7 ms·
I think the disease model is in many ways flawed. It posits one notion of normal and then divides everything into "normal therefore fine" or "different, therefo
by wpietri 11y ago
I think the disease model is in many ways flawed. It posits one notion of normal and then divides everything into "normal therefore fine" or "different, therefore broken".
Some good, HN-relevant examples are ADD and autism-spectrum "disorders". One of the hallmarks of ADD is hyperfocus, so ADD is a misnomer; it could easily be called, "doesn't pay attention when the teacher wants syndrome," or "is not interested in your boring trivia syndrome". There are a ton of people previously diagnosed with Asperger's who lead happy, productive lives. Both of these characteristics can be positive in the world of tech entrepreneurship, and could well have been positive in previous environments. [1]
That said, I think this guy making his central message, "Addiction is not a disease," is dangerous to the point of idiocy. In our current society, we really only have one mechanism for aiding those who will need a lot of help, and that's saying that they're sick. If he would like to make a full-scale assault on the disease model, godspeed. But a lot of people already want to believe that addicts could quit any time if they just applied a little willpower. Reinforcing that means that people who could be saved will die unnecessarily.
[1] See, e.g., the hunter vs farmer hypothesis for ADD: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hunter_vs._farmer_hypothesis https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hunter_vs._farmer_hypothesis
- stdbrouw 11y agoA better understanding of addiction is the key to effective treatment – and treatment really isn't very effective right now – so the question is whether the harm from any increased stigma is offset by the benefit of better treatments. It's always possible to willfully misinterpret Marc Lewis' message as saying that addicts just need to grow a spine, and it's definitely possible that a certain group of people will try to appropriate him to that end, but the interview itself is very nuanced.
- girvo 11y agoAs an ex-heroin addict, I agree. I also agree with the author/scientist who was interviewed in the article; my personal addiction was far more behaviour based than it was a disease. Becoming an addict takes practice and choices, and it was taking responsibility for that, along with a great support system from my family and governmental medical help that helped me break the 6 year cycle. As of today, I've been clean for three years. That said, N=1, and from others I used to associate with (many who are no longer with us), the disease model makes more sense. Basically, I think addiction is complex, and any one way of thinking about it will likely miss a lot.
- BurningFrog 11y agoThere was a study suggesting that what we call Schizophrenia is really 8 separate conditions with similar symptoms. That is probably how most mental disorders are. http://www.cnn.com/2014/09/16/health/schizophrenia-eight-diseases/ http://www.cnn.com/2014/09/16/health/schizophrenia-eight-dis...
- duaneb 11y ago> what we call Schizophrenia is really 8 separate conditions with similar symptoms I don't think we'll be able to say for sure how many different conditions there really "are". There may not even be such a number.
- wpietri 11y agoOh, definitely. Many things have complicated relationships to behavior like that. When I talk to friends with chronic diseases like Celiac's or diabetes, they spend a lot of time thinking about behavior, choices, and responsibility in ways similar to my recovering addict friends. Congrats on being clean 3 years, by the way. That's an enormous accomplishment, especially with something so socially stigmatized as heroin.
- danharaj 11y ago> it could easily be called, "doesn't pay attention when the teacher wants syndrome," or "is not interested in your boring trivia syndrome". "Doesn't fit into modern modes of domination and unquestionable authority" syndrome. How many diseases are "isn't productive under capitalism and is therefore less useful to society" syndrome? There is a presumption that we treat people the way we should treat people (we being society in the abstract, of course). Well yeah, if you take that as a premise then the only conclusion you can make is that people who cannot participate in society effectively for their own benefit and the benefit of others are sick! How many diseases are culturally specific, both geographically and historically? Depression is on the rise in many countries. Are people getting sicker, or is society becoming more inhospitable? If drug addiction is perceived as a symptom of a sick society, suddenly the logic of treating it is completely different.
- forgetsusername 11y ago>How many diseases are "isn't productive under capitalism and is therefore less useful to society" syndrome?" We tend to call those "crimes".
- danharaj 11y agoJust like drug possession and use? :3 Every institution of power has its own designator of "bad" that justifies dehumanization. Police: Crime. Medicine: Disease. Military: Terrorism (nowadays). Religion: Heresy. etc. We should not be surprised when they overlap.
