2 ms·
> If many of Bitcoin's believers had only been less dismissive [...] You have really put your finger on something for me. If I had to pick one word to describe
by wpietri 11y ago
> If many of Bitcoin's believers had only been less dismissive [...]
You have really put your finger on something for me. If I had to pick one word to describe the bulk of the Bitcoin advocates I've dealt with, it would be dismissive. Banking, social sciences, politics, history, economics, design, user experience, even a lot of technology.
Years ago I did tech for market makers and dealt a fair bit directly with exchanges, so naturally I read up on the history of places like Wall Street and the Chicago Mercantile Exchange. The technology was mostly uninteresting; things had run fine for decades with shouting and slips of paper. The impressive part was the elaborate social system, the set of subtly interlocking roles that made it all go.
I never met a Bitcoin advocate who seemed to understand any of that. Or even that understood that there was something to understand. So much of what I heard and read was in the true-believer vein, as if someone had crossbred gold bugs with partisan gadget fanboys. That's not to say that more responsible thinkers don't also like Bitcoin, just that I haven't managed to find any of them talking about the stuff I knew from experience was important.
I still hope people find something useful to do with blockchains, as they're a really cool technology. But it seems to me that if one has a solution looking for a problem, then actually understanding problems would be a valuable step.
- Frondo 11y agoYes, this comment is exactly my experience with Bitcoin advocates, too. I often post the exact same critique of Bitcoin in these stories, that there's no political accountability in the Bitcoin technology to its users. Bitcoin, of course, has economic assumptions baked in that influence how people use it, but those people have no real recourse to effect change in those economic assumptions. So its users, unlike with any national currency, have to take what they are given, without ever being able to have a say in how the currency is run. This is antidemocratic at its core, of course, but the near-ubiquitous response I get is, "sure it's democratic, you just need to fork it and then persuade 51% of the network to use your fork," and occasionally someone comes out and says "people aren't fit to make economic decisions, it's right that Bitcoin makes those decisions for them." Never has a single Bitcoin advocate ever said, "you're right, there should be some method in place for Bitcoin users to have a say in how it operates." Not once. I haven't seen any other community so willing to either take power (for those who think of themselves as the techno-elite) or give it away (for those who recognize they aren't). It reminds me of Terry Pratchett's running gag about how the people of Ankh-Morpork want kings back.
- wpietri 11y agoAbsolutely. The whole public story is "decentralized techno-magic freedom money with no nasty governments!" But as was pointed out long ago in "The Tyranny of Structurelessness", a lack of visible structure just means the true power structure ends up implicit. Right now it's fascinating to watch nominally technical decisions being made based on what mysterious Chinese mining organizations will think. I can appreciate the notion of having machines implement the transparently-published rules humans decide on as a way of increasing market trust. I'm not sure if it will work, as expressing rules sufficient to operate economies is very hard. But regardless, I'd like to see some rules about the humans who make the rules. Rule by law has been working out pretty well the last couple centuries.