6 ms·
I am looking at apartments to buy here in Sydney and not a single one has available power sockets in the car parking garage. Likewise at work. Which obviously m
by threeseed 11y ago
I am looking at apartments to buy here in Sydney and not a single one has available power sockets in the car parking garage. Likewise at work. Which obviously makes charging impossible. The problem here is the chicken/egg situation. Building owners aren't going to install per bay power without cars. And people aren't going to buy cars they can't charge.
As land becomes more and more expensive housing density is increasing worldwide. This means fewer houses will have dedicated garages/driveways and apartments are going to become more popular. This increases the chances that your car will not be within distance of a power socket.
Hydrogen doesn't have this problem. It works exactly like petrol does today. It doesn't require much education or really any change in user behaviour. It is simply another nozzle at the gas station just like when LPG/Natural Gas was introduced.
- skrause 11y agoHowever, hydrogen fuel cell cars have another number of problems: http://ssj3gohan.tweakblogs.net/blog/11470/why-fuel-cell-cars-dont-work-part-1 http://ssj3gohan.tweakblogs.net/blog/11470/why-fuel-cell-car...
- TheSpiceIsLife 11y agoThe limitations of hydrogen powered fuel cell vehicles are grossly underestimated by many (layfolk) who espouse the technology. Storing hydrogen is difficult, it will leak out of steel and embrittle the steel. The biggest drawback, as it stands today, and quoted from the article you linked is this: "You won't even go 100 miles on current tech hydrogen tanks that are still safe to carry around in a car." However, some of the drawbacks could very well be the reasons hydrogen wins out. Again, quoted from the article you linked: "Even though a HFC-powered car is essentially an electric car, you get none of the benefits like filling it up with your own power source, using it as a smart grid buffer, regenerating energy during braking, etc." Those look like good ways to maintain the something similar to the present distribution change. It'll be interesting to see how this unfolds. People will argue over which is the better technology, but that isn't necessarily going to be the deciding factor.
- yc1010 11y agoI don't get the "smart grid" buffer argument why would anyonce cycle their car battery (and hence reducing its lifespan) for little to no financial gain
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoYou don't need to cycle to help the grid, just temporarily stopping charging for short periods and/or delaying overnight charging to off-peak times helps enormously. And you don't do it for free, the org operating the charger can get electricity cheaper if it agrees to modulate load to match demand.
- aianus 11y ago> little to no financial gain Electricity here in Ontario costs twice as much during the day as it does at night (US$0.12 vs US$0.06 per kwh). If you cycle most of a Tesla battery every day that's ~$120 a month in electricity savings. Not sure if that offsets the battery lifespan costs, but it's not nothing.
- nkoren 11y agoHydrogen is not simply a drop-in for petrol, like LPG/Natural gas. It is considerably more challenging to store and pump, and its infrastructure is orders of magnitude harder to install than electric charging points.
- brianshaler 11y agoCouldn't orders of magnitude more people use a single piece of infrastructure? I think their point was you could live and work anywhere then go to the one station in the vicinity for a couple minutes once or twice a week to top up.
- threeseed 11y agoBut as a customer I don't know or care how the hydrogen gets there. I just know that I will drive to the same gas station, use the same hardware to put it into my car, wait the same amount of time and pay for it exactly the same way I do today. Only it will be clean. And I won't involving changing my life to fit my car.