- joesmo 11y ago"If drug addiction is perceived as a symptom of a sick society, suddenly the logic of treating it is completely different." Couldn't agree more (see my post elsewhere in this thread). I think the campaign against addicts (drug war) was indeed started from the 'isn't useful to capitalist society' angle, but now addicts, at least in the US but I'm sure pretty much everywhere else, are actually what bring massive profits to capitalist society through our government's prosecution and persecution of them. While it probably was not the intended result for most prohibitioners when they started the drug war, the war itself has created a whole new multi-billion dollar industry and front for many capitalists, especially the manufacturers of weapons, law enforcement, etc. Society, at least in the US, refuses to look at itself as the source of the problem because it enjoys the problem. Much of society has benefitted from persecuting and prosecuting drug addicts and the inevitable supply lines that are caused by the existence of a black market. Police, military, politicians, and other beneficiaries of all these billions (trillions over time) refuse to ever acknowledge there is a problem because that would mean the end of their nice perks, the end of the pina colada machines in the police station, the end of the fun SWAT raids, the end of selling so many assault rifles, tanks, and other death equipment that doesn't belong in civilian police hands. Damn straight addiction would be treated differently if it was seen as what it really is: a symptom of an incredibly sick society that no longer cares about its members and values profits above all else, including all human life, even that of its own citizens.
- ap22213 11y agoI'd never heard of the hunter vs farmer hypothesis. But, it's very interesting. A disproportionate number of my friends and I, although intelligent, had lifelong difficulties with ADHD, bipolar disorder, and substance abuse (as did many of our parents). We always used to ponder and hypothesize, as kids (in the 80s / 90s), that we just weren't built for modern life and that our recent ancestors were probably nomadic hunter gatherers. We felt like our bodies and minds truly were trying to push us to escape, to run wild in the forest.
- wpietri 11y agoRegarding bipolar disorder, you might enjoy reading Jameson's "Touched With Fire". She looks at the family trees of Romantic poets and how so many of the creative ones struggled, and how they had relatives that were thoroughly troubled in a way that made them unproductive. It's a great look at creativity as a double-edged sword.
- DanBC 11y agoYour point about the disease hypothesis is flawed because one of the main questions asked during diagnosis is "does this affect your day to day living? How much?"
- wpietri 11y agoI think that changes treatment choices, but I don't think it changes diagnosis. Plenty of people with cancer aren't affected by it (yet), but that doesn't mean they wouldn't be diagnosed with the disease.
- eivarv 11y agoDanBC is talking about the diagnosis of addiction (or indeed most mental illnesses), not diagnosing any disease. For example, a patient would likely not be diagnosed with an anxiety disorder if symptoms did not have a marked effect on their day to day living. This means that the disease model can not be said to be a tool used to enforce normative cognition or behavior, but a model to help decrease suffering.
- wpietri 11y agoCould you perhaps point me to a link? When I look at Generalized Anxiety Disorder, I don't see that one: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generalized_anxiety_disorder#DSM-5_criteria https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Generalized_anxiety_disorder#D... "Excessive" is normative, there. And Oppositional Defiant Disorder seems quite clearly designed to enforce normal behavior: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oppositional_defiant_disorder https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Oppositional_defiant_disorder And there are scads of articles critical of the way ADD is treated in the US, and specifically critical of how the diagnosis and medication are used to create classroom compliance. A teacher friend once substituted in a classroom where every single child was on medication. Given that the disease prominence is circa 10% and not all kids are on medication, either she should have bought a lottery ticket or there was some other factor than strict medical necessity going on there.
- 11y ago
- mistercow 11y ago>it could easily be called, "doesn't pay attention when the teacher wants syndrome," This is a common misunderstanding. My experience with ADD is that it's not just "doesn't pay attention to what someone else wants"; it's "I can't pay attention to what I want to pay attention to". And yeah, I do think that ADD has some beneficial effects as well. Syphilis can sometimes attack the nervous system in ways that create permanent elevated mood. I don't think that makes syphilis "not a disease".
- anigbrowl 11y agoYikes, what a terrible parallel when we're talking about the unhelpful connotations of infectiousness when the word disease is brought up.
