4 ms·
Privatized public transportation seems to work in other countries. This particular plan sounds exactly like Hong Kong's minibuses. Also in other countries, pr
by jrockway 11y ago
Privatized public transportation seems to work in other countries. This particular plan sounds exactly like Hong Kong's minibuses. Also in other countries, private companies own competing rail networks, competing directly against the local government. (Tokyo is an example, compare Tokyo Metro and Toei. JR was once the government, but was privatized. Keio, Tobu, Seibu, Tokyu, etc. were always private companies.)
Meanwhile, the government-funded model of public transportation seems to be failing in the US. The MTA spent billions of dollars buying new trains and resignalling entire lines to run trains every 1 minute 30 seconds. But didn't actually schedule service that frequently, resulting in trains that are un-boardable during rush hours. (In fact, unresignalled lines have higher levels of service. The Flushing line runs at 33 trains per hour. The upgraded Canarsie line only runs 26 tph.)
Off-peak service is similarly abysmal, with trains running every 20 minutes as early as 11:00pm, that are often as packed as rush hour trains. They can't afford three more trains per hour to run them at 10 minute headways?
With more people using public transportation than ever before, it's a sad time for the government to be unable to justify expanding service to meet the needs of the new commuters. But they are doing a great job of being inept, so it would be great to see the private sector come in and fix things. I don't care who I pay to get to work, I just want to get there quickly and hassle-free.
- Tiktaalik 11y agoIt's important to recognize that public transit as a concept has major opponents in North America and cities are constantly having to fight to be able to build necessary infrastructure. Bafflingly expansion and funding of transit seems to need to go to referendums, where projects are frequently defeated (a yes vote in a referendum is very tough to achieve). In contrast other transportation infrastructure simply goes ahead as regular government spending. Ideological Anti-Tax, special interest groups have put huge amounts of money and effort into discrediting and defunding public transit and turning public opinion against expansion projects that would benefit everyone. The most recent example of this would be the Vancouver transit referendum, where the Canadian Taxpayers Federation seeded the idea that the transit runner Translink was a woefully inefficient organization even though in reality by almost any measure it's the best performing transit system on the west coast of NA. In the United states the Koch Brothers' Americans for Prosperity group has been pushing back against transit expansion and funding all across America. http://billmoyers.com/2014/10/03/koch-brothers-war-transit/ http://billmoyers.com/2014/10/03/koch-brothers-war-transit/
- akshatpradhan 11y ago> major opponents in North America and cities are constantly having to fight to be able to build necessary infrastructure. Bafflingly expansion and funding of transit seems to need to go to referendums, where projects are frequently defeated (a yes vote in a referendum is very tough to achieve). Its not working, so what can the US Gov do RIGHT NOW to implement a better system than Hong Kong?
- Tiktaalik 11y agoI am not an American so forgive me if this answer is not viable due to the structure of American government, but the simple solution is continuous and steady investment in public transit detached from political tampering. Many of these failed referendums were about creating a local tax in order to provide that dependable pool of transit funding for expansion and operating costs. A solution would be for the government to take the initiative and start seriously funding public transit, considering it a first class citizen along with the road and highway network.
- jrockway 11y agoThe roots of the MTA were in an agency detached from political tampering. It used the lack of political influence to raze entire neighborhoods to build freeways. The MTA was mostly created to remove this power from Robert Moses.
- x0x0 11y agoNot to mention the massive subsidies for driving: roads, parking, trillion dollar wars in the middle east to secure oil supplies. None of these are questioned, but a couple billion for public transit takes giant fights.
- Symmetry 11y agoPublic transit doesn't work very well in the US but that's mostly a problem with the way US politics and government works rather than something intrinsic to public transit. France isn't exactly known for low labor costs but they can still build subways for roughly 1/5 the price per mile you see in the US. So maybe we ought to be doing more private mass transit in the US but that doesn't mean it's a good idea everywhere.
- bweitzman 11y agoWhere have you seen a packed train after 11? I think I've seen one once and that was on Halloween (IIRC) at West 4th Street.
- jrockway 11y agoTake the 2 to Brooklyn. Even at 2:30 in the morning it can be crowded.