- nkoren 11y agoI honestly don't mean to sound antagonistic, but literally every single point you make is wrong. > use the same hardware to put it into my car It is not the same hardware: hydrogen pumps are far more complicated, difficult, and expensive than gasoline pumps. (http://ssj3gohan.tweakblogs.net/blog/11493/why-fuel-cell-cars-dont-work-part-2 http://ssj3gohan.tweakblogs.net/blog/11493/why-fuel-cell-car...). > wait the same amount of time Hydrogen cars will always have very poor range compared to hydrocarbon-fueled cars. So for the range that you get, you will spend much more time pumping. See the blog-post series above for more on that. > and pay for it exactly the same way I do today Because the infrastructure is many times more expensive than petroleum infrastructure -- and this is not just a matter of relative economies of scale, but a fundamental attribute of hydrogen -- you will need to pay much more to recoup those capital costs. Again, read the blog post series above (I'll stop repeating this, but it holds true for every point). > Only it will be clean. Only at your tailpipe, which is a false form of cleanliness. Systemically, Hydrogen is dirty. Hydrogen production is spectacularly inefficient. The only remotely efficient way of producing it is to extract it from hydrocarbons -- in which case it would actually be cleaner to generate work by burning the hydrocarbons directly. Truly "clean" methods of hydrogen production (electrolysis of H2O) require copious amounts of electricity, which must come from somewhere, and again would be better used directly, via a battery-electric vehicle. Basically, any energy source which produces hydrogen could be used to directly power a vehicle, and would be 5x-10x cleaner by doing so. > And I won't involving changing my life to fit my car. You have already changed your life to fit your car -- by driving to gas stations! Home-charging is a feature, not a bug. Besides, if you really want to drive to a remote location to get a complete top-up of your range -- that's what battery-swap is for. Battery-swap stations are far cheaper to build than hydrogen filling stations, and can give you more range, more quickly, than hydrogen pumping. And they are truly clean, not imaginarily clean.
- justincormack 11y agoIn the UK you can get a government grant for 75% of the install cost of a domestic charge point; there are also a growing number of public chargepoints (1400 now, increasing to 6000 in a couple of years), and workplace garages often have them; urban gas stations are mostly closing for commercial reasons (redevelopment).
- threeseed 11y agoI spent years living in London and I had to find parking on the street often not near my car. Are we really expecting every house to have a power cable running from their house down the street ? Because it sounds dangerous, impractical and hardly an elegant solution for the next generation of automobile power technology. And again my workplace in London was a big car garage. I don't see how that magically ends up with per bay power with the current chicken/egg situation.
- buro9 11y agoIt is now common in London to see electric only parking spaces, with a power bay, on most central London streets and these are increasing in number in the 'burbs too. You will get a ticket if you put a liquid-fuelled vehicle in those spaces. These tend to be filled with Nissan Leaf and cars of that kind, I've yet to see a Tesla in one (do all Tesla owners charge at home?).
- threeseed 11y agoThe Nissan Leaf takes 8 hours to recharge. I just don't understand how electric cars scale out to all consumers given the housing situation. There would need to be an electric charging unit on every parking spot. Is this logistically practical ?
- kuschku 11y agoRemember, whatever the charging time at a residential socket is in the US, the charging time at a European socket will be half of that. (If the socket is properly used) (US uses 110V residential, 220V industrial; Europe uses 220V/230V/240V residential, 400V industrial; Additionally usually british and German wall sockets, at least, offer up to 16 or 24A, which, again, is more than US sockets. If the socket delivers more power, you can charge faster)
- mtgx 11y agoThen how come we haven't seen a single "gas station with a hydrogen noozle" so far, but only specialized and very expensive "hydrogen stations"? If anything it's the electricity infrastructure that already exists, and you only need chargers installed, which are far cheaper than hydrogen stations - which is why we're already seeing thousands of EV chargers across the US and only a handful of hydrogen stations.
- bennettfeely 11y agoIf you were to take every single car on the road today and replace it with an electric car overnight there would be massive, massive blackouts, everywhere. Cars use a whole lot of energy, gasoline stores a whole lot of energy. I doubt there are many places around the world where electric power distribution systems are equipped to serve vehicles, on top of cooling, heating, refrigeration, electronics, etc.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> If you were to take every single car on the road today and replace it with an electric car overnight there would be massive, massive blackouts, everywhere. Half-credit. The DOE has shown that 77% of light vehicles could move over to overnight electric charging without adding any additional grid capacity. If we need more capacity, we add additional renewables to the grid.
