7 ms·
Take ideology off the hook for a moment, and if you are a supporter of lots of government support for mass transit, ask yourself, do you really want government
by jerf 11y ago
Take ideology off the hook for a moment, and if you are a supporter of lots of government support for mass transit, ask yourself, do you really want government agencies to engage in extremely, extremely speculative development [1] of millions of dollar's worth of software, radical new ways of organizing mass transit, and experimenting with a brand new way of providing services that have never been seriously tried before, and by all rational measures, at the outset of the project the most likely outcome can only rationally be considered failure?
Honestly, if this wasn't an ideologically-loaded "private industry vs. government" issue and we were all wearing our rational thought hats instead of our politics hats, we would vigorously condemn any mass transit authority that prioritized such a risky venture at the risk of dropping actual services to poor people! That's not their job.
This isn't a private vs. public story. Let the private industry prove out the model at their own risk and their own expense. Let them recoup the expense and pocket some profit for the risk at the expense of those who can afford the service. (The poor are not actually hurt by not having access to Uber, anymore than they were hurt by not having access to it 10 years ago.) Let the government come in behind and work on providing services based on the risks taken and the lessons learned. Perhaps even by contracting out to Uber, or perhaps more likely, a yet-to-be-founded mass-transit-focused competitor, when the model has been derisked enough that the poor aren't at high risk of being boned by the vagueries and vissitudes of Silicon Valley unicorns.
This would hold true even if all the city governments were models of efficiency, and all had highly trained and skillful staffs of programmers on staff who could easily write all this code. But come now, even you promoters of government, let's all be honest with each other, this is not the case. And, again, that's not least because it would be unacceptable for a mass transit authority to hire all that talent when it should be using money to provide service.
Government can't be good at everything, because there are something things that it can only be good at at the expense of other things it is supposed to be doing instead. Wildly risky experimentation certainly sounds like a good candidate for that category to me.
[1]: By contrast, to be clear, I am fully behind incremental advancement, exploration, and development by governments. It routinely happens and it should. But in general, it is not their job to do moon shots with social programs. (Note the "moon shot" and "the bomb" and all the other really experimental stuff that you might want to name are not social programs. A line of military research coming up dry does not directly harm the poor. (Especially under progressive taxation where "the poor" pay either very little or negative taxes in the US, so you can't even really complain about their tax load.))
- gkop 11y agoI like your point on public/private risk/reward, but you're too quick to say that wealthy people switching from public transit to private rides doesn't hurt poor people: the public transit systems will suffer from reduced frequency of routes and diminished funding, and the community will suffer from a wider class divide. I think Peñalosa did a good job advocating in favor of public transit for all in his talk in which he said "An advanced city is not one where even the poor use cars, but rather one where even the rich use public transport" (https://www.ted.com/talks/enrique_penalosa_why_buses_represent_democracy_in_action https://www.ted.com/talks/enrique_penalosa_why_buses_represe...)
- wfo 11y agoI want to agree with you but unfortunately the system you're proposing isn't really feasible. The poor actually are hurt by not having access to Uber as it becomes more and more popular and ubiquitous. We all are in fact. It's a stratification of society; there's one transportation scheme for the rich, Uber, and one transportation scheme for the poor, government-funded mass transit. And mass transit is barely funded in the United States as is. Once the rich have alternatives how long do you think it will take for people to whine "why should I pay taxes for a service I don't use? I can afford Uber I shouldn't have to pay for busses for poor people". Three months? Six? Maybe a year? If people use Muni every day they're willing to support it. If not, well... Then the wealthy with all of the political clout will push to defund our 'inefficient' public transit and it will become unusable. I think that it would be really nice to let private industry test things like this, but their tests are completely worthless from the perspective of providing actual mass transportation. They will find ways to take wealthy affluent people from places where wealthy affluent people live to places where wealthy affluent people work. The government isn't allowed to cater only to the rich in the pursuit of profits so unfortunately the results of the experiment will always say: hello government, if you stop taking care of those pesky poor and disabled and old citizens, you could have a very efficient system and reap great profits. Too bad you aren't legally allowed to throw people under the bus.
- jerf 11y ago"I want to agree with you but unfortunately the system you're proposing isn't really feasible." It's the system we actually have. I suppose that isn't proof of "feasibility", because people's definitions vary. "The poor actually are hurt by not having access to Uber as it becomes more and more popular and ubiquitous. We all are in fact. It's a stratification of society; there's one transportation scheme for the rich, Uber, and one transportation scheme for the poor, government-funded mass transit." If you want to define "harm" as "one day, a new thing pops up, and only the rich have access to it because it's very expensive, and now the poor are more harmed than they were yesterday because there's a thing they don't have access to that didn't exist yesterday", that's your decision. It is consistent and perhaps not wrong. But I don't care much about that sort of "harm". You've defined yourself up a definition of harm that can never be fixed, by definition. There is no way in theory or in fact to move things instantly from brand new and expensive to "affordable to provide to the poor for free or high subsidization". And problems that don't admit of solutions, even in theory, aren't ones you should spend a lot of time worrying about.[1] Far more interesting is the question of how to harness what has been created to help the poor. And there will be a time delay. It can't be helped, only at most minimized, and economics being what they are, you can blow a lot of money that really ought to be helping people now trying too hard to push that date forward beyond what it naturally "wants" to do. If that reality bothers you... well, good, you're human. But that doesn't mean you can change it. Things like this can only start at the wealthy end of society and flow down. Deny it to the wealthy in a fit of pique and you only create a situation where the poor don't get it either! If we accept that the poor are harmed by not getting these sorts of services we are ethically constrained to consider that a bad choice. [1]: "But if people just accept this, it'll be true!" Tell you what, you create a concrete solution where innovations can generally be instantly introduced to the entire world and I'll happily, gleefully, joyfully recant. In the meantime, this is the world. The rare examples of successful rebellion against some small part of reality puts a heavy survivors bias on our view of that sort of struggle; in general, this sort of reality is not fixed by wishing really hard it wasn't true.