4 ms·
Why do people keep bringing thinks like OpenWRT into this? The regulations here are about the firmware in the radio components themselves, not any particular fi
by Silhouette 11y ago
Why do people keep bringing thinks like OpenWRT into this? The regulations here are about the firmware in the radio components themselves, not any particular firmware running on a specific end user device that happens to include such a component.
The firmware running on the end user device and provided by its manufacturer probably doesn't even have access to the firmware running on the radio component in many cases, in which case the kind of regulations we're talking about would make no difference at all to that device.
If the main device firmware does have access to reconfigure the radio component, these regulations are a good thing, because it means you can afford to let end users swap out the main device firmware without risking them breaking the radio with adverse consequences for everyone else nearby. If you didn't have that safeguard, the only safe thing to do would be to lock down the entire device in exactly the way you're describing.
You are arguing against the regulatory framework that makes your desired outcome practical to achieve.
- nitrogen 11y agoThose who want to run exclusively open source software and firmware will not like such an approach.
- Silhouette 11y agoAs far as I am aware, they (or the developers of the software they use) are free to seek the necessary regulatory approval to operate a radio running their choice of software instead. They just have to play by the same rules as everyone else. Running open source software is completely orthogonal to having the proper regulatory approvals to transmit radio signals.
- kuschku 11y agoThe issue, as I see it, is that we ban owning something, instead of banning bad behaviour. It’s similar to the gun debate or the "speed limits on the autobahn" debate. Funnily, I’m on a different side in each of these 3 debates, but the issue is still there.
- Silhouette 11y agoI understand the ethical conflict here. I'm generally liberal in my views and tend to favour lighter regulation by default, so personally none of these issues sit easily with me. I believe technology is neutral and how it is employed is what counts, so my usual stance is that freedom should be the default and with that freedom must come responsibility. But I'm also a pragmatist. You can debate the merits of useful technologies that are also dangerous. Many technologies have both negative and positive applications. Sometimes in reality those technologies are used more often for negative purposes. We then get conflicts where the same tool that can protect an individual from harm can also harm others and/or protect the individual from the consequences of their harmful actions. We also get rather different kinds of conflict where a technology can be a net benefit to society because it helps many people but that comes at a high cost a few innocent people who will lose out in some way. However, when there is nothing to balance in how a technology is employed, when realistically it can only be used for harmful things or it causes wildly disproportionate harm, I think the ethical stance must change as well. Some things can't be fixed afterwards, and in that case mere deterrence isn't always enough and I do think formal regulation can be justified.
- kuschku 11y agoThe thing is, I think the balance here is at some different point. In Germany, we ban guns, but don’t really restrict people modifying routers, as long as it doesn't interfere with anything.
- the8472 11y ago> However, when there is nothing to balance in how a technology is employed But in this case there is: - open firmware - security research - running radios outside their regulated envelope without interfering e.g. because you're building a directed link between two sites in a rural area. With locked-down device you can't do that even if you got a permit. You'll have to buy more specialized, more expensive hardware
- jrockway 11y agoBad behavior is already banned. People behave badly nonetheless. Reading some of the other comments in the thread; two things become clear to me. People causing their devices to behave badly have no idea what the ramifications are, lacking knowledge in both regulatory issues ("what's DFS? what's TDWR?") and RF-related issues ("jacking up the power can't cause spurious emissions!") [note]. These people should not be modifying their radio equipment, they don't have the understanding required to do so safely. That said, you can be licensed by the government to prove that you understand these things, and then the government gives you free reign to build your own equipment and basically do whatever you want. If I were modifying my WiFi equipment for Part 97 operation (questionably legal for various reasons I won't go into), I'd know to look for things like: interference with primary users of the frequencies, spurious emissions, permissible RF exposure limits, and so on. "Unlicensed" doesn't mean you can do whatever you want. People seem to think it does, however, and the FCC has a very tiny enforcement budget, so it seems natural to go after the device manufacturers rather than the end users. The device manufacturers already pay to have their devices certified, a few more hoops don't matter to them (and save the taxpayers money), and a well-locked device will prevent even the most ignorant hobbyist from causing plane crashes, so I understand their logic. I am probably going to write them a letter opposing the changes, but mostly from the perspective of amateur radio operators rather than "I can do whatever I want in my own home". [note] Let me share some choice quotes from elsewhere in the thread: "Sounds like those TDWR systems are in dire need of an upgrade if that's enough to cause fatalities." "The hardware should know the amplitude of the input signal and what maximum gain can be applied to it before these detrimental effects set in. [...] I'm not going get a multi-gigahertz-capable scope costing tens of thousands of dollars just to tweak my home router."
- Sanddancer 11y agoIt feels very much like a knee-jerk reaction. Oh no, they're taking our wifi away, instead of figuring out why the regulations are proposed, and why there are unintended consequences far beyond a little noise at the edges of the wifi spectrum. Additionally, they don't want to realize that like you described, the cheapest way is to put in a radio that doesn't need a binary blob to operate, because router makers are sure as hell not going to pay for the expensive re-certification process after every software update.
- ignisf 11y agohttps://apps.fcc.gov/kdb/GetAttachment.html?id=1UiSJRK869RsyQddPi5hpw%3D%3D&desc=594280%20D02%20U-NII%20Device%20Security%20v01r02&tracking_number=39498 https://apps.fcc.gov/kdb/GetAttachment.html?id=1UiSJRK869Rsy... Here's a draft of the rules where they specifically ask how You will prevent end users from installing DD-WRT. Third-Party Access Control: What prevents third parties from loading non-US versions of the software/firmware on the device? Describe in detail how the device is protected from “flashing” and the installation of third-party firmware such as DD-WRT.
- Silhouette 11y agoAnd so I ask the same to you that I asked to 'PhasmaFelis, who seems to have been the first poster of that link in this discussion: what is the actual legal status of that document (which unlike others linked here does mention DD-WRT by name), and to which devices does/would it apply?
- makomk 11y agoIn many cases, especially with lower-end routers, the firmware running on the end user device is the firmware running on the radio component - there is no seperate radio CPU.
- Silhouette 11y agoIn those cases, restricting the use of unapproved firmware seems to be exactly what these regulations are supposed to do, and as I've argued elsewhere, I think it is a reasonable step to take given the damage one ignorant user can cause with these systems.