5 ms·
I've always felt that all fines - for any cause - should be turned over to the state. Even simple parking tickets. The state should fund the court for hearing
by ars 11y ago
I've always felt that all fines - for any cause - should be turned over to the state. Even simple parking tickets.
The state should fund the court for hearing those cases (but not enforcement).
Then we'll see if cities really care about safety or about money.
- JoshTriplett 11y agoThen the state will get used to having a certain volume of such funds, and the departments that provide a substantial fraction of those funds will tend to get looked on favorably...that doesn't end well, either.
- mjevans 11y agoFines should go directly to a federally recognized not-for-profit. This is how repaying the community for a fine-able offence could be made. Also they should be /on top of/ damages. (In the case of most non-accident traffic matters, the 'damages' are non-existent.)
- briandear 11y agoNope. The Clinton Foundation is a "Federally Recognized not-for-profit." Could you imagine the stratospheric levels of corruption of non profits start to demand law enforcement revenues. The money should go to the general revenue fund but as an offset against tax income. More fines: lower taxes (which essentially means that the fines are distributed to the taxpayers, which is completely fair since the crime is against "the people." Law enforcement should never get fine money. That's a huge conflict of interest. It would be like a foreign government donating to the non profit of a sitting Secretary of State.
- realityking 11y agoThere actually is a system like this in place in Germany. Not for traffic fines, but if you get a fine in criminal court (technically your case is suspended conditionally on paying X€) it will go to a local charity. Caused quite a bit of drama a few months ago when the "Kinderschutzbund" refused the payment in a widely publicized child pornography case (the defendant was a member of the federal parliament at the time of the crime) despite accepting it before in similar cases.
- dibujante 11y agoProbably the money should simply be destroyed. There's too much conflict of interest when law enforcement can become a profit centre.
- ahallock 11y agoThere's a 25 MPH speed trap near me (no schools or anything nearby) that uses photo enforcement instead of actual police officers. It's basically an ATM for the tiny village of 179 residents. In 2013, they stopped 26 people for going too slow. Yes, too slow. Edit: more about Linndale: http://www.cleveland.com/metro/index.ssf/2014/12/linndale_with_its_reputation_a.html http://www.cleveland.com/metro/index.ssf/2014/12/linndale_wi...
- sliverstorm 11y agoYou could say the same thing about alcohol & vice taxes. It might make more sense than I realize, but destroying punitive damages seems like a terrible option. Damages are meant to penalize the offender; destroying wealth penalizes everyone.
- ahallock 11y agoSo how do you remove the conflict of interest? They have every incentive to abuse these revenue (more like theft) streams and become dependent on them.
- sliverstorm 11y ago"Send it far, far away" might be enough. It was only after local police departments started getting a cut of civil asset forfeitures (they used to be sent to the FBI, I believe) that counties started abusing it. There are surely other options too, such as spreading it out. You could fund a flat tax credit for all residents of the county with the fines. The wealth is not destroyed, and if the credit is on the order of a handful of dollars per resident, no one is going to have any strong incentives. You could vote to double all traffic fines- but if you personally stand to gain $3.72 from that doubling, the incentive exists but is very small.
- ptaipale 11y agoThen the state will start profiteering, as they do where I live. Here the government decided to just double the speeding fines, and they still pretend they do it for "traffic safety". It's a farce.
- crazyideaman 11y agoYou could remove all perverse incentives by putting all fines, fees, etc into a state fund that is paid back annually to citizens via a rebate of some sort. All funding of government would come only from taxes. This would eliminate any financial benefit to the government from fines, fees, and asset forfeiture.