3 ms·
That's not a tragedy of the commons, it's a simple externality. It might be readily solvable simply by moving those people who are affected. For example, consi
by yummyfajitas 17y ago
That's not a tragedy of the commons, it's a simple externality. It might be readily solvable simply by moving those people who are affected.
For example, consider the Maldives, with 300,000 people making about $5k/year. Relocating every person in the Maldives to the US would probably be cheaper than most climate change solutions. This would also quadruple the standard of living of the average Maldivian, provided their income increases to the US poverty line.
- encoderer 17y agoHave you been to the maldives? I live in a particularly beautiful part of the US (Sarasota, FL) and I can say without question that moving to the Maldives would increase my standard of living. You're right that it would increase their incomes. But standard of living is much more than income...
- gwern 17y agoIf that is true, why not move there? Or are you a masochist?
- ori_b 17y agoActivation barriers. Cutting ties to where you currently are may be sufficiently painful that moving isn't worth it, even if the end result is an increased standard of living.
- gwern 17y agoIf one has offspring, and they have offspring and so on, the gain from moving is indefinitely large and overwhelms any activation barrier. This suggests a new alternative: the poster is either barren or doesn't care about the standard of living of his offspring.
- philwelch 17y agoYou left out a few possibilities: -The poster hadn't considered that argument -The poster doesn't want to have kids -The poster will have a finite number of descendants -The poster's concern for the standard of living of his distant descendants diminish according to distance (for instance, he probably cares a great deal for his children and a similar amount for his grandchildren, but by the time you're talking great-great-grandchildren his empathy has diminished significantly) -The poster's descendants will not want share his fondness for the Maldives -The poster's descendants will move away from the Maldives for other reasons I'm sure you can think of a half dozen other alternatives if you think for a minute.
- gwern 17y ago1. If the poster can consider 'activation costs', he most certainly can consider the benefits for his kids. Billions of people have radically altered their lives for the benefit of their kids, it's not some remarkably difficult task. 2. Same as barren. 3. Impossible to know, and under any plausible reckoning of improvement, insufficient to make activation costs predominate. 4. Same as doesn't care. 5. Unlikely; goes against millennia of empirical evidence that people love where they live (nowadays we call that 'patriotism') 6. A fully general counterargument (http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Fully_general_counterargument http://wiki.lesswrong.com/wiki/Fully_general_counterargument). You can use that to argue against anything: 'You should move away from North Korea', 'Why, my descendants might move away into it for other reasons!'; 'You shouldn't move away from North Korea, then', 'Why, my descendants might then move away elsewhere for other reasons!'
- ori_b 17y ago> If the poster can consider 'activation costs' What makes you think people consciously consider it? Most of them just say "I don't feel like moving", or "I'm too lazy". Also, you missed the point of the "fully general counterargument". The point is that if your descendants find it better to be somewhere else later - well, they're fully capable of moving themselves.
- philwelch 17y ago
- Readmore 17y agoThat's a great idea! Forced relocations always work out well, just ask the Native Americans. We really appreciated being moved across the country and forced to live in reservations. We should definitely use that as the solution to climate change.
- david 17y agoYou're right, letting people drown is a much better solution.
- w00pla 17y agoI agree with your sentiments but not your facts. > For example, consider the Maldives, with 300,000 people making about $5k/year. The sea level of the Maldives fell by more than 20cm since the 70ies. If the worst of the IPCC predictions come to pass, then the Maldives will still be better of in 2100 than in 1970. Here is a reference - but you can find many more using Google: http://network.nationalpost.com/np/blogs/fpcomment/archive/2009/10/20/maldives-president-all-wet-on-sea-level.aspx http://network.nationalpost.com/np/blogs/fpcomment/archive/2...
- didroe 17y agoAssuming their population has stayed the same and that they haven't built anything on lower lying land since then.
- jacoblyles 17y agoThey will also probably be much richer and able to afford ambitious engineering projects. 100 years from now, Bangladeshis are expected to be as rich as the modern Dutch.