3 ms·
We're in a weird time. I just read the writeup about moot's challenges moderating 4chan. But we will soon have an unmoderatable "crypto 4chan" built on blockcha
by erikpukinskis 11y ago
We're in a weird time. I just read the writeup about moot's challenges moderating 4chan. But we will soon have an unmoderatable "crypto 4chan" built on blockchain technology that mechanically cannot be censored. Ethereum, Maidsafe, et al are building the infrastructure right now.
Government officials are concerned about this direction, as they should be. We will soon start seeing crypto-murder software that cannot be censored. Imagine Bitcoin, except instead of mining, you get paid to cache weaponized drones in remote locations so that they can do the blockchain's bidding.
These are not science fiction fantasies, the infrastructure for this is planned to be completed within the next few years. We can laugh at congress for thinking there is some obvious way for them to backdoor PGP, but they have good reasons to be concerned.
You might argue that this is a separate issue from the simple cryptography issue that congress is debating. But in my mind they are parts of the emerging phenomenon of information tools which are impervious to physical violence. For the state, which derives its power from physical violence, the entire movement is an existential threat.
I'm actually more concerned about this issue than the whole "AI superthreat". The kinds of tools the AIs would use to harm us will already be in the hands of bad people, long before the AIs wake up.
I am in no way suggesting these technologies are bad. People are already dying because they don't have access to food, shelter, and healthcare, and I belive crypto-technologies will save far more lives that way—providing universal logistics support to all humans—than they will facilitate deaths.
But so far IT has been sufficiently insulated from the physical world that technology feels somewhat safe... A long weekend in Vegas with fun games and a lot of money to be made. No one is really dying because pets.com went awry. But that is changing. Robotics combined with blockchain technologies enable information systems that are very much "of the world" and yet are not subject to the same mechanics of control as humans are, due to them not needing food or physical safety. That's not a smal change, it's a huge one.
Sometimes I wonder if this jump won't set us temporarily back towards a more totalitarian state. The obvious solution is to ban robotics and crypto, with a censorship regime like China has. I don't know how many "bad robots" or "bad blockchains" would need to exist for that scenario to trigger with wide public support.
I honestly spend most of my time trying to solve problems with these technologies so I haven't spent much time thinking about harm mitigation strategies. But I don't think it's silly to have that conversation. And we should help congress to have the right conversation, not mock them for failing to understand a problem that, frankly, none of us really understands.