6 ms·
This whole thing was triggered at opening. Why does the market even close these days? There is "after hours" trading going on for some people. Why shouldn't the
by phkahler 11y ago
This whole thing was triggered at opening. Why does the market even close these days? There is "after hours" trading going on for some people. Why shouldn't the computers be running 24/7? Is there some batch stuff that goes on after close? I've seen cases where transactions were unwound, but aren't we nearing real-time across the board?
- jperras 11y agoWouldn't you like to sleep, at some point?
- aianus 11y agoBanks can (and already do) have multiple shifts. I used to work for a forex broker (forex is 24h a day) and we had offices in different timezones (Toronto, New York, London, Singapore) so we would always have trader coverage without requiring night shifts.
- branchless 11y agoAnd you had full 3rd level knowledge of all issues in all regions? Or key people in key regions who got woke up a lot? They should run these things for an hour a day 4 days a week. It's just a game, we don't need this.
- aianus 11y agoYou don't have to participate. But I don't see how it's your business if people want to trade equities 24h a day any more than if people want to open a 24h McDonald's.
- branchless 11y agoIt's not "my business" but it's my opinion that tech has enabled far more finance business to occur and that this is not "a good thing". Finance needs to be a means to an end not the end in and of itself.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoAdding more trading hours to the day doesn't serve a productive purpose.
- monochromatic 11y ago"I don't see a reason for this, so you shouldn't be allowed to do it." Not very good reasoning. It's not exactly on point, but I'm reminded of a quotation from G. K. Chesterton: > In the matter of reforming things, as distinct from deforming them, there is one plain and simple principle; a principle which will probably be called a paradox. There exists in such a case a certain institution or law; let us say, for the sake of simplicity, a fence or gate erected across a road. The more modern type of reformer goes gaily up to it and says, “I don’t see the use of this; let us clear it away.” To which the more intelligent type of reformer will do well to answer: “If you don’t see the use of it, I certainly won’t let you clear it away. Go away and think. Then, when you can come back and tell me that you do see the use of it, I may allow you to destroy it.”
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI'm not saying you shouldn't be allowed to, I'm saying that even if it was permitted, it wouldn't be productive. I mean, this is Hacker News. We discuss all day about what should or shouldn't be done. If you want action, go out and do it. Otherwise, we're just armchairing all of this.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- aianus 11y ago> Adding more trading hours to the day doesn't serve a productive purpose. Sure it does. Why should Chinese investors only be able to trade US equities from 9:30pm to 4:00am?
- ant6n 11y agoI worked late night that Sunday, slept through the whole thing on Monday :( They should start the trading day later, so I can sleep longer.
- ryanlol 11y agoCompanies don't sleep, individual traders are fucked anyway.
- dsjoerg 11y agoContinuous availability is good, but we also want markets to connect buyers and sellers of various sizes as efficiently as possible. Efficient not in the CS sense, but in the sense of paying the middlemen as little as possible. Discrete markets are, under certain circumstances, more efficient at connecting buyers and sellers than continuous markets. It's similar to how an eBay auction is a more efficient way to get the best price for your rare item rather than having a continuously open market where you have to keep deciding whether or not to accept people's lowball bids.
- icebraining 11y agoYet eBay has Buy It Now, because sometimes it's better for both the buyer and the seller to agree on a potentially lower/higher price than having to wait for the end of the auction. Why do we want efficient transactions? If it's for the benefit of the buyers and sellers, why shouldn't they be given the choice? It's as if we were saying that the stock market is for less sophisticated users than eBay!
- cma 11y agoOn the market you buy a fungible asset, so the auction can be batched up between multiple buyers and sellers. On eBay you can't batch the things sellers are selling because a key part of what buyers are supposed to be doing is things like checking an individual seller's feedback and weighing whether he low price is worth risking it, or carefully reading the description to make sure you aren't buying a cardboard cutout picture of the product, a product box, or a car that was sawed in half and photographed so that it could be sold to two people instead of one. Plus a lot of the products are used and have one-off descriptions of flaws. EBay doesn't have the same kind of clearing houses and broker-dealer regulations that would make sold items be anything like stock shares, even if they were all brand new and retail packaged.
