4 ms·
No, in practice the same trader will make the trade and make another trade to hedge against losing money on the first. That's normal. What's wrong here is acti
by gaius 17y ago
No, in practice the same trader will make the trade and make another trade to hedge against losing money on the first. That's normal.
What's wrong here is acting in bad faith by selling known-bad investments. At best it's insider trading, at worst outright fraud.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoAny time you sell a security, you are selling a security which you believe to be a bad investment. If you buy at the bottom and sell at the top, the guy you sell to will lose money. Take their deal with Hudson Mezzanine. Goldman offered Hudson a bet: if the housing market goes down, Goldman wins, if it goes up, Hudson wins. Hudson lost. What's the problem?
- gaius 17y agoAny time you sell a security, you are selling a security which you believe to be a bad investment. Firstly, that's not true if you're a "market maker" as many large banks are. Secondly, it's not true if you are selling for a reason (e.g. you need the cash to do something else with) or for a technical reason (e.g. you are an index fund). Thirdly, so long as you are not actively misleading the buyer, if he thinks it's worth that much, that's his call.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoI oversimplified. However, the article describes Goldman taking a position, not acting as a market maker. It also says that Goldman informed the clients that it might be taking a position opposite to theirs. So I'm really not sure I see the problem, apart from lazy reporting: "Goldman Sachs made money, scary financial words, now I've got a story."
- anamax 17y ago>> Any time you sell a security, you are selling a security which you believe to be a bad investment. > Firstly, that's not true if you're a "market maker" as many large banks are. Actually, it's always true. You sell things because someone else is willing to pay you more for them than you think that they are worth to you. You buy things because they're worth more to you than the money it costs to get someone else to give them to you. Yes, there are lots of reasons why your valuation is different than the other party's, but the difference is why both of you are willing to do the deal. > Thirdly, so long as you are not actively misleading the buyer, if he thinks it's worth that much, that's his call. Absolutely. The buyer is willing to take the "profit", so he should be willing to take the loss. (The seller has similar issues - if they sell for "too little", that's their problem because they were willing to take "too much".)
- Eliezer 17y ago> Actually, it's always true There are such things as "gains from trade", you know. Not all assets are worth the same amount to all players! If you buy an asset that you think anticorrelates with your other assets to reduce variance, you don't need to think that asset is underpriced. And if you need to liquidate some of your assets to return to shareholders or, heck, buy a house, we call that "liquidity preference" and it means you don't necessarily think the asset is undervalued, just that cash in hand is worth more to you.
- anamax 17y ago> Not all assets are worth the same amount to all players! I wrote that trades happen because the parties value the relevant asset differently (the one that starts with the asset thinks that the cash is worth more than the asset to it, while the other thinks that the cash is worth less to it), so "correcting" me by telling me that is curious.... > to think that asset is underpriced I didn't say anything about "underpriced". I said that the two parties had different opinions about the assets in question wrt themselves. They can both be correct. (They can also both be wrong.)
- mschy 17y agoWhat's wrong here is acting in bad faith by selling known-bad investments. I participated in this activity in that I created software systems to enable the creation, valuation, analysis and management of the securities. As such, I'm sure I'm biased, but perhaps I also have some additional information and perspective. At the points in time when the securities were being sold, they were not known-bad. It's possible a few were sold afterwards, but they stopped being created pretty much the moment it was realized that they weren't going to perform. After all, the profit on them came primarily from holding a piece of the equity tranche (rather than from the sale itself), and the value of that tranche plummeted to zero and those bits were renamed 'toxic assets' in the press. As this new information came to light, two activities occurred. One was the wind-down of a lot of the structured products. Another was that traders looked for ways to use the information for a profit, such as buying swaps to profit from it. While I support 'what did they know, and when did they know it' style research to find bad actors (of which I'm sure there are some), it's my sincere belief that the vast majority of the deals were made in good faith. I don't think the insurance/fraud analogies are accurate, nor particularly useful in garnering lessons learned.
- Confusion 17y agoAt the points in time when the securities were being sold, they were not known-bad Do you honestly believe that? There is no reason whatsoever to suppose they didn't know these CDO's were rubbish. However, there also wasn't any reason for them to care: they profited a bunch, which is what an investment bank should do. If they hadn't, they would have gone down, instead of other banks and institutions. This is cut throat capitalism: there is no room for considering ethics or the public good.
- yummyfajitas 17y agoThey certainly believed they were rubbish. However, a belief that the market will swing in a certain direction is not the same as knowing a product sold is rubbish. In fact, the CDO's were not rubbish. The CDO's are supposed to pay off in a certain way based on market outcomes, which they did. Goldman simply believed the market would go one way, while buyers thought the market would go another way.