3 ms·
> Aside: on a very recent trip to India, spending some time working in a very large, very new office (not retail) building, replete with fully functional lifts,
by mschuster91 11y ago
> Aside: on a very recent trip to India, spending some time working in a very large, very new office (not retail) building, replete with fully functional lifts, it was fascinating to see each lift had a uniformed attendant that pressed buttons on request.
I think this may be more of a "show off, we're rich and can afford service" attitude. Spoken from the POV of an European only hearing about India when there is another outsourcing, terrorism, gang-rape or caste-based case (like the two poor "untouchables" girls sentenced to being raped by a village court, because their brother had married and run off with a higher-caste girl), I think it's just symptomatic of the culture.
Prove me wrong.
- SilasX 11y agoWell, since you asked ... It's my understanding that menial labor in India is expected to be cheap and so people wouldn't naturally interpret one extra worker as an extravagant show of wealth. I also read on Quora that Indian parking attendants will do nothing but press a button to generate your parking pass and give it to you, another example of pointless labor that doesn't seem very related to flouting wealth.
- Jedd 11y agoYes, it's almost definitely not showing off - though it may appear that way to outsiders. My understanding is that, as you observe, with labour being so cheap and a culture that values inclusiveness, this is the obvious course of action. In lots of non-western societies westerners will see inefficiencies and opportunities to replace human labour with fewer and better trained staff, or automated / mechanised systems. But this is to miss the point. The way I interpret it is a form of UBI - everyone(ish) has an opportunity for a modicum of income, with an underlying tacit agreement.
- aianus 11y agoThe difference between this and UBI is that these people have no time or opportunity to explore and possibly learn how to do something progressive. It's a gross waste of human potential.
- Jedd 11y agoI totally agree with the sentiment, but remember that for each of us, as we look at other people(s) there's a breathtaking number of activities that we would consider wasteful. While I am not a huge fan of cultural relativism, I appreciate that there may be some validity in considering such things through that lens. Though it may just be hopefully healthy self-doubt. Academic exercise -- what differences would you imagine for transition to a UBI between, say, India with this kind of social norm, the UK or AU (as examples with a half-way decent welfare and some 'work for unemployment benefits' programmes), and the USA or Singapore (again as examples, with extremely modest welfare arrangements)?
- witty_username 11y agoI've NEVER seen a lift attendant in my urban life in India. Maybe's it's there on the old style lifts with black gates, idk.