3 ms·
I was not, but only in retrospect. Facebook succeed by keeping the ghetto out. It really was clever to only let in people from high status universities.
by danieltillett 11y ago
I was not, but only in retrospect. Facebook succeed by keeping the ghetto out. It really was clever to only let in people from high status universities.
- kristopolous 11y agoI strongly believe that facebook succeeded because myspace got bought. Unless the purchasers are really diligent and know the space, being bought seems to be a great way to kill a company.
- danieltillett 11y agoMyspace had a pretty bad reputation long before facebook succeeded. As reddit has discovered maintaining a good community while being open to all is hard. The true name policy was also very influential is stopping facebook sliding down the ghetto path once they opened up to the general public.
- kristopolous 11y agoreally? I think it's the walled garden that has more to do with it then the true name ... I'm familiar with all the (speculative untested) claims that true name is the secret sauce, but since those arguments come with nothing more than a spiffy domain and a nice stylesheet - I can't really go with it. metafilter, yelp, hacker news, ebay, instagram, twitter, wikipedia, flickr, stackoverflow, github - none of these have true name policies and they work fine. Google insisted that the decorum of youtube comments would skyrocket after instituting it - but of course they're the same as they ever were.
- danieltillett 11y agoI find it kind of interesting that the two of us are discussing the value of true names when we both are using our true names voluntarily. You can have a successful site without true names, but it takes much more effort once you open the door to the masses. Almost all the examples you provide have major issues with trolls and spammers - the one exception is HN, but I think this is more to do with the strong community ethos here and it's limited appeal.
- arfar 11y agoI guess the counter example to that might be 4chan. It's difficult _to_ be recognized on 4chan, if at all. Obviously it has its "ghetto" parts (weird term, I don't fully get it) but it still manages to be a successful (and I would argue quite influential) site 10 years on. Would you say the true name policy has assisted in them getting bigger too? Or just stopped them from getting "ghetto"?