4 ms·
Maybe autodrive cars, but I certainly do not want to see driverless cars. I want meat onboard. Licensed meat. Someone to get the tickets. Someone to sue whe
by sandworm101 11y ago
Maybe autodrive cars, but I certainly do not want to see driverless cars. I want meat onboard. Licensed meat. Someone to get the tickets. Someone to sue when the robot does something stupid. Someone with a foot on the hydraulic braking system and mechanical steering for when the electrics fail.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoWhere is the meat operating Predator/Reaper/Global Hawk drones? Thousands of miles away in an air-conditioned cargo container in the outskirts of Las Vegas.
- sandworm101 11y agoThe chances of those drones flattening me and my motorcycle are extremely slim.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoMotorcycles are already 45 times more dangerous than a car. I have a hard time (even as an ex-motorcycle owner/rider) feeling bad for motorcycle riders who are worried about self-driving cars (which are already better drivers than humans).
- sandworm101 11y agoExcept that in many ways a motocycle is no different than a bicycle, wheelchair, pedestrian, moped, horse+rider, or anyone else not wrapped in steal. Cars must share the road with non-cars.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoRight. Google and several other tech companies are going to keep pouring vast amounts of money into self-driving tech (to ensure its ability to "share the road with non-cars"), and naysayers are going to yell angrily at clouds. In this case, I appreciate the momentum behind self-driving vehicles. The sooner people are replaced, the better.
- sandworm101 11y agoI see the momentum but question its direction. Why not start with driverless freight trains? That would seem a far more controlled environment and some cities (Vancouver, DisneyWorld) have been doing it with passengers for years. Then self-driving planes. They already have autopilots. When I see people lining up to board a pilotless 747 then I'll start trusting driverless cars to not flatten me from behind as I sit on my bike helpless at a red light.
- jessaustin 11y agoDo you trust human drivers not to do that? Statistically, they're more likely to drive poorly in that situation.
- zer00eyz 11y agoOk is there a difference between "writing software for global hawk" and "writing software for self driving cars" As humans killing others is something we do, and based on history were pretty good at. We have the ability to justify our actions in some fairly ugly ways. There is a great quote from fog of war (check it out if you haven't seen it) on the firebombing of japan in WWII "LeMay said, "If we'd lost the war, we'd all have been prosecuted as war criminals." And I think he's right. He, and I'd say I, were behaving as war criminals. LeMay recognized that what he was doing would be thought immoral if his side had lost. But what makes it immoral if you lose and not immoral if you win?" So thats war, thats folks who build the engines of war, and send folks out to die and kill. I would say that in writing a missile guidance system, your writing it as "fit for purpose" and should KNOW and COMPREHEND what is going to happen when it is used. Is that going to be the same mind set for someone building a self driving car? Would I, or you, feel any better knowing that I had saved lives in 'theory' or 'statistically' only to know that I had caused actual death with my programing? I don't know how I would feel, I'm somewhat thankful that I'm not facing that dilemma in my current job.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoI think you missed my point. Ignore for the moment what drones are used for (a pilot still makes the final decision to deploy ordinance). My point was, software has advanced far enough for unmanned vehicles can fly on their own and navigate without human intervention. The X47-B (the Navy's "Salty Dog" UAV) can take off from an aircraft carrier, navigate to waypoints, refuel on-air from a tanker, and land back on an aircraft carrier deck in the ocean without any human intervention. Its not a stretch to think that self-driving cars are of similar complexity, and the problems around them will be solved in due time as well. There is no reason to have "meat" in the driver's seat anymore. https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northrop_Grumman_X-47B https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Northrop_Grumman_X-47B
- sandworm101 11y agoI don't think the pilot makes that decision. They push the button according to essentially a decision flowchart. Their decision is based on evidence gathered by others, wanted lists drawn up by politicians, standards written by committees, and orders from commanders. They do not see the guy's face in the truck and match it to a wanted poster. (Even in than scenario the decision is partially made by the person who created the poster.) The pilot/operator may decide the exact moment the ordinance is released, but he is not the person making the decision to kill. That is a very shared responsibility.
- magicalist 11y ago> Someone with a foot on the hydraulic breaking system and mechanical steering for when the electrics fail A huge number of accidents are because of inattention or distraction today. How are you going to the the bag of meat to pay attention in case of an anomalous situation if 99+% of the task is being taken care of for them?
- sandworm101 11y agoThe meat is the last hope for when the machines fail. And they do fail. For below: I totally agree that autopilots can be distracting. The same was said of cruise control and even automatic transmissions. We adapt.
- magicalist 11y agoNot sure if you missed the point of my question. Unexpected situations happen very fast while driving. If the human driver isn't sitting there ready to take over, they might as well not be there for that type of situation, and if they haven't had to do anything for the last half hour while driving, it's highly unlikely their eyes will consistently be on the road with hands ready to take over the controls.
- manicdee 11y agoGetting the human to take over from a failing autopilot is a fool's gambit. It takes the human thirty seconds to become as competent as a drunk driver, about a minute to get to normal competency levels. The time it takes a human to regain competence suggests that the only way to safely hand over is for the robot to come to a complete halt before ceding control.
- epmatsw 11y agoI think you strongly overestimate how helpful having a human being in the car would be in any of those scenarios. If my mother is the driver and the power steering goes out, she might as well not be there. And we already have well established systems for giving out tickets to cars whose owners aren't physically in the car (license plates, registrations tied to VINs, etc.).
- sandworm101 11y agoReally? How can a cop issue a google-powered car with a ticket for reckless driving? Are cops now to submit bug reports when they see cars making mistakes or misreading signs? They can churn out the tickets, but the likelihood of a ticket altering the machines behavior is very slim. Now if a person is in the car, they can learn where the software falls down and adapt accordingly. If the robot doesn't spot the new speed limit sign, the human can. I'm still waiting to see how these google-cars manage with hand gestures, people directing traffic. Just today I was waved through a red light by a volunteer firefighter not in any sort of uniform.
- Zigurd 11y agoThe actual problem will be that cops will have nothing to do and no ticket revenue to pay them with. We'd better get on what to do with a 70% decline in cop workload before they come up with some bright ideas.
- jonknee 11y ago> Someone with a foot on the hydraulic breaking system and mechanical steering for when the electrics fail. That already doesn't exist in a lot of cars (drive-by-wire).
- sandworm101 11y agoI have yet to see a production car that doesn't have manual brakes, either hydraulic in the case of master-slave cylinders or mechanical in the form of parking/emergency brakes, that can be engaged without electricity. There might actually be a rule about that, else parked cars could start drifting away if their batteries run down.
- woofyman 11y agoMany cars have electronic parking breaks.
- sandworm101 11y agoBut is there a model that, if you disconnect the battery, has no brakes? The few electronic parking brakes I've seen fail into the on position, much like truck trailers and or traincars. They lock if they loose voltage/pressure from the controlling system. And even those cars had master cylinders under the pedal.
- woofyman 11y agoThere are no break by wire production cars in the USA. Infinity sells the only steer by wire car. It uses clutches that engage a direct mechanical link if the electronics fail.