7 ms·
Imagine the dystopic future where Uber then colludes with the legal/prison complex, and can track everyone. Even if you don't use their services, their roving
by zdw 11y ago
Imagine the dystopic future where Uber then colludes with the legal/prison complex, and can track everyone.
Even if you don't use their services, their roving band of rfid/wifi/bluetooth sensing cars with cameras that read and recognize object like other cars, license plates, and other people in their environment will be observing everyone and everything, all the time.
Every vehicle, a subpoena-able bundle of sensors.
Watching.
Personally, I find that even scarier than the mass destruction of public transit.
- masterleep 11y agoYou find government owned transit better in this regard?
- masklinn 11y agoIt could hardly be worse, and there's the remote possibility of holding your government accountable.
- bsbechtel 11y agoHuh? You hold Uber accountable by not using their service. That's much more accountability than being 1 of ~150million votes.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoApparently 8 million people use Uber. Being 1 of ~8 million isn't significantly better than being 1 of ~150 million, in terms of accountability. But it's a faulty argument, anyway. It's not a single citizen that holds a government accountable, it's the masses, and the media, etc.
- bsbechtel 11y agoEven if it is the masses and media that hold the government accountable, they can still be more effective by pointing their power towards Uber than a government. The media's effect on Nike's labor practices in the mid-90s comes to mind as an example.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoBut not a particularly good example, as the labor problem was absolutely not solved by any of the bad publicity: https://rottenindenmark.wordpress.com/2015/07/16/we-are-not-going-to-shop-ourselves-into-a-better-world/ https://rottenindenmark.wordpress.com/2015/07/16/we-are-not-...
- bsbechtel 11y agoSounds like the bad publicity did help, but as the problems moved, the publicity didn't follow. It also sounds like local governments were more than complicit in allowing these new problems to fester.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoYup. And the changes in government seem to be sticking.
- donkeyd 11y agoIn the Netherlands you can get an "anonymous chipcard" to check in to public transportation. There are cameras pointed at every check in point, wouldn't really call it anonymous then...
- the-dude 11y agoWhich you typically charge with your bank-card... And if it breaks and you still have money on it? You need to fill out a form for reimbursement which asks EVERYTHING, including your gender!
- Lawtonfogle 11y agoIn theory, even if not in practice, governments have limits that private companies do not.
- icebraining 11y agoAnd vice-versa.
- toomuchtodo 11y agoA government is (in principle) accountable to its citizens. A private company is only accountable to its owners and shareholders.
- masterleep 11y agoIn reality, governments enjoy low accountability compared to private companies that must compete for business. That is why failed government programs hardly ever get replaced.
- pavel_lishin 11y agoI'm less afraid of unreplaced-failed-government-programs, and more afraid of unreplaced-successful-privacy-invading-companies, especially when they have government approval.
- vtlynch 11y agoPrivate companies may be held more accountable, but they are done so by a much smaller group of people. I think its also fairly evident that when a private company harms the general public, the only thing keeping them accountable is the government.
- gress 11y agoPrivate companies usually do everything they can to defeat competition - not to engage in it.
- jazzyk 11y agos/defeat/remove
- wfo 11y agoIn reality, private companies enjoy low accountability compared to government because while they perpetuate the myth of a highly competitive market, it isn't so; they are generally inefficient small fiefdoms. And government isn't allowed to keep secrets the way private companies are; and is required by regulation to act in a certain fair and reasonable way. If someone asks you for every email you've sent in the last year and you're a CEO, you give them the finger and laugh. If you work at a government agency, buy a couple thousand reams of paper and start printing.
- placeybordeaux 11y agoFor the price of a police helicopter police departments can continously monitor a 10 mile wide area from the sky. That is a lot better than waiting for cars to recognize stuff, subpoena all of them then work on the very hard problem of pieceing it all together.
- djrogers 11y agoI think you are vastly underestimating the cost and complexity of tracking everything/everywhere. It's not just a matter of mounting a couple of go-pros on a chopper and putting it in the air. Heck, even if that were all it took, that's very expensive.
- somebodyother 11y agoActually, you can look find cases of this already. Complete neighborhood-wide monitoring of every car down to the license plate, and every individual's basic outline are captured by surveillance planes. https://www.aclu.org/blog/free-future/mysterious-planes-over-baltimore-spark-surveillance-suspicions https://www.aclu.org/blog/free-future/mysterious-planes-over...
- Apocryphon 11y agoWell yeah, that's why you use much smaller, cheaper, and quieter drones instead of helicopters.
- 6d0debc071 11y agoThe existence of this system is rather odd then: https://youtu.be/QGxNyaXfJsA https://youtu.be/QGxNyaXfJsA Not that the level of surveillance that's becoming possible (and even expected) isn't deeply repugnant, I'm just not convinced it's quite as cheap as you make it out to be.
- josu 11y agoWhat about Uber free states then? Islands of liberty. Your vision necessarily needs coercive governments to make sense.
- BurningFrog 11y agoImagine the worst possible future with the system I dislike. Then imagine the best possible future with the system I do like. My system is clearly superior!
- zdw 11y agoWhile I get your point, I don't particularly dislike Uber. The point is that, like arguments for backdoored crypto, imagine when Uber hits some political roadblock it's had trouble overcoming, and uses the described "eyes everywhere" idea as a way of selling one of their already gathered externalities as a public safety benefit. Basically, it comes down to what kind of sci-fi you like - are the baddies evil corporations, or evil government. I just happened to conflate/combine the two...
- gentleteblor 11y agoI mostly second this thought (our potential dystopia resulting from some combination of corporate and government misbehavior). I'll just add that it isn't exactly science fiction. I think it's happening already, case in point, the frequent: NSA +- AT&T, Google, [corporation recently accused of collusion]
- woah 11y agoImagine a system where the subways are used as mandatory transportation to forced labor camps. Government trains transporting citizens to government factories, where they are forced to sing the national anthem before another grueling 14 hour shift. And if there are any problems, well, the subway is deep underground and out of sight. A truly sinister system of subterranean socialism that stands in stark contrast to the red-blooded freedom of the open road. That's almost scarier to me than Uber bans. </sarcasm>
- Apocryphon 11y agoI can't imagine a system like that, because the American taxpayer is already unwilling to pay enough to barely support a passenger train system as it is, much less some sort of efficient totalitarian government train system. And digging subways? As if this totalitarian government will be able to get its contractors to do that on time, and fight off the complaints from the totalitarian EPA.