4 ms·
Yeah, there's always someone with a contrived answer like yours. If 1/10th the people die because the computer isn't perfect, aren't we much better off? Deaths
by melling 11y ago
Yeah, there's always someone with a contrived answer like yours. If 1/10th the people die because the computer isn't perfect, aren't we much better off? Deaths are actually increasing this year: http://www.newsweek.com/us-traffic-deaths-injuries-and-related-costs-2015-363602 http://www.newsweek.com/us-traffic-deaths-injuries-and-relat...
https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_motor_vehicle_deaths_in_U.S._by_year https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_motor_vehicle_deaths...
"In 2010, there were an estimated 5,419,000 crashes (30,296 fatal crashes), killing 32,999 and injuring 2,239,000.[2] The 32,479 traffic fatalities in 2011 were the lowest in 62 years (1949). Records indicate that there has been a total of 3,551,332 motor vehicle deaths in the United States from 1899 to 2012."
- gress 11y agoSelf driving cars are by no means the only solution to road deaths.
- valhalla 11y agoProbably true, but they're the most effective tool that would have the greatest singular impact available to us right now.
- gress 11y agoSelf driving cars are not available to us right now.
- UnoriginalGuy 11y agoThat's a truism. What are these solutions, how much do they cost, what are the relative pros/cons compared to self driving cars?
- gress 11y agoThat's for self driving car advocates to state, rather than simply raising the bogeyman of road deaths every time there is any commentary that detracts from their position.
- NhanH 11y agoThe easiest answer to your argument is for self driving car advocates to claim that it's the ONLY solution to reduce road deaths. Note that you are the one who claimed there are more than one solution.
- gress 11y agoExcept that that is self-evidently false, and we're not talking about some meaningless argument in a vacuum, but one between humans who have experience of the world.
- UnoriginalGuy 11y ago> That's for self driving car advocates to state Uhh what? You said: > Self driving cars are by no means the only solution to road deaths. I asked you "what other solutions?" You're literally pointing at other unnamed solutions as better alternatives to road deaths, it is very reasonable to ask you to be more specific. It is in no way up to driverless car advocates to complete an argument that you made.
- gress 11y agoIt's fairly obvious that things like pedestrian detection systems with automatic braking, lane departure warnings, tiredness detection, etc. will make a significant difference as they become widespread. These exist in production today and similar technologies are in active development and deployment. There is no reason to believe that human driven cars can't be made safe through technology without requiring self-driving. There may be other benefits to self-driving cars that are desirable, but as I said, the road deaths argument is clearly just fear mongering based on the false idea that other technological safety measures are not being developed. As for costs and numbers - those certainly aren't provided by self driving car advocates, who can't even say when the technology will be available or how basic legal and economic problems it presents will be overcome.
- ThrustVectoring 11y agoWe are much better off, of course, but that isn't enough to get the thing done. We also need to figure out how the "much better off" gets distributed, in a way that convinces everyone to actually do the thing. If, for instance, Google is held liable for accidents while reducing the overall rate, self-driving cars aren't going to be a thing (unless you fix that particular problem). Or if the victims of self-driving car accidents have difficulty getting compensated.
- zer00eyz 11y agoIs my above scenario contrived, yes. Is it demonstrative of the kind of ethical questions that are going to have to be answered by developers, rather than individuals. It absolutely is. If you note I'm not even dismissive of "self driving cars", I only point out that its going to be INTERESTING if we ever see them. The reality is that at some point, some where, some piece of software is going to have to make a very hard choice. The road will always have exposure to irrational actors (kids, drunks, a random person crashing their bike). Are we at a point where we WANT software making that decision? If I have terminal cancer I might make a different choice than if I just had a baby and I was a human behind the wheel. Will we be able to inform the system that were willing to commit self sacrifice? Is there going to be weighing on the system based on ages of those involved? What happens when someone decides to kill themselves by jumping in front of a self driving car? Lets forget about the legal battle that ensues the first time this happens. We will pretend that no lawyers will be allowed to be involved. The guy who wrote the code that said 4 kids > granny do you tell him? Maybe you have to go back and tell him his code killed 4 kids, and NOT granny and he has to fix it, cause that was wrong? I saved 32,999 people in THEORY but I know my code killed 4, they told me, it was a bug, I have to fix it now. Lets look for a real world example where we see some of this today. Train drivers kill people on a fairly regular basis. Some times its because people choose to kill themselves, sometimes it really is an accident where there was no intent on the part of the person killed. Do you know what happens to those folks? Do you realize the impact these actions have on their lives? They certainly do, its part of the job, they get training before they go out and drive, the get counseling after. For some of them IT DOESNT HELP. Stats aren't people, they don't react the way we want or expect. Like I said it is going to be INTERESTING.
- NhanH 11y agoShouldn't you got the pick the morality of the car you're in? Which will probably ends up with everyone choosing to protect themselves. And if that causes too much externality to society (some kind of Prisoner Dilemma where everyone tries to protect themselves being the worst?), then we have regulation step in and regulate the morality of the systems. It's not going to be easy, but I don't agree it's harder than the gazillions moral choice we already made as a society nowadays.