5 ms·
Can we ever really know another person?
- caylus 11y ago> What we did is we had them predict on a zero to 10 scale how members of the opposite sex would rate them in terms of their attractiveness > accuracy was not significantly better than chance I think this experiment conflates people having different opinions on attractiveness with the inherent difficulty on mapping the attractiveness spectrum onto the scale of 1 to 10. I'd be interested in an experiment that instead had participants order the attractiveness of many photos from most to least without assigning numbers to them. The photos should range from grotesque to average to supermodels. I think almost everyone would agree on the broad ordering, with some variation in exact ordering. Then, to capture the personal aspect of the original experiment, subjects could insert themselves into the ranking and see if the opposite sex agrees. My hypothesis is that performance would be far better than chance in this scenario.
- vodik 11y agoProbably even easier to just show pictures in pairs and have the participant to select the one they think is more attractive.
- ademarre 11y agoSo, Facesmash[1] instead of Hot or Not[2]. [1]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Facebook#Facemash https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/History_of_Facebook#Facemash [2]https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hot_or_Not https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hot_or_Not
- shawn-butler 11y agohttp://pickthehottie.com/ http://pickthehottie.com/ was fairly popular and predated Facemash by several years. Wouldn't surprise me in the least that Zuckberg would copy it. Seems to be his modus operandi in life.
- nly 11y agoWhat if attractiveness doesn't have a total order?
- jrowen 11y agoThis reminds me of a passage from Aldous Huxley's essay on mescaline, The Doors of Perception: We live together, we act on, and react to, one another; but always and in all circumstances we are by ourselves. The martyrs go hand in hand into the arena; they are crucified alone. Embraced, the lovers desperately try to fuse their insulated ecstasies into a single self-transcendence; in vain. By its very nature every embodied spirit is doomed to suffer and enjoy in solitude. Sensations, feelings, insights, fancies - all these are private and, except through symbols and at second hand, incommunicable. We can pool information about experiences, but never the experiences themselves. From family to nation, every human group is a society of island universes. Most island universes are sufficiently like one another to Permit of inferential understanding or even of mutual empathy or "feeling into." Thus, remembering our own bereavements and humiliations, we can condole with others in analogous circumstances, can put ourselves (always, of course, in a slightly Pickwickian sense) in their places. But in certain cases communication between universes is incomplete or even nonexistent. The mind is its own place, and the Places inhabited by the insane and the exceptionally gifted are so different from the places where ordinary men and women live, that there is little or no common ground of memory to serve as a basis for understanding or fellow feeling. Words are uttered, but fail to enlighten. The things and events to which the symbols refer belong to mutually exclusive realms of experience. As thoughts like these have swirled in my head over the years, I have become somewhat obsessed with the question of how my words and actions are interpreted by others, to the point where I often feel like I have no idea what they are thinking. Sometimes I think I have lost some cognitive ability, but others I feel it is just the acknowledgement of the author's sentiment "I assume that my mind is a pretty good simulation of yours, and it's just not." https://www.maps.org/images/pdf/books/HuxleyA1954TheDoorsOfPerception.pdf https://www.maps.org/images/pdf/books/HuxleyA1954TheDoorsOfP...
- theoh 11y agoReading this the idea of "modelling" from gestalt therapy[1] came to mind. I think it's quite practical to create an internal model of another person, which can be refined over time through observation. Fringe practices like "tulpamancy" involve actually "running" such a construct, and I think, whatever the truth behind the claims of tulpamancers, there is a lot still unknown about this (see also multiple personality, or dissociative identity disorder, and of course "hearing voices" in schizophrenia). Edit: [1] Actually it is a "neuro-linguistic programming" concept, which makes it a bit less credible. Still, the concept is clear.
- crimsonalucard 11y ago>"if you ask people to psychoanalyze themselves, ask them why their brain is doing this; or you ask them to report on mental processes, why did you make this decision versus that one—psychologists find over and over again that basically what we’re doing in those situations is we’re telling stories. We’re making sense of ourselves without having actual access to how our brains are causing those decisions." This quote is so telling in how little people know about themselves. When you analyze yourself, you're telling a story, not conducting a scientific analysis. Unlike science, stories can be fictional. This is why it's so easy for people to lie to themselves and paint a rational world around what is essentially mob mentality. It's also why I repeatedly see good, moral people do great evil and be completely unaware of it. They justified their actions to themselves with a story... a fictional story.
- orthoganol 11y agoAnother name for these stories is "ideology."
- bostik 11y agoSo in a way, we all live in an echo chamber of just one individual.
- forkandwait 11y agoIt seems completely obvious that individuality is the basic state, and then we come together to form friendships, families, societies. But I would hold that actually our collectivity and connectedness is actually logically and historically prior to any individuality -- we evolved from social animals, we are still social animals, and even the language with which we say "I am an individual" is a testament and an inheritance from this collectivity. In fact, our feeling of separatedness might be the illusion, not our feeling of union. Of course there is a Marxist angle to this: the relations of production in Capitalism are based on contracts between individuals, so we become steeped in this ideology from before we are even born and it just becomes "obvious", even though it makes even less sense than earth's seeming flatness. Even the nasty, brutish, short competitive phase of human history was likely not competition between individuals but between groups whose unity and homogeneity was probably almost total. Anyone who was not one with his / her group was probably ostracized, then died shortly thereafter.
- peterashford 11y agoNow, personally I can fully understand why Americans view 9/11 one way and Al Qaeda another. Is it really so hard? That said, I'm neither an American nor a member of Al Qaeda so maybe it doesn't count =)
- peterashford 11y agoNow, personally I can fully understand why Americans view 9/11 one way and Al Qaeda another. Is it really so hard? That said, I'm neither an American nor a member of Al Qaeda so maybe it doesn't count =)
- liamconnell 11y agoMy girlfriend just came home and I told her the study about rating yourself 1-10. She replied, "Everyone already knew that. I learned nothing from these two minutes."