- wpietri 11y agoHi! As someone also diagnosed with ADD I know what you mean. But that's still a control relationship, whether it's the teacher controlling me or me controlling myself to do something dull. I don't know about you, but I've never had any problem focusing on anything I found interesting; even in high school 12-hour coding marathons were easy for me. In one of Hallowell and Ratey's books they talk about how a better name for it would be "Attention Inconstancy Syndrome". But we have the name because in our industrial model of education teachers expect controllable students, and so see our difference as a deficit. All humans have limited attention spans, and different people have different limits. The problem for me wasn't my difference per se, but the expectation that I conform to patterns of behaviors that work for others. Now that I'm an adult and can define my own life, I'm no longer a "problem", just different.
- bumbledraven 11y ago> My experience with ADD is that it's not just "doesn't pay attention to what someone else wants"; it's "I can't pay attention to what I want to pay attention to". So kids with ADD can't concentrate for hours on, say video games or other interests?
- colechristensen 11y ago
- middle334 11y ago15+ years sober here, mostly through some recovery programs and a lot of AA. Neither the "disease" model (which has connotations of communicability) nor the AA "allergy" model (there's something wrong with my body) make total sense. Rather than try to fit other terms into a procrustean bed, I just call it addiction. Everyone is different, but there are a lot of commonalities. Given the amount of denial that is present in most cases of addiction, trying to fit it into other categories can make more room for rationalization and avoidance. "I clearly don't have a disease, I never caught it from anyone," someone might say, or "It's not an allergy, I don't break out in hives." And delay treatment that much longer. I'm a firm believer in getting whatever help works for you. If that's Rational Recovery, great. If that means an AA meeting every day, great. Just get help. Get it earlier than you think you need it. Tell your boss (s/he probably knows something is up anyway, just not what). Drop in on a meeting [yeah, AA, I know]. Tell a friend. Tell your doctor. Make a call and get into treatment. Do something, because until you do that, nothing is going to change. 16 years ago I was without a job and essentially unemployable, on the verge of being homeless, drinking 750ml+ of hard liquor a day, and this close to offing myself to end the misery. Today I'm married, doing really, really well financially, am bringing up a kid, and have a 6100+ karma score on my non-throwaway HN account. Life is good :-)
- igravious 11y agoGood for you, random internet person, good for you. Do you think the disease model implies more some kind of genetic/environmental slant, as opposed to a 'weak character'. I think what the disease model is putting forward is that something outside of your control led to your addiction rather than something you're supposedly meant to have control over, that is to say your decisions and will. Thanks for posting this. edit: And I just remembered, the clinical/medical label used is actually "illness", not disease...
- wpietri 11y agoAre you sure about the latter? Wikipedia believes that "disease" means "any condition that impairs the normal functioning of the human body": https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disease#Terminology https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disease#Terminology Illness, they say, refers to the patient's experience of the disease. A person with a disease might not feel ill, and a person who experiences illness might not have a disease.
- unimpressive 11y agoThe rosy, noble rebellious picture you paint of ADD isn't really what the disease looks like in people who are suffering: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LyDliT0GZpE https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LyDliT0GZpE
- wpietri 11y agoHaving been diagnosed with it in college, and knowing many similar people, I agree that it isn't all puppies and flowers. However, if that's how all humans were, it wouldn't be defined as a disease, it would just be human nature. It's also about human performance in very specific environments, that being certain industrial and early-post-industrial environments. And I'll add that most humans have inadequate attentional mechanisms for those environments, which is why 80% of adult Americans consume attention-enhancing stimulants every day, and why it is extremely rare to find an office environment without ready caffeine. One caveat: there are a variety of things that get lumped under the term ADD, like organophosphate pesticide poisoning [1]. There are people with severe attentional issues who do indeed suffer, and would even in historical human environments. Here I'm speaking only of the 5-10% of the population with the standard sort of ADD that appears to be genetic, and wouldn't have been recognized as a disease until recently. [1] http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2010/06/there_is_no_link_between_adhd.html http://thelastpsychiatrist.com/2010/06/there_is_no_link_betw...
- vacri 11y ago> There are a ton of people previously diagnosed with Asperger's who lead happy, productive lives. Who said being diagnosed with Aspergers meant you didn't have a happy, productive life? A disease doesn't mean you're debilitated.
- wpietri 11y agoI'm obviously not saying that, but it gets said a lot. Anything defined as a disease is seen as a problem, even when the person with it just sees it as a difference. An example people gave elsewhere in the thread was homosexuality, which was defined as a disease for years and years.