- minimax 11y agoThe US equity index futures opened for trading (as usual) at 5pm Chicago time on Sunday night. Two of the biggest US equity exchanges (NASDAQ and Arca) start trading in a pre-market session at 4am NYC time. The futures hit their own limit down band before the cash open, and I don't think the single-stock circuit breaker rules apply during the pre-market session for equities. There was a ton of volume in both the futures and the pre-market, but it was still dwarfed by all the activity at and just after the open. Most people just don't want to trade until other people are trading, so there's this sort of feedback loop that drives volume to the open.
- ISL 11y agoI've often wondered the same. It is perhaps a calming influence. Companies can release results after the close, and everyone gets to think on it overnight. In a logarithmic sense, the market's 33% uptime is quite close to 100%, and it allows for a rhythm, maintenance, and reflection that would be lost to continuous trading. Most animals sleep, and we've even evolved the seven day week. Perhaps it's a good thing. If you take the opposite view, someone will always trade with you after hours at the right price.
- nickff 11y agoBut deadlines also rush people, often into a frenzy (I.e. Auctions); and the uncertainty of what will happen overnight could cause crashes to be more severe. It may be that leaving markets open overnight would calm trading all day. I am not sure either way, but it seems that 24/7 trading would be worth a try.
- codexon 11y agoThere are very few people trading after/pre market hours. And those after/pre market hours are only 4-6 hours.
- carbocation 11y agoRegular hours for the NYSE are 9:30am-4:00pm (6.5 hours). 4-6 hours in that context is quite significant.
- codexon 11y agoIt is still very far from 24 hours.
- joshu 11y agoBecause being open (availability) spreads the same amount of liquidity across the clock. This decreases the available liquidity at any moment and thus generally increases volatility A another solution would be a single auction a day, and everyone would get more fair but less timely trades. And a lot of the goofus mechanics around high speed continuous auction would disappear. It is a trade off.
- cm2187 11y agoThe longer the markets stay open, the less liquidity you have. If you want stable and meaningful prices, having limited market hours is probably helping.
- Bootvis 11y agoI don't see why this is down-voted as this is true and a disadvantage of having longer hours. The problem is already somewhat apparent: During the trading day the volume changes and a lower volume increases price impact. It seems logical that longer days spread out the volume even more, thus increasing price impact of orders.
- branchless 11y agoDon't say that. Do I want to have to loose my opportunity to free up memory with a daily bounce? Do I want to have to support this stuff for even more hours? No!!!
- BurningFrog 11y agoWhen the system is open, sub millisecond performance is essential for the market to function properly. And then you obviously close it for 63000000 ms each day.
- uxcn 11y agoLargely, it's legacy in the United States. When human specialists were in control of the book for a stock, the market opened at 9:30, and closed at 16:00. It probably hasn't changed for nearly a century. More algorithms are trading around the clock though, since markets are more interconnected than ever. To trade effectively, you need to be more aware of what has happened since market close as well. More explicitly, instruments have global presences. Running and maintaining systems, and trading 24/7 would be a major shift for a lot of institutions though. So, my guess is that it once an ATS can get approval to start trading continuously, outside human hours, the rest (including exchanges) will need to adapt.
- anonu 11y agoCurrent trading hours on the NYSE were last changed in 1985 when they were 10am to 4pm. http://www.marketwatch.com/story/a-brief-history-of-trading-hours-on-wall-street-2015-05-29 http://www.marketwatch.com/story/a-brief-history-of-trading-...
- minimax 11y agoThe NYSE is only one of 11 registered US equity exchanges. There are other exchanges that open earlier and close later (for example the NYSE owned Arca exchange trades from 4am to 8pm Eastern).
- itchyouch 11y agoAnother oft looked over featuer of the markets is price discovery. By compressing when all the participants participate, it allows all the buyers and sellers to come to an agreement on price with the most information participating. At least that's the theory. When looking at off-hours trading data, differences in opinion cause wild swings that then normalize during the 9:30-4 window. Technically, there's no reason that the markets can't participate 24/7, but the Nasdaq operates from 4a to 8p, and the crash that occurs at 9:30 still occurred despite markets being available for participation between 4a to 9:30a.
- joshdick 11y agoIf you're going to question market hours, you should ask why the market is open for so long. Why not just have one big print a day? There's not actually so much new information coming out throughout the day that the market needs to update prices on a sub-second basis for hours and hours every workday.