- MrRadar 11y ago> If you were to take every single car on the road today and replace it with an electric car overnight there would be massive, massive blackouts, everywhere. Not quite true. It's estimated[0] that up to 75% of light-duty vehicles (the kind regular people drive) could be converted to electric without requiring major grid upgrades. The one major assumption is that most people would be charging their vehicles at off-peak hours (overnight) which is already the case[1]. [0] http://www.technologyreview.com/news/518066/could-electric-cars-threaten-the-grid/ http://www.technologyreview.com/news/518066/could-electric-c... [1] http://www.powermag.com/impact-of-electric-vehicle-charging-on-grid-may-be-far-less-than-feared/?printmode=1 http://www.powermag.com/impact-of-electric-vehicle-charging-...
- rmason 11y agoRight now I know of only one charging point in the Lansing area and that's at Kellogg Center on the Michigan State University campus though there could be one or two more I don't know about. Tesla only has one charger and that is in SW Michigan near Chicago though they recently announced one more in the Ann Arbor-Detroit area.
- mikeash 11y agoAccording to plugshare.com there are several dozen charging locations in Lansing.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoOne just went live in Grand Rapids.
- ZeroGravitas 11y agoAustralia seems a bit ambivalent about meeting its international obligations around carbon, but in several other countries they're solving this relatively simple issue with incentives, subsidies and planning regulations. It's really not hard at all.
- DasIch 11y agoNo matter how much money you throw at the problem, you won't be able to solve it entirely in cities. European cities aren't really built with cars in mind and most buildings don't come with garages. So all the cars currently parking in streets, can't be charged at all. In order for electric cars to become a good alternative, they need to be chargeable in <5min at least.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoWhy can't you put chargers on the street?
- twic 11y agoWe do put chargers on the street. There are a couple outside pubs i drink at. I'm not sure what would happen if you had a whole residential street wanting on-street chargers, though. At that point, we might need some new planning rules. Doesn't seem an insuperable problem, though.
- DasIch 11y agoThey take up a lot of space on a sidewalk. If all cars were electric, charging them on my street would require putting up a charger roughly every 5m on both sides of the street to charge all cars typically parking here. The same would have to happen for almost all residential streets in Berlin. Even ignoring the fact that there simply isn't enough space for chargers everywhere, it's also not practical financially.
- mikeash 11y agoChargers aren't that big. They'd take up about as much space as a parking meter. Lots of places have one parking meter per parking space.
- brc 11y agoIn reality, it would be a waste of money to install charging point infrastructure in each place as the demand is so low. Most people would prefer better appliances than a charging point. It wouldn't be that difficult to fit the charging point yourself if you purchase an apartment.
- Pxtl 11y agoIsn't Australia still coal-powered? With coal-burning power, EVs aren't cleaner than gas vehicles.
- NickM 11y agoYou are largely correct, but rooftop solar is fairly popular in Australia, and EV owners are much more likely than average to also buy rooftop solar. This is for economic reasons as much as ideological ones - solar pays for itself a lot faster if you're using that much more electricity - so there's a potnetial for a virtuous cycle that goes beyond whatever the current power generation mix happens to be.
- toomuchtodo 11y ago> With coal-burning power, EVs aren't cleaner than gas vehicles. Incorrect. Even if you run a car off coal, its cleaner than gasoline. That coal fired plant has better emissions controls, and is more efficient than the powerplant in your vehicle. And the grid will continue to become "cleaner"; a gas-powered vehicle will never reduce its emissions over the life of the vehicle.
- Pxtl 11y agohttp://www.cbc.ca/m/news/canada/nova-scotia/electric-cars-are-they-really-more-polluting-than-gas-1.3012929 http://www.cbc.ca/m/news/canada/nova-scotia/electric-cars-ar... Emission controls yes, but CO2 release cannot be captured and you can't beat entropy - energy is wasted on conversion from chemical=>electric=>mechanical rather than just going directly chemical=>mechanical.