4 ms·
As a marketer, I have long given up on psychology as a field. The practitioners are too wishy-washy, the experiments too prone to confirmation bias, and the res
by legitster 11y ago
As a marketer, I have long given up on psychology as a field. The practitioners are too wishy-washy, the experiments too prone to confirmation bias, and the results too unusable.
I feel behavioral economists cover many of the same subjects, but their work is much more interesting and scientific. The experiments are tighter and ask better questions. And they focus more on specific characteristics in decision making, and less on asking big questions.
- vacri 11y ago> And they focus more on specific characteristics in decision making, and less on asking big questions. It seems more that it's behavioural economists that do studies relevant to your marketing, not a flaw in psychology itself. Psychology is an incredibly broad field, and it asks questions both big and small. Plenty of psychology studies ask very specific questions looking for very specific effects.
- will_work4tears 11y agoMy place of employment was funded a grant, and did a study to show that teens were using mobile devices more often than they did years ago (I don't remember the timeframe). I believe they got something like a 200k+ grant for this. A team of like 10 PhD psychologists to show something we already know. Not saying psychology as a field is pointless, or anything, just that they do occasionally do some silly studies.
- superuser2 11y agoTherein lies the problem. On many of the questions that psychology studies, people are deeply committed to an intuitive answer. A layperson reading any psychology experiment will either say "That's obvious! You spent how much establishing something everyone already knows?" or "No way. You must be twisting the data to make a name for yourself." Particularly when it touches hot-button issues like "to what extent are [people I don't like] in control of their own situations?" You don't get that around physics quite so much.
- vacri 11y agoYou're probably oversimplifying the study considerably, but even so, even things that "everyone knows" need to be formally studied. All across science, non-intuitive results happen all the time. In psychology, it's even more common, since biology doesn't play by the relatively clean rules of materials physics. After all, "everyone knows" that blacks are inferior and only useful as slaves (they even want to be, deep down); "everyone knows" that women are too temperamental to vote sensibly; "everyone knows" that people of that religion over there eat babies and we should destroy them before they destroy us... For a more recent example, "everyone knows" that young people use condoms more often now, given the higher levels of sex education about pregnancy and STIs they've grown up with - yet regional studies often show significantly decreased levels of condom use. Another one is the assumption that the current crop of young'uns are fantastic with understanding computers due to growing up with them, yet this hasn't been borne out in studies. Turned out that consuming from a device doesn't mean you understand how it works any better. Such studies are particularly important at ferretting out what's happening with people who aren't society's favourites - we all know what a man is, right? Always looking to get laid, not afraid to get physical, plays sport, drinks beer. Most men are like that, right? Not really; there's actually a huge variety of interests and desires. Studies of 'obvious!' things are just as necessary as fringe things, because sometimes the results are really quite unexpected.
- will_work4tears 11y ago"After all, "everyone knows" that blacks are inferior and only useful as slaves (they even want to be, deep down); "everyone knows" that women are too temperamental to vote sensibly; "everyone knows" that people of that religion over there eat babies and we should destroy them before they destroy us..." This is simply not true at all these days, and I don't like that HN users would push a normal conversation into one where you imply your "opponent" is racist, sexist, or a religious bigot. Might as well have called me a Nazi or brought Hitler into the conversation. And I don't believe you need Psychologists or a peer reviewed study to discern mobile platform usage, we have other ways to getting said metrics.
- afarrell 11y ago
- omginternets 11y ago>As a marketer, I have long given up on psychology as a field. This very much depends on what you're referring to as psychology. Bear in mind that when you throw that term around, you're including very rigorous research such as this: http://cavlab.net/?lang=en http://cavlab.net/?lang=en This article concerns social psychology, not cognition (mostly). The underlying problem is that social psych has become increasingly politicized.
- waltermoose 11y agoIt's interesting that you say that. In my time studying psychology one of the things that I've found interesting is the way that various subfields flee the label. Many IO apsychologists take to the label behaviorism economists. They're work is relatively opaque to main stream psychologists however in that they have their own professional societies separate from American Psychological Association (APA). The professional label of "psychologist" is actually strictly regulated in most states for the purposes of providing counseling and therapy, and typically requires a PhD from an APA accredited university and clinical experience to practice, but anyone can call themselves a counselor in most states (IIRC). Despite this many psychologists (the PhD ones) will use the counselor label for many purposes. (I think that family and marriage counselors require accreditation in most states as well, but I know less about the area.) In the area that I did research, people more typically consider themselves cognitive scientists, often doing work that overlaps machine learning techniques and perceptual measurement. I wanted to ask though, since some of the statistical techniques we're using seem like they could have some use cases in your field, what kind of adoption (if any) is there in marketing research of techniques such as [Multidimensional Scaling of similarity ratings](https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multidimensional_scaling https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Multidimensional_scaling) or other perceptual mapping techniques? It seems like a relatively straightforwards way to figure out what dimensions use in making classification judgments about products or companies...