3 ms·
In general anti-virus is more useful for less educated users. For example, I'd never escalate (sudo, UAC, etc.) a process that I wouldn't expect to need the esc
by zamalek 11y ago
In general anti-virus is more useful for less educated users. For example, I'd never escalate (sudo, UAC, etc.) a process that I wouldn't expect to need the escalation. This severely limits the control a virus can take (stopping most in their tracks). The only people who really need AV are the type of idiots who run as root, or turn off UAC.
The real concern are advanced worms. Most of these would likely infect a machine regardless of the presence of an AV, either because they are zero-day or because a machine does not have security patches installed. AVs, typically, would struggle to catch an e.g. malicious BIOS flash resulting from an escalation vulnerability.
In the face of security patching, AVs are largely obsolete, irrespective of their detection rates: not 'completely' because human error does exist (which is why I still run one).
- tormeh 11y agoMany, many security patches are way late. AV software is nice when a vendor can't be bothered to update their software.
- zamalek 11y ago> Many, many security patches are way late. My main point was: a virus that uses a 0-day (or unpatched/unfixed 0-day) is likely going to cause problems for an AV: > AVs, typically, would struggle to catch an e.g. malicious BIOS flash resulting from an escalation vulnerability. Over-exaggerating to clarify: AVs are like bringing a knife to a gunfight. You might just be actually able to eliminate the weaker opponents (who also brought knives), but you're going nowhere against the veterans.
- dogma1138 11y agoIt takes about 5min to refactor the code of existing malware to avoid detection, heck playing around with compiler settings is enough in many cases. I've recompiled Netcat probably 200 times by now, small refactoring playing with compiler flags (compile with x64 profile, debug on, add some symbols etc..) and every time it avoids every AV out there. I usually use Virustotal which means that it will be short lived but i can do it over and over and over again ;)
- brobinson 11y agoThere's actually tools to automatically do what you're talking about for malware: http://www.rapid7.com/db/modules/encoder/x86/shikata_ga_nai http://www.rapid7.com/db/modules/encoder/x86/shikata_ga_nai (Japanese for "it can't be helped")
- dogma1138 11y agoEncoders and compactors are not good actually they usually leave too many patterns that are easy to detect. The might work on some binaries in some cases but if you want to avoid evasion refactor the malware yourself. Encoders and compactors are intended to modify existing binaries only :)
- brobinson 11y agoThat's what I'm seeing people doing (modify existing binaries): https://www.google.com/#q=shikata+ga+nai+antivirus https://www.google.com/#q=shikata+ga+nai+antivirus Seems like it's pretty effective for bypassing AV according to how everyone is using it.
- dogma1138 11y agoWell if you actually read the search results you'll see :) 1st result 2012: "If you want to avoid detection, a 60% success rate is not good enough. Remember, our implant was caught by 40% of the products, not 40% of the targets. Assuming the better anti-virus products have a larger market share, our 40% product failure rate could look more like an 80 or 90% detection rate on target machines. - See more at: http://www.digitalthreat.net/2012/02/anti-virus-evasion-choosing-a-payload/#sthash.htXfsyBb.dpuf" http://www.digitalthreat.net/2012/02/anti-virus-evasion-choo... 4th result 2014: "There are a couple of built in encoders in Metasploit (shikata ga nai is the most popular one), but these signatures have been updated in many Antivirus solutions, resulting in detection." Every decent AV out there today has signatures of packers and encoders they are very easy to find since the artifacts of things like PE headers and binary cave of the encoded binaries will be identical every time you use them. Most people who claim it works are simply rehashing the same old metasploit guides that are not really relevant in the real world anything that is wide used will be singnatured in a second by every AV company. Yes if you encode it and upload it to VirusTotal even today you might get 50% or more evasion but those 50% of products will have maybe 5% of the market, and pretty much zero enterprise users.
- technion 11y agoSome time ago, I went and grabbed all the quarantined executable attachments from our mail system. I was shocked there were so many, given how long it's been that blocking zip files containing .exe files has been a standard. I uploaded 30 to virustotal to see what would happen, and I can't recall exact numbers, but I believe we'd be looking at about 25 that has detection rates of 0/51. Since then, I'd been a staunch advocate of the argument AV just wasn't worth the effort. Meanwhile, I walk into organisations and every single person has 15 different toolbars clouding up half there screen real estate, and popups hitting them constantly. And you scan with an antivirus and the majority of players end up claiming this sort of thing is legitimate software.