5 ms·
Many thanks for the detailed post, I will try to pass this on to her, although she tends to not be terribly open minded about discussing diet, so it's a bit dif
by mistermann 11y ago
Many thanks for the detailed post, I will try to pass this on to her, although she tends to not be terribly open minded about discussing diet, so it's a bit difficult but will do my best.
The whole thing about diet and exercise is it's a tough subject, because it's not completely understood, and the same thing doesn't work for everyone. Also, fitting in a 1 hour workout 6 days a week (plus typically a commute to & from gym, showering) on top of work, commuting, and family, is not easy.
Most of what you said seems logical, but this part seems a bit iffy to me: "Much better is to lower the intensity so that you can do 30-60 minutes of activity. This will spare the sugar in your body, while burning calories (from fat)." I mean, it's not a crazy idea, but it doesn't seem particularly logical to me either. Maybe it's scientifically well documented though, I have no idea. That's why personally I prefer going the low carb route - it's a very simple theory that makes complete sense to me, and the results for most (if not all) people that follow it (and don't cheat like my wife did, then claiming that it "doesn't work" for her) are pretty spectacular. However, the ability to eat that strict diet varies largely per person - it was great for me because I tend to like that kind of food, but for others it is psychologically difficult to maintain and depression and self-pity become very big problems.
I think your advice that 1200 calories is too low is very interesting, because she has been very strict at that level + exercise, so it seems apparent that her body has gone into some sort of an ultra-efficiency mode. (She's tried cheat days but with no effect....maybe there's a particular food she's eating that's a problem.) I hit the same wall on keto where I just couldn't lose anymore despite caloric restriction, but luckily I had already hit my goal weight by then.
Lots to think about, thanks for the advice!
- boundlessdreamz 11y agoBody adapts quite well to most changes. Probably the exercises have become easier to do for her. You can try mixing it up or try https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-intensity_interval_training https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/High-intensity_interval_traini... HIIT goes against the advise above (low intensity, longer duration to burn fat) but it does work for some
- mistermann 11y agoHigh intensity is suggested here also: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QHHzie6XRGk https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=QHHzie6XRGk So confusing, what's right!!??
- mikekchar 11y agoThere are some definite possible advantages to HIIT. If you are careful to monitor your heart rate to keep a good level overall, then I think it has good potential. I used to run track when I was young (400 and 1500 meters) and we always trained this way. Honestly, if you are training every day and being relatively careful with your diet, then you will pretty easily get down to a weight that the average North American would call "skinny". The main problems I've seen with people are not understanding what they are eating (Google tells me a single blueberry muffin is 377 calories -- that's practically a meal in itself!!!) or people who are fooling themselves about their exercise (unless you are a competitive athlete, the 5-600 calories per hour is about right -- if you are lifting weights, you can divide that by a fair amount).
- leshow 11y agoDiet and exercise is actually very well understood, and the same thing will 'work' for everybody. There just happens to be a lot of bullshit floating around. For example your claim about the size of your wife's deficit... unless you tracked eveyr calorie she ate and she remained weight stable for weeks for you to get an average intake: you have no idea what her maintenance intake is and thus no idea how big of a deficit she is in. Caloric requirement calculators are bullshit, there's too much individual variation. As for losing weight; it's pretty simple. Resistance train a few times a week, to maintain muscle mass, consume around 0.8-1g of protein per lb of LEAN mass, and be in a moderate deficit of a hundred or so calories, and continue to make adjustments my lowering food intake and/or increasing activity to keep the fat loss moving as your caloric maintenance changes to your lower body mass. just an aside, there is no 'ultra efficiency mode' you comment here: >I just couldn't lose anymore despite caloric restriction is completely bogus, unless you're suggesting your body violates the law of conservation of energy
- mistermann 11y ago> Diet and exercise is actually very well understood, and the same thing will 'work' for everybody. > just an aside, there is no 'ultra efficiency mode' you comment here: Do you genuinely believe that metabolism doesn't vary across individuals, or for an individual over time? Do you think the bodies of all individuals have precisely the same ability to both absorb calories from ingested food, as well as produce motion with the exact same efficiency? Do you believe enzymes present in the digestive system have absolutely no effect whatsoever on the calories in / calories out calculations? Do you think every calorie you put into your body is converted into energy?
- mikekchar 11y ago1 kg of fat is about 7700 calories. So if you are in deficit by 1100 calories per day, then you should lose about 1 kg of fat. Assuming that you have a base metabolism of 2000 calories per day (average for a male of average size), and say you did an hour of moderate aerobic exercise (like jogging) every day (600 calories per day), the with a diet of 1500 calories, you should find yourself losing about 1kg a week on average. If you are not losing any weight with the above, then the potential explanations are: - You are in ultra efficiency mode: In other words, you are burning only 900 calories a day. - You are not running an hour a day. - You are not eating 1500 calories a day. Let's say you are 70 kg. It takes 1 calorie of energy to raise 1 kg of water by 1 degree. You are roughly 15 degrees above ambient temperature. Thus it takes 1050 calories to raise your temperature from ambient to body temperature. It is highly unlikely that your body will be able to maintain body temperature for an entire day on 900 calories. Thus, the only other explanation are the other two.