3 ms·
> if a single mom working a minimum wage job can go to her workplace in 20 minutes rather than 1h30 for the same price, her quality of life would dramatically i
by pavel_lishin 11y ago
> if a single mom working a minimum wage job can go to her workplace in 20 minutes rather than 1h30 for the same price, her quality of life would dramatically improve.
That's a big honkin' if. Here in New York, you can get an unlimited metrocard for $116 a month; that's probably a week's worth of Uber rides.
Mom's not going to benefit much from that 20 minute ride if she still has to get up an hour earlier and work for two more hours to pay for Uber.
> We can't have it both ways. Either we go full capitalist
Also, this is a problem. If we go full capitalist and kill all government public transit, we end up having ONLY the upper classes use transit. There will be no reason to lower rates, there will be no subsidies. Is Uber going to build me a train to get me across town for $2.25? Absolutely not.
A city can afford to lose money on a public transit system because it gains that money back in having a tax base and an economy that's fueled by the people who use it. A private transit company has absolutely no reason to lose money per ride, except in the very beginning when they're trying to establish a user base. After that, their interest in the local economy is not as high as the municipal government's.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- djrogers 11y ago> Mom's not going to benefit much from that 20 minute ride if she still has to get up an hour earlier and work for two more hours to pay for Uber If she's saving over an hour on each end of her shift, she won't have to get up earlier. Also keep in mind she's probably paying a good chunk of her wage on daycare, so cutting 2 hrs off that would help a lot too. Heck, just having an extra 2.3 hours a day to spend with your kid is way more valuable than anything else I could think of...
- pavel_lishin 11y ago> If she's saving over an hour on each end of her shift, she won't have to get up earlier. But she will be having to pay a lot more to get to work. Which means she'll have to work more. Which means she'll have to get there earlier, or leave later. Which means that all the time she saved by not taking the bus is now spent at work. And sure, 2.3 hours with your kids is great. But making sure your kids can have dinner is better.
- SilasX 11y ago>That's a big honkin' if. Here in New York, you can get an unlimited metrocard for $116 a month; that's probably a week's worth of Uber rides Sure, if she just got a regular UberX ride, but that's not responding to the GP's point or the article, which discuss the possibility of Uber setting up its own transit lines, somewhere in between UberPool/Lyft lines and a municipal bus line, in which they could get fares down closer to bus rates with more direct routes. You're right that it's a big "if", but it's not responsive to compare a monthly pass to the current non-bus-ified Uber rates.