3 ms·
And when someone proposes a viable technology that could actually work the way Reed contemplates, we can and should review these kinds of regulations. Right no
by Silhouette 11y ago
And when someone proposes a viable technology that could actually work the way Reed contemplates, we can and should review these kinds of regulations.
Right now, today, in the real world, it doesn't matter whether the phenomenon we commonly call interference is a property of radio waves or a property of the receivers we use or the will of benevolent aliens watching us in their lab. The fact is that it causes communications systems not to work properly.
- DennisP 11y agoUltrawideband exists today. It's not in common use because the FCC restricted it to such low power it has about a 30 foot range.
- Silhouette 11y agoWhat would be the effect of the Ultrawideband that exists today on other devices using the relevant radio frequencies, absent that regulation? Put another way, what was the justification for imposing such a restrictive rule?
- Frozenlock 11y ago> what was the justification for imposing such a restrictive rule? This is a totally worthless question to ask about a law or rule. The general form would be "why was the law created?" And of course, there's never a law with the (disclosed) purpose of killing all kittens, giving money to friends or destroying an enemy. On the contrary, every law is always spun on some kind of "will you think of the children". The only good question you can ask about a law: "What are its consequences?" Interestingly, your first question was more in this sense.
- CountSessine 11y agoI believe that Silhouette's question was rhetorical. The answer, of course, is that UWB radio broadcast significantly impair conventional heterodyne radio receivers.
- leereeves 11y ago> The only good question you can ask about a law: > "What are its consequences?" Also, what are the consequences of not having the law? Which I suspect was the intended meaning of: > what was the justification for imposing such a restrictive rule?
- DennisP 11y agoThe effect would be an increase in the noise floor. Narrowband incumbents claimed it would be very disruptive, UWB advocates claimed it would be slight. I don't have the expertise to say who's correct, but find myself more suspicious of the side with billions invested in narrowband spectrum that could be made obsolete, and less suspicious of the academic researchers advocating UWB.
- bsder 11y agoNobody could make a UWB system that runs effectively over coax for cable companies. That isn't FCC getting in the way. More interesting is the question of whether there are other forces involved. Cringely postulates the NSA, but I do think incumbents more likely: http://www.cringely.com/2014/05/15/nsa-help-kill-uwb/ http://www.cringely.com/2014/05/15/nsa-help-kill-uwb/
- DennisP 11y agoI don't see how trouble with coax is relevant to wireless. The main point of UWB is high-bandwidth wireless, and the FCC is certainly preventing that.
- bsder 11y agoThe main point of UWB was making it work. UWB should, in theory, be able to pump a lot more bandwidth down the same wires. Both the cable companies and the phone companies would be salivating at a system that effectively automatically avoids nulls on coax or twisted pair. However, UWB requires highly accurate, synchronized clocks. Keeping those clocks in sync is non-trivial. The fact that they could never get it to work over wire means that they had no hope over wireless.