6 ms·
So they've invented low-capacity, very expensive buses?
by PhasmaFelis 11y ago
So they've invented low-capacity, very expensive buses?
- justincormack 11y agoNo, they had been invented in many places before eg the dolmuş in Turkey [1], or the pesero in Mexico [2]/ [1] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dolmu%C5%9F https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Dolmu%C5%9F [2] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pesero https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Pesero
- batbomb 11y agoLyft Line is a low-capacity, slightly more expensive bus.
- imgabe 11y agoMore like on-demand buses that adjust their routes automatically according to where people need to go.
- mvid 11y agoAnd filter the riders to not be obnoxious, violent, unhygienic, racist, etc. And have real, working location status updates. And are clean. And won't tell you they are coming even though they are at capacity. As you can tell, this bus analogy irks me.
- maxwelljoslyn 11y agoUber really only has two things in common with public transit: cars and buses both have wheels to go places, and the services are both paid. {1} On-demand vs. scheduled {2} The given number of cars in the field sets a harder upper limit on number of riders. With buses, it's basically always "pack more people onto the bus, no matter how crowded" (i.e. the bus is forced to approach closer to "theoretical" carrying capacity of vehicle's physical volume - compare this to how much Uber is used for single riders.) {3} Anti-"troll" filtering (I mentioned elsewhere that this works for the same reason it works on web forums - you eliminate the irresponsible elements.) {4} No routes with Uber: go where you want. Normally this flexibility costs you at the rate of a taxi. Etc.
- SilasX 11y agoThat's not a full pictures of their current offerings. UberPool/Lyft lines are already closer to public transit on the continuum, with respect to the distinctions you made: 1: Pool/Lines add a lag to search for a match, so it's a bit less on-demand and more favorable others' schedules. 2: Pool/Lines increase the riders/vehicle. 4: Lyft Line hotspots reward you for picking start points at special locations, and ending within a zone, so it's somewhat route-constrained in return for a lower price. The article's prediction (and Uber's upcoming initiatives) simply go further in that direction: more constrained routes, more constrained times, lower prices. It's not the sharp boundary you suggest.
- maxwelljoslyn 11y agoOh, I see. Thanks for the correction.
- BorgHunter 11y agoA better analogy would be jitneys, or perhaps airport shuttles that aren't restricted to the airport.
- prawn 11y agoI think they'll eventually be quite affordable. If they're partly on-demand and on a more convenient route, even a higher cost may be worth it. And ultimately anyone is free to ignore the offer if costs are too high.
- peyton 11y agoThat "fire" drivers very quickly in response to passenger feedback and ban passengers in response to driver feedback. Doing so solves a significant subset of the problems with public transit.
- macspoofing 11y ago>Doing so solves a significant subset of the problems with public trans 'Bad' passengers and 'bad' drivers are a significant problem with public transit? Huh?
- krakensden 11y agoI don't know about drivers, but if you've ever shared space with someone going through cocaine psychosis, you'll believe in bad passengers.
- maxwelljoslyn 11y agoWell said. This is what makes Uber so good: this mechanism for keeping out the people who aren't responsible[1] enough to use the service fairly/follow the rules. It's the same reason a web forum with firm moderation and anti-troll policies will have higher-quality discourse.
- PhasmaFelis 11y agoThat actually kinda makes me more worried. As a passenger, removing the crazies sounds great, but in this scenario someone who's going through a hard time and makes a couple of bad decisions can get permanently banned from their only means of getting to work (assuming Uber succeeds in completely privatizing public transit). It's basically a No-Fly List on the ground. ("Get a bike" is not a universal solution; bikes cost money, and the kind of winter wear you need to ride across town in a cold climate without getting frostbite costs more money, and a lot of people don't get paid enough to have that much squirreled away even before their life went to shit.)