3 ms·
Bad behavior is already banned. People behave badly nonetheless. Reading some of the other comments in the thread; two things become clear to me. People caus
by jrockway 11y ago
Bad behavior is already banned. People behave badly nonetheless.
Reading some of the other comments in the thread; two things become clear to me. People causing their devices to behave badly have no idea what the ramifications are, lacking knowledge in both regulatory issues ("what's DFS? what's TDWR?") and RF-related issues ("jacking up the power can't cause spurious emissions!") [note]. These people should not be modifying their radio equipment, they don't have the understanding required to do so safely.
That said, you can be licensed by the government to prove that you understand these things, and then the government gives you free reign to build your own equipment and basically do whatever you want. If I were modifying my WiFi equipment for Part 97 operation (questionably legal for various reasons I won't go into), I'd know to look for things like: interference with primary users of the frequencies, spurious emissions, permissible RF exposure limits, and so on.
"Unlicensed" doesn't mean you can do whatever you want. People seem to think it does, however, and the FCC has a very tiny enforcement budget, so it seems natural to go after the device manufacturers rather than the end users. The device manufacturers already pay to have their devices certified, a few more hoops don't matter to them (and save the taxpayers money), and a well-locked device will prevent even the most ignorant hobbyist from causing plane crashes, so I understand their logic.
I am probably going to write them a letter opposing the changes, but mostly from the perspective of amateur radio operators rather than "I can do whatever I want in my own home".
[note] Let me share some choice quotes from elsewhere in the thread:
"Sounds like those TDWR systems are in dire need of an upgrade if that's enough to cause fatalities."
"The hardware should know the amplitude of the input signal and what maximum gain can be applied to it before these detrimental effects set in. [...] I'm not going get a multi-gigahertz-capable scope costing tens of thousands of dollars just to tweak my home router."