3 ms·
Me: Do you believe it is literally as simple as calories in calories out, for all people equally? You: Yes, it factually has to be that simple, for all creatur
by mistermann 11y ago
Me: Do you believe it is literally as simple as calories in calories out, for all people equally?
You: Yes, it factually has to be that simple, for all creatures, there is no possible other way. It is extremely simple science and logic.
And then you proceed to point out several items (that I agree with) showing that calories in / calories out doesn't fully describe the complexity.
In your "If you put in 3 gallons per day, and burn 4 gallons per day" analogy, the devil is encapsulated within "burn", in that the fuel efficiency of the car can vary - therefore while the energy going in is a constant, the energy being burned will vary. And additionally when dealing with humans, ability to absorb energy from fuel in also varies (many calories come out as waste, how many varies by individual.)
- grecy 11y ago> then you proceed to point out several items (that I agree with) showing that calories in / calories out doesn't fully describe the complexity. That's because for 99.999% of people to lose weight, they don't need to understand / deal with anything more complex than calories in / calories out. When your grandma wants to use a computer, she doesn't need to understand interrupts and CPU instruction sets anymore than a 3 year old needs to understand HTTP and TCP/IP to surf the web. It really is this simple. Figure out how many calories you should be eating daily to maintain based on your height, weight, age, sex and activity level. (And let's be perfectly honest here, for anyone that's obese or higher, it's an ungodly amount of calories per day - so many that it would be very difficult for anyone to eat that many calories per day without eating massive amounts of fat (fried food) and sugar (soda). So cut out just soda for most people and that's enough) Eat 200-300 less than that per day, for 3 months, and do a tiny bit more exercise than you normally do - and by tiny bit for someone that does nothing, that means walk an extra hundred yards to your car daily, nothing more. No running on the treadmill, no caring about carbs vs. fat vs. protein. Hell, if you stay 200-300 under what you require, it doesn't even matter if you still eat fast food like you used to. After 3 months if you have not lost weight, cut down another 200-300 per day, and continue for another 3 months. Repeat. You will lose weight, it can not be any other way, and the "complexities" mentioned above need not be considered, because they over complicate the issue.
- leshow 11y agothank you. said it better than I would've
- mistermann 11y agoI have trouble reconciling this with my personal experiences - I did keto for several months and lost about 25 pound until I hit a plateau that I couldn't get past after trying for over two weeks, eating the same diet as before, and I know with certainty I was WELL below my maintenance caloric intake. > You will lose weight, it can not be any other way I wonder if maybe the logical impossibility people are having trouble with is maybe from not differentiating between calories consumed and calories absorbed?
- grecy 11y ago> I hit a plateau that I couldn't get past after trying for over two weeks 2 weeks? 2 weeks? We're talking about changing your eating and exercise habbits for the rest of your life. Two weeks is such a tiny drop in the bucket it's hard to even measure it, and likely too many things were in flux to have settled down. Continue for 3 months. You will lose weight. > I wonder if maybe the logical impossibility people are having trouble with is maybe from not differentiating between calories consumed and calories absorbed? It makes no difference, because you can't absorb more than you ate. Don't think about how much your body is absorbing, because it's too hard to measure and do anything about. Think and focus on the thing you can impact - how much you eat. You are worrying about what kind of efficiency your car is getting, when all you need to care about is to stop putting so much damn gas in every day because the tank keeps overflowing. When the tank is overflowing each and every day, put in less gas!!!!
- mistermann 11y ago> We're talking about changing your eating and exercise habbits for the rest of your life. Two weeks is such a tiny drop in the bucket it's hard to even measure it, and likely too many things were in flux to have settled down. I had already hit my target so didn't mind quitting. The interesting part of the conversation to me is the plateau itself - according to many people, all people and especially individuals are the same, calories in minus exercise equals weight gained (or lost), there is no such thing as flux, every day is exactly the same, literally the only variable is your weight, and that hardly changes at all day to day. Yet, myself and millions of other people do in fact hit a plateau with no noteworthy change in diet or exercise. I'm just having a bit of fun seeing the variety of ways people twist logic and dance around questions related to this phenomenon while still maintaining this hardline calories in calories out stance. :) > It makes no difference, because you can't absorb more than you ate. Correct. However, you can absorb less than you eat! Eat 2000 calories, absorb 1500, poop out the rest, gee, I wonder if that might have any effect on weight loss?