5 ms·
I wouldn't lump all us Bitcoiners together. It was very clear right from the start that Bitcoin is just a tool that lets people rearrange and disperse power, no
by mike_hearn 11y ago
I wouldn't lump all us Bitcoiners together. It was very clear right from the start that Bitcoin is just a tool that lets people rearrange and disperse power, not a magic cure-all (even though some people get rather breathless over The Blockchain™).
If you look at the current dispute, it looks somewhat like what an election campaign for central bankers might look like if western countries were to allow for such things. Or rather what the first one might look like, if the current set of central bankers weren't really on board with the whole idea. You've got different groups with differing visions running something that vaguely resembles an election, but the issues are rather wonkish and technical.
Undoubtably many people will look at this whole thing and say, look how much more professional the dollar or the euro is. You never see such disagreements in the Fed! But I think the social failures that are leading to this crisis are actually also present there too: an assumption that experts never disagree, a preference for opaque unanimity, and a strong mental/emotional link between (perceived) unanimity and credibility.
Put another way, it's difficult to imagine a new central banker announcing that his/her predecessors and peers were all wrong and - for example - the correct inflation rate to target is 0% and not 2%. Even though there are economic papers out there that imply their policies might not be correct (written by economists at central banks, no less), the giant shitstorm that'd unleash would be extremely un-Central-Banker like and be seen as a serious threat to the credibility of that CB or even that country.
Bitcoin, for all its faults, does at least have some kind of mechanism to handle the case where the people making boring technical decisions stop doing it right.
- pron 11y ago> If you look at the current dispute, it looks somewhat like what an election campaign for central bankers might look like if western countries were to allow for such things. But they do (indirectly, of course)! Conformity of thought arises not because of the rules of the democratic system, but because of the way power tends to get concentrated in homogenous groups (another thing the social sciences tell us), unless resisted by some civil action. > Bitcoin, for all its faults, does at least have some kind of mechanism to handle the case where the people making boring technical decisions stop doing it right. I don't think that the Bitcoin system has any such advantage. The only difference I see is that Bitcoin's leadership are not accountable (even nominally) to any collective social interests that go beyond technical concerns regarding the currency. Whether that's good or bad depends on your ideology. You cannot fix the bugs in the workings of a system that on paper seems like it should work (i.e. modern democracy) without understanding what the bugs are and how they're created (and even then it's very hard, and entails a lot of politics, meaning influencing people), and you can't learn about those bugs in the mechanism if you dismiss the academic disciplines that have studied it for decades to centuries (depending on the discipline). You certainly can't do all that without an appreciation for politics.
- mike_hearn 11y ago> But they do (indirectly, of course)! Who do? In all western democracies that I'm aware of, the central bankers are meant to be independent of politicians. Of course you can view this as a fiction, but all the players do seem to believe it and it's exceptionally rare for politicians to directly argue with, let alone override, central bankers. > I don't think that the Bitcoin system has any such advantage. The only difference I see is that Bitcoin's leadership are not accountable (even nominally) to any collective social interests that go beyond technical concerns regarding the currency. Of course they are. You don't see developers releasing forks of Bitcoin that try to bring about economic outcomes, because such a fork would be almost certainly ignored by the userbase. But that doesn't mean it's impossible, or that it'd never happen even if the users were collectively strongly in favour. Besides, the two can't be easily divided. The block size debate is a bizarre witches brew of technical concerns, pseudo-technical concerns and social/economic concerns. The line between them is often blurry. So even a fork implementing a very minor technical change is causing massive uproar. Some people just really like the idea of a central planning committee of experts. Regardless, that's not a technical limitation of the protocol. In theory the fork can work.
- pron 11y ago> In all western democracies that I'm aware of, the central bankers are meant to be independent of politicians. What do you mean? They are appointed (and reappointed or not) by politicians. > But that doesn't mean it's impossible, or that it'd never happen even if the users were collectively strongly in favour. The difference is that in a state these things are done as part of bargains, which help prioritize. For example "I'll support your nomination for the chair of the central bank if you support my law allowing same-sex marriage". Sometimes these bargains can take the form of hostage-taking and be annoying, e.g. "If you don't repeal the ACA, I won't vote to raise the debt ceiling", but that's all part of the same process of keeping people in control. That bargaining, BTW, happens regardless of the political system (i.e. even in autocracies), only in a less explicit way and sometimes with different people involved. Once you completely separate the power structure for the currency from other concerns, you lose that control, and you lose it in a very radical way. Thing is, it's harder to bargain with people with money because they are relatively immune to many social effects. However, one of the classical checks-and-balances mechanisms in history is that of money and violence (and, at some point, religion). The two are both forms of power (i.e. ability to influence), but unlike money, violence is much harder to concentrate in the hands of the few (technology is changing that, but there are other, subtler sanctions at play that resist total concentration of violence). So the rich could starve the poor and had horses and swords, but they knew that if they went too far, they couldn't withstand an uprising. The state made an interesting deal: a central authority (though ideally not concentrated -- the two are different concepts) would have a monopoly over violence (up to a point), and, in exchange, it would regulate money. It wouldn't let the poor kill the rich (again, up to a point), but, through regulation it would make sure that the rich don't starve the poor. Once you separate the two, and, in the process, make even extreme violence less disruptive, you break a very important balance that has been reached. Like some sort of a MAD doctrine, you want to keep a mutual, implicit threat going. Which brings me back to the first point about central bankers. Even after their appointment, and even if they're not interested in another term, they still have a responsibility toward their community -- as I hinted at before, democracy only formalizes certain rules that have always implicitly had an effect, and certain sanctions are always at play even if not made formal by the democratic system. Bitcoin breaks that, too.