4 ms·
When I was younger, I used to marvel at all the people who said they wished they could do a startup but couldn't come up with any ideas. I can usually sit down
by nostrademons 11y ago
When I was younger, I used to marvel at all the people who said they wished they could do a startup but couldn't come up with any ideas. I can usually sit down and write up a half-dozen ideas in an hour. They're not worth being possessive about, simply because there are so many of them.
Having spent the better part of a year thinking up ideas and testing them in front of users, I'll revise that opinion. Ideas are cheap. Good ideas are incredibly valuable. It's really easy to sit down and think up ideas that seem like they'd be both plausible and useful. It's much harder to find ideas that 1) can be implemented by a small team with virtually no resources 2) excite other people enough to overcome their "activation energy" and get them to try it out 3) would be useful enough in everyday life to keep them using it and 4) aren't already being done by dozens of other people. The filter isn't "1% of ideas that you dream up are actually good ones", it's more like "1% of ideas that you dream up and think are actually good ones actually are good ones."
- danieltillett 11y agoReally good idea are rare. Bad ideas are common and sometimes because of luck and hard work bad ideas succeed. This causes people to discount the importance of truly good ideas. The idea is one of the most important components to success - a good idea won’t guarantee success, but it makes it much more likely.
- wpietri 11y agoMaybe. I think the "good idea leads to riches" story is much more often constructed in retrospect because people like tidy narratives. I also think that the whole notion of "good idea" is misleading, in that a lot of people think that good ideas come out of the blue and then you just run with them. The companies I find interesting don't start with one good idea; they iterate toward success and have hundreds of ideas along the way, winnowing the good from the bad. Ernest Hemingway wrote, "The first draft of anything is shit." Artist friends say, "To make good art, you first have to make a lot of bad art." Ira Glass said, "It is only by going through a volume of work that [...] your work will be as good as your ambitions." I think this is true for all creative work.
- danieltillett 11y agoI agree with this. Good ideas almost never come all at once and often need to be worked on over a long time period. In the end though what matters is not how long, or how much effort it took, but how good the idea is.
- wpietri 11y agoIn that case, I don't think we're really talking about the idea. What we're talking about is that the idea has been validated through a lot of hard work. Ideas are still cheap; what's valuable is knowledge.
- danieltillett 11y agoI consider an idea everything pre-execution. I have had the odd goodish idea in a flash of brilliance, but the truely good ideas all took a lot of thinking and improvement over time. For example, the idea I am working on right now as my next venture I had 15 years ago, but I could not think of any way to monetarize it. Three months ago I finally worked out a way of doing this and have since been spending around 20% of my time filling knowledge gaps and planning what I need to do to begin execution. Right now I have nothing but an idea, but it is a well thought out and considered idea that I think has a reasonable chance of success.