5 ms·
When the Facebook hack comes, it will be devastating.
by TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago
When the Facebook hack comes, it will be devastating.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoThe torrent to end all torrents.
- qrendel 11y agoWould it even be possible to exfiltrate all that data? It's hard to imagine even storing all that they're generating in a single day. What's the most an attacker could likely get? Usernames & passwords for all users? Complete profile/album/comment data on a few tens of millions?
- toomuchtodo 11y agoVery insightful question. The only way I could see this working is having a botnet network that extracts the data externally, encrypts and stores locally, and then each node serves up its cache over bittorrent to a command and control system. It's just so much data. The more valuable data, arguably, would be plain text profile data about people, not their photos. Assuming 7 billion people in the world (very conservative, for funsies), each profile containing 10 megabytes of profile data (exclude photos, just textual data), uncompressed, would be 70 petabytes. A lot of data to be sure, but not unsurmountable. Compressed, you could probably get down to 30-40 PB depending on compressibility.
- andrepd 11y agoWhy 7 billion people if FB has less than 1.5 billion users? And why 10MB? 10 megabytes of text is a lot of text.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoWas assuming worse case scenario. Based on 1.5 billion users and 3MB of text, its only ~4.5 PB. That's nothing.
- imaginenore 11y ago10 megabytes of text data per user? You are orders of magnitude off. A list of friends, all posts and private messages. After compressing it will probably average 10 kilobytes per user.
- tomovo 11y agoAn attacker could attempt to damage or destroy some or all data. Covertly or openly. Immediately or over a long run.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoMmmmm silent corruption without underlying verification of the data. The most evil of attacks.
- marrone12 11y agoThey keep a lot of data in cold storage as well, so not sure how easy it would be able to get everything. Probably just whatever data they think will be likely accessed soon and is in relatively ephemeral storage.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoInteresting attack vector would be something that watching the staging area from cold storage and sent that data out.
- r3bl 11y ago> What's the most an attacker could likely get? Remember that thing when a guy from Europe asked from Facebook to give him everything they knew about him (which European citizens are allowed to request by law) and got over 1000 pages of information from Facebook? Now, multiply that by a billion (well, two or three billions actually).
- andrepd 11y ago>which European citizens are allowed to request by law Can they? TIL. It would be a fun thing to know, exactly how much they know about you.
- lucb1e 11y agoI only know about the Netherlands, but European might be similar: - When an organization collects data about you, they are forced to tell you about it (unless they're police or something I guess) and tell you what they are going to do with it. In Dutch this is called the "Informatieplicht persoonsgegevens". - Upon reasonable request, an organization must give you all information they can reasonably give you. "Reasonably" means, given a normal amount of effort. If they need to contact the garbage collectors and dig up an old cassette they threw away years ago, that is unreasonable to ask. They may also charge a fee, but the limit is quite low I think. - You can ask an organization to correct or remove your personally identifiable information if you have a good reason or if they have no reason not to. For example if you ask to remove your IP address from logs and they want to keep it for security purposes for 4 weeks, their argument sounds pretty reasonable (unless you have some better reason). - They cannot keep personally identifiable information for longer than necessary. For example, log files from the web server may be kept for security purposes, but if you have ten year old log files, that is too long to be reasonable for that purpose and is thus illegal. One thing I've always wondered about is how applicable this is to foreign organizations with websites accessible from the Netherlands. I've heard some people say that for companies with customers in the Netherlands, Dutch law applies and those customers have the above rights. Nobody seems to comply with that, though. Another thing I've heard is that if they have an office here, that office can be held to our laws. I should look that up some time.
- 11y ago
- zitterbewegung 11y agoWhere are you going to upload that many users? Pretty sure they have a good bug bounty program.
- babuskov 11y agoInto the Matrix ;)
- gpcz 11y agoGetting in might be possible, but then the attacker would have to covertly exfiltrate and store all of Facebook's content to do a dump. Does J. Random Attacker have enough storage to do this?
- 0942v8653 11y agoMaybe; realistically, the Internet speed would probably be more of a limiting factor. At mine, it would take almost a week to fill up 1 terabyte of storage. That's plenty of time to go get a few more HDDs. At 1 Gbps you'd have about 2 hours.
- gpcz 11y agoI think you're underestimating the scale of this problem. According to http://www.datacenterknowledge.com/archives/2013/01/18/facebook-builds-new-data-centers-for-cold-storage/ http://www.datacenterknowledge.com/archives/2013/01/18/faceb... , people upload 350 million new photos per day, and they have 240 billion photos total. If we use 1 MB per photo as an average, you'd need about 334 terabytes to store a day of Facebook's pictures. You'd need 228882 terabytes to store the whole thing. Assuming Wikipedia's estimate of $35/TB for desktop hard drives, it would cost about $8 million to store Facebook's photo archive (that's without videos or text). Actually hosting it would cost even more.
- 0942v8653 11y agoIf you were bent on getting it all, even at 1 Gbps: (228882 TB to Gb) sec to years = 58 yr 3 w 1 day 18 h 40 min 58 years is going to take a long time
- yellowapple 11y agoYou can split that across multiple attackers, though. A botnet of 58 machines would be able to do it in about a year by that math. Once you cross into the thousands, a full dump like this is suddenly feasible. That's why this is more a storage problem than a bandwidth problem in practice. That's a lot of hard drives. While it might be possible to build up a botnet of a few hundred thousand slave machines to download and store it all, the task is by no means trivial.
- monochromatic 11y agoAre there actually people who put stuff on facebook thinking it's private?
- muppetman 11y agoDepends how you define private.
- monochromatic 11y agoI assume that anything I put on facebook is already known to various governments, and might well become known to anyone in the world. I mostly post funny comments and the occasional picture, but would never post anything I didn't want my employer, my children, etc. to see.
- muppetman 11y agoMe either. But I post photos of my children with the assumption that I have privacy from the masses, and I think Facebook offers that. My ex girlfriend can't access those photos. Yes, I agree they're not private, I know someone can copy them and email them to her. The government has access. They're sitting in public CDNs, the URL to them has no security etc etc. But those photos still have a level of privacy. So yes, I think there are many people who put things on Facebook expecting they're private. Not private in the way you mean, but private in the way I mean.