-we-dont-need-warrants-for-e-mai...
- zaroth 11y agoWhat do you mean until recently?