5 ms·
Who is naturally better at lifting heavy objects -- men or women? Who is naturally better at bearing children -- men or women? Reality isn't gender-equal, or
by bitwize 11y ago
Who is naturally better at lifting heavy objects -- men or women?
Who is naturally better at bearing children -- men or women?
Reality isn't gender-equal, or even finely balanced like a Starcraft game. Equality means equal rights, not equal abilities. (A strict belief in the latter gets us into Harrison Bergeron territory.)
If we're talking cognitive skills, there is rough equality in ability, but a difference in approach which makes one sex better for a particular job than the other. If women tend more to seek social consensus, for instance, they would fare better in a software engineering job with a high degree of peer collaboration, as opposed to the same job in a more "cowboy coding" environment.
- s73v3r 11y ago"Who is naturally better at lifting heavy objects -- men or women?" Whichever one gets off their ass and stops stuffing their face with cheese doodles all day long.
- jimworm 11y agoSeems plausible on the surface, but not supported by research. The average elite female athlete is only as strong as an average male. Quote: The results of female national elite athletes even indicate that the strength level attainable by extremely high training will rarely surpass the 50th percentile of untrained or not specifically trained men. http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17186303 http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/17186303
- rayiner 11y agoMy problem with this line of reasoning is the inferential leap. The other day my wife was surprised that I could box jump higher than her, even though I rarely work out, while she had been training for a stair climbing competition. Being a man has its advantages. But then we're going to make the jump from that to saying "and that explains why men just prefer/are better at programming and thus make up 90% of the industry!" My second problem is that men set the metrics in ways that benefit them. Let's take the stereotypes as an assumption. What is a good programming team? One full of cowboys and rockstars, or one full of people who can concentrate on detail work for long periods at a time and communicate with each other? Studies of children show that girls are better at the latter (which is why they get higher grades).
- ivanca 11y ago>My second problem is that men set the metrics in ways that benefit them If you think going to war is a benefit then you may have a different concept of "benefit" than most. And you are extrapolating stuff, just because men are better at lifting weights doesn't mean we are going to close female weight competitions. The same thing happens with programming or any career where one of the sexes may be better by biological predisposition.
- Lawtonfogle 11y ago>My second problem is that men set the metrics in ways that benefit them. To a greater degree than women do?
- harryh 11y agoYour question doesn't matter if it's the men doing the hiring.
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoAnd GP's point doesn't matter if it's the women doing the hiring.
- harryh 11y agoSure, but which world do we live in?
- shanemhansen 11y agoI'd argue that the above questions aren't well formed. Gender equality is such a sticky issue that it's really important to use precise language. For the first question, it might be fair to say that the average amount men can lift is more than the average amount women can lift. However it's really important to realize that given 2 individuals of different genders, there's no reason to make any assumptions about which one is able to lift more weight. You could just assume, and if you had to assume, you'd be most accurate by assuming the man could lift more than the woman, but why assume? Be very careful when taking a statement that's accurate wrt to populations and applying it to 2 individuals in the population.
- norea-armozel 11y agoThis is a false comparison since even most industrial jobs have machinery which does the heavy lifting and most dangerous part of production (I know from personal experience). As for how women work in an office it largely depends on the job and the social norms in the office. I've seen women act as cut throat as the men in some offices and I've seen men work toward consensus in others. It's not biology that drives the behavior patterns at jobs it's the factors of production: the input, the tools, and the desired output. Everything else is an accident of history.