3 ms·
From the submission title: "Does the distro matter when applying for a job as a Linux admin?" Yes. Almost certainly some clueless people will care whether you'v
by staunch 17y ago
From the submission title: "Does the distro matter when applying for a job as a Linux admin?" Yes. Almost certainly some clueless people will care whether you've specifically used their flavor of Linux.
From the article title: "Does the distro matter?" No. The differences among Linux distros is so slight that any otherwise qualified/competent admin can be expected to easily learn everything important in days or weeks.
- riffic 17y agonot true, the differences between distros is the support the distro provides. Some organizations need more support than others, and may even need to pay that.
- jrockway 17y agoThe differences among Linux distros is so slight that any otherwise qualified/competent admin can be expected to easily learn everything important in days or weeks. Not sure I agree. After years of using Debian, I had a hard time administering CentOS. yum is a cruel joke... and that's when the dependencies aren't messed up. The quality control and the intrinsic design is ... inconsistent. This makes it hard to administer, and I would certainly never take a job where I would be responsible for CentOS or Redhat.
- jonny_noog 17y agoI feel similarly. To me, as a (primarily) Debian user, there's Debian and all the distros that descend from it, then there's all the others. This differentiation exists in my mind primarily because of the difference in package management. It's not that I couldn't use CentOS and stuff (I have and still do to some extent), but I certainly have a much harder time of it. I guess that would probably change pretty quickly if I really wanted it to. I don't want to though.
- staunch 17y agoSo, do you disagree that "any otherwise qualified/competent admin" could easily learn to use a different distro than the one(s) they know? (I've noticed an increase in the number of replies I get like this on HN now. Time was people made an effort to reply to what you actually said (and meant), not just state some tangentially related populist opinion. Maybe it's just me though...)
- bugs 17y agoSomeone competent with linux ( More than "Oh I run a vps all by myself") should easily be able to learn how to do the same administration tasks on another. It may end up taking longer to do certain tasks and they may have to refer to documentation more often than someone competent in that distro thinks they should but linux is relatively universal and once you get past initial setup maintenance becomes rather similar.
- jrockway 17y agomaintenance becomes rather similar In that any task can be completed in an unbounded amount of time. If you want to do things quickly, though, all Linuxes are not the same.
- jrockway 17y agoI've noticed an increase in the number of replies I get like this on HN now. I've noticed an increase in the number of replies I get like this on HN now...
- skorgu 17y agoAs the article said, if the recruiter is at that level of box-ticking it would be a major disincentive for me as a hypothetical applicant. Generally, from the other side a candidate not having experience in RHEL (our bread and butter distro) isn't a deal breaker here. It's somewhat surprising if an applicant has really never used RHEL or CentOS but as you say there frankly aren't that many differences that someone intelligent can't pick up shortly. As long as there's a general knowledge of unix concepts the details of package management and where the config files happen to live isn't enough to get worked up over. What would be a red flag would be experience in only one distro, ever, even outside work.