6 ms·
Isn't it Bernie Sanders', not *Bernie Sander's? (Edit: or Sanders's, indeed. That's what I'd usually write.)
by TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago
Isn't it Bernie Sanders', not *Bernie Sander's?
(Edit: or Sanders's, indeed. That's what I'd usually write.)
- billpg 11y agoPeople with names ending in S shouldn't be allowed to own things!
- thesteamboat 11y agoWith attitudes like that, it's no wonder he's a socialist.
- albedoa 11y agoThere's a style choice. I prefer: Bernie Sanders's We can agree that the title is clearly wrong :D (In case it gets fixed, the title was submitted with: Sander's)
- keeganpoppen 11y agoBernie Sanders's'
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- yellowapple 11y agoBernie S'anders.
- raldi 11y agoActually, if you want to get technical, it should be "Bernies Sander".
- Someone1234 11y agoNo, because that's not his name. His name is Bernard Sanders and he goes by "Bernie." So Bernie Sanders, or expanded out to Sanders's or Sanders' are correct.
- insensible 11y agoMost styles render this as Bernie Sanders’s. In some circles this rendering (Bernie Sanders’) is correct. Reasonable people disagree: http://www.dailywritingtips.com/possessive-of-proper-names-ending-in-s/ http://www.dailywritingtips.com/possessive-of-proper-names-e... but those are the only two correct versions.
- Someone1234 11y agoThe way I always understood it is that originally the s's (Sanders's dog) style was considered correct, and that the s' (Sanders' dog) style was a shorthand version for informal writing (so in formal writing it would be "sanders's dog" and in letters to a friend it might be "sanders' dog"). But as with all things, informal writing was more popular than formal writing, and eventually the s' style grew in such popularity that it became valid and understood in its own right. So now effectively we have two "correct" ways of representing the same thing, a "long form" version and a "short form" version. The way I was always taught it (in a stuffy English secondary school) was that consistency within a single text is the most important thing, if you write s's once, you have to use it everywhere else also (ex. quotes).
- coldpie 11y agoI think it's much more likely that s' is and has always been incorrect, but the error is so frequently committed that it has become "correct". Language does evolve, after all. Snark: Given the current rate of apostrophe-abuse, I look forward to the apostrophe merging with the S at the end of words to form a new final-S character, which eventually usurps S entirely re'sulting word's that were 'spelled wrong becoming correct, and creating very weird form's of po's'se's'sive noun's: Jame's''s.
- coldpie 11y agoMost manuals of style say that "Sanders's" is most correct, but will allow for "Sanders'". I strongly prefer the former. It's logical if you think of it: s' is always for plural nouns that end in S, 's is always for singular. "The cats' milk" vs "James's hand." This way also matches pronunciation. It gets tricky to keep straight when you have plural nouns that don't end in S. I know "Men's clothes" is correct. But I'm not sure what to do with fish. "The fish's pond"? "The fishes' pond"? (In any case, just because a word ends in S does not mean it needs an apostrophe. Many, many English writers need this lessen pounded into their head. I lose brain cells every time I see someone write "want's".)
- a3n 11y agoI was in Sears (where America used to shop) and saw "Mens clothes".
- dhimes 11y agoThat's not the problem. The problem is that his name is Sanders, not Sander.
- r3bl 11y agoMan, it's no wonder that people like me two aren't speaking English natively get confused about that whole *'s thing.
- 11y ago
- sdenton4 11y agoI agree that there's no need to dereference Bernie.