82 ms·
> Diet and exercise is actually very well understood, and the same thing will 'work' for everybody. > just an aside, there is no 'ultra efficiency mode' you co
by mistermann 11y ago
> Diet and exercise is actually very well understood, and the same thing will 'work' for everybody.
> just an aside, there is no 'ultra efficiency mode' you comment here:
Do you genuinely believe that metabolism doesn't vary across individuals, or for an individual over time? Do you think the bodies of all individuals have precisely the same ability to both absorb calories from ingested food, as well as produce motion with the exact same efficiency? Do you believe enzymes present in the digestive system have absolutely no effect whatsoever on the calories in / calories out calculations? Do you think every calorie you put into your body is converted into energy?
- mikekchar 11y ago1 kg of fat is about 7700 calories. So if you are in deficit by 1100 calories per day, then you should lose about 1 kg of fat. Assuming that you have a base metabolism of 2000 calories per day (average for a male of average size), and say you did an hour of moderate aerobic exercise (like jogging) every day (600 calories per day), the with a diet of 1500 calories, you should find yourself losing about 1kg a week on average. If you are not losing any weight with the above, then the potential explanations are: - You are in ultra efficiency mode: In other words, you are burning only 900 calories a day. - You are not running an hour a day. - You are not eating 1500 calories a day. Let's say you are 70 kg. It takes 1 calorie of energy to raise 1 kg of water by 1 degree. You are roughly 15 degrees above ambient temperature. Thus it takes 1050 calories to raise your temperature from ambient to body temperature. It is highly unlikely that your body will be able to maintain body temperature for an entire day on 900 calories. Thus, the only other explanation are the other two.
- Evgeny 11y agoDo you genuinely believe that metabolism doesn't vary across individuals, or for an individual over time? It differs a bit. Therefore, the problem is to find out a particular individual's calorie requirements, which is achieved by carefully tracking calories and weight. I.e. if the weight is stable, we found this person's calorie requirements. Do you think the bodies of all individuals have precisely the same ability to both absorb calories from ingested food, as well as produce motion with the exact same efficiency? For weight loss purposes it is not so important. There is a top limit on energy to be absorbed, i.e 9 cal from a gram of fat. If a person only absorbs 8, good for him, but there is no way he will absorb 10. Do you believe enzymes present in the digestive system have absolutely no effect whatsoever on the calories in / calories out calculations? Again, there is a hard limit on how many calories can be extracted from a unit of food. Do you think every calorie you put into your body is converted into energy? For the purpose of weight loss, not so important. You digest only half of what you put in your body - good news, you can eat more and still lose weight. You digest everything - also no big deal. It's just that you cannot magically eat 1g of fat and suddednly gain 100g bodyweight from it.
- mistermann 11y agoYou did a fairly decent job of discrediting your "the same thing will 'work' for everybody" statement. "top limit on energy to be absorbed" is one of those interesting statements that sounds like an answer and proof of something, but actually isn't relevant and is a dodge of the question I actually asked. Of course there's an upper limit to what calories can be absorbed from food, you can't consume that which literally isn't there - the question is, is is the caloric content that is actually extracted the same for all people (which is a subset of the question does the same thing work for everybody).
- Evgeny 11y agoYou did a fairly decent job of discrediting your "the same thing will 'work' for everybody" statement. My "same thing works for everybody" is, in other words, "every person has a number of calories N, eating under which he will lose weight". I think I stayed pretty consistent. And yes, N may vary over time, but it still exists. the question is, is is the caloric content that is actually extracted the same for all people I can only restate that yes, it is different and no, it is not very important if our goal is weight loss. Suppose I extract 1500 calories from a meal, and you 1800 calories from the same meal. But the "thing that works for everyone" remains: you track your calories and weight, I track mine, maybe my weight is stable at 2000 calories per day, yours at 1700 calories per day. Then we just respectively start lowering our intake until we reach the desired rate of weight loss. Algorithm remains the same, we just plug in our own numbers. which is a subset of the question does the same thing work for everybody No, I can't see relevance. For lack of better example, all homes are different, some may have only rectangular rooms, some have oddly shaped rooms etc. So kind of "everyone is different". And still, anyone can easily calculate the space in square meters, or at least achieve a very close approximation for all practical purposes. So it does "work for everybody".
- mistermann 11y agoMy argument is that the calories in (eaten) / calories out (exercise) explanation, and the idea it is just that simple and if you're not losing weight you're cheating on your diet or lying about your exercise is wrong. You seem comfortable with the idea that different individuals have differences in caloric uptake (Suppose I extract 1500 calories from a meal, and you 1800 calories from the same meal), but I don't think others are comfortable with that idea. And if it varies across individuals, why is it impossible to vary with one individual over time, or change drastically in a short period of time? Can the physiology of your body change to (for example) start extracting more calories from food than it normally does? It doesn't seem like that crazy of an idea to me, and if it can do this (as anecdotal evidence suggests), then it makes weight loss strategies much more complicated, and it makes the simple calculations no longer work under all scenarios. This doesn't seem like a terribly controversial idea to me.
- leshow 11y agoNowhere did I state that metabolism doesn't vary across individuals. On the contrary I think that individuals have vastly different caloric requirements. None of this means that a caloric deficit and increased activity won't cause all individuals to lose weight, just that the absolute value will differ between individuals.
- mistermann 11y ago> Nowhere did I state that metabolism doesn't vary across individuals. "the same thing will 'work' for everybody." "just an aside, there is no 'ultra efficiency mode' you comment here: >I just couldn't lose anymore despite caloric restriction is completely bogus, unless you're suggesting your body violates the law of conservation of energy" If metabolism can vary by individual, why is it impossible for the metabolism for one individual to change over time? Serious question, I honestly don't know.
- DanBC 11y ago> None of this means that a caloric deficit and increased activity won't cause all individuals to lose weight, just that the absolute value will differ between individuals. Do you accept that the caloric value may vary in one person due to changes in gut flora? Or changes in metabolism?
- leshow 11y agoMaintenance caloric requirements change as your body mass changes (and composition). It's pretty obvious that, for example, your maintenance requirement at 200 lbs will be different from your maintenance requirement at 150 lbs; you have less tissue to sustain.
- mistermann 11y agoAny comments on the question asked? (Gut flora & metabolism)
- mikekchar 11y ago