5 ms·
I'm curious, what subset of the software development world are you working in? "Developing locally on your machine" is and has always been standard practice in
by marssaxman 11y ago
I'm curious, what subset of the software development world are you working in? "Developing locally on your machine" is and has always been standard practice in every part of the industry I have encountered.
- walshemj 11y agoEvery project I worked on at BT (15 years) and all the webdev work it makes no sense to have 20 different pcs all developing and trying to merge the code at the end. You remove the risk of subtle differences between developers pc's if your only developing standalone apps I could see it but Microsoft doesn't develop windows or office that way.
- marssaxman 11y agoPerhaps I just don't understand what you're describing, because in my experience it is completely normal to have developers working on 20 different PCs and all merging code as they go - that's what version control systems are for! I can't really imagine how else you would do it. Do all the devs really mount a shared filesystem with a single copy of the code!? Or do you mean that the devs all still have individual copies of the source tree, but they do all their work by remoting in to some big monster server and building/testing there? That sounds.... um.... ungodly slow. Though I suppose if you are talking about webdev, perhaps there is no build step, so it might not suck quite as much...? It sounds like a very different world, and I'm struggling to understand what you mean. I never worked on Windows or Office, but I did work in devdiv for a while, and at that time Microsoft certainly did develop Visual Studio in the traditional way. There were build farms, to be sure, but they were used for occasional checkpoint builds and for testing. For daily work, we ran the ol' edit/compile/link/run/crash cycle locally, on our own dev machines.
- walshemj 11y agoYou can have your own source control at the server level and every one logs into that server just run an X Server on your PC. And yes you should be developing on exactly the same hardware its going to run on. All you need to set up a new user is a bog standard pc and a new account set up on the server. Its a lot easier to keep dev test and live identical than 20 or so developers pc's And even when we did local development (oracle forms) all the code was checked in to a central server which was used to produce a daily build. How do you think IBM mainframe development is done?
- marssaxman 11y agoThanks for explaining. That's certainly a very different way of working from anything I've ever encountered. I don't know enough about mainframes to even wonder how things are done, it simply isn't part of my world at all. I come from a personal computing background, where it really doesn't make sense to talk about "developing on exactly the same hardware it's going to run on" because you cannot know in advance what that is going to be. The kind of thing you are talking about makes even less sense in the embedded world, where cross-compilation is the rule and the target machines are likely not capable of self-hosting a toolchain at all.
- collyw 11y agoI actually think those subtle differences are more likely to bring problems to the front earlier. If you have code that works on 20 slightly different setups, then it is likely to be more robust than code that has only ever seen one setup. Obviously this is quite subjective, and depends a lot on what type of development you are doing.