6 ms·
The mention that they plan to remove XUL usage within Firefox (which is a good idea) is interesting. That's an extra justification for the change of extensions
by TazeTSchnitzel 11y ago
The mention that they plan to remove XUL usage within Firefox (which is a good idea) is interesting. That's an extra justification for the change of extensions approach (the one we knew before was e10s).
Looks like they realised that to keep moving forward, clean up technical debt and fix longstanding issues, they'd unfortunately break almost all extensions in the process. And if that's the case, they might as well switch to a better API while they're at it. It's painful, yes, but Firefox is still a slow, unstable and memory-guzzling behemoth, where all your extensions break on every update. This won't change if they stick with single-process, XUL, XPCOM and the existing extension model.
I am optimistic. I think Firefox can and will survive this. Look how well Apple's Mac OS to OS X transition went. Mozilla are willing to help people port extensions. And their timeline is probably unrealistic, but it can be pushed back. In two or three years, Firefox will be a world-class browser again, and we will look back at the panic we had now and laugh.
- justinmk 11y ago> In two or three years, Firefox will be a world-class browser again, and we will look back at the panic we had now and laugh. I was hoping Servo would be their flagship in 3 years :/
- lern_too_spel 11y agoServo would replace Gecko, not Firefox.
- kibwen 11y agoServo is just the browser engine, an alternative to the component known as Gecko in modern Firefox. Mozilla isn't going to drop the Firefox brand even if they do end up replacing Gecko with Servo (which is hardly guaranteed). Though if anything, the move here makes it more plausible that such a switch could happen, because the whole XUL situation is probably the single largest blocker for a Servo-based Firefox. A standardized extensions API would also give Servo a free extensions ecosystem with minimal effort, especially if Mozilla pursues a GUI based on browser.html which could be shared with Servo immediately.
- cpeterso 11y ago> Mozilla isn't going to drop the Firefox brand even if they do end up replacing Gecko with Servo Microsoft rebranded IE as Edge to jettison both technical debt (like ActiveX) and IE's bad reputation. Conveniently, IE and Edge both have blue "e" icons so users are not confused. :) I wonder if Mozilla could successfully launch a Servo-based browser product with a new name to distance it from Firefox's historical reputation for memory leaks and broken extensions.
- sanxiyn 11y agoDoesn't Firefox have a reputation for using less memory than other browsers these days?
- icebraining 11y agoI don't think so, the reputation still hasn't matched the reality :)
- oblio 11y agoI've definitely seen a lot of discussions where Chrome is considered a memory hog compared to Firefox. At least in the last 2-3 years.
- zurn 11y agoFirefox has a pretty good reputation among users and web developers, despite risks of hitting bad extensions. Their problem amont end users is more the relative obscurity vs the big 3 commercial browsers. IE on the other hand has been a swear word for years.
- tomjen3 11y agoI hope not. Mandatory extension signing requires handing over proprietary code to some random dude and trust them to not accidentally leak it, just to run it on your own computer and now this.
- Arcanum-XIII 11y agoApp store app require signing : I've never, ever, got to handle anything beside the binary (and the eventual code/uri to test it). I don't see why it would be different here.
- mook 11y agoMozilla explicitly wants to have a system where the extension is uploaded to them for signing, unlike the Apple / MS Authenticode systems where the developer gets a certificate to sign locally. https://wiki.mozilla.org/Addons/Extension_Signing https://wiki.mozilla.org/Addons/Extension_Signing (look for "not hosted")
- pjc50 11y agoIf you just want to run it on your own computer, you can replace the sign check certificate (or build Firefox without this feature altogether). Signing is for protecting other users.
- hackuser 11y ago> Firefox is still a slow, unstable and memory-guzzling behemoth, where all your extensions break on every update. Using dozens of extensions, this has not been my experience or the experience of many others I know. I believe the problems with extensions breaking and memory consumption were solved years ago; AFAIK tests show Firefox' memory consumption is less than Chrome's (in part because of the single-process model) and performance, at least a little while ago, was slighlty better. I haven't experienced, seen, or read about instability.
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoI experience frequent crashes in Firefox. I don't think it's to do with extensions, though. I'm saying XUL, XPCOM and the single-process model hurt Firefox's maintainability and performance.
- kbrosnan 11y agoCrash IDs? https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/mozillacrashreporter https://support.mozilla.org/en-US/kb/mozillacrashreporter or email at HN username at mozilla dot com
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agobp-9ae5ccb2-a36f-48f7-b649-648712150822 22/08/2015 15:49 bp-63bbf3d2-c39f-43ee-ad31-d8e812150820 20/08/2015 19:18 bp-816c2b7e-fa1a-422c-96ff-3b5e92150810 10/08/2015 20:43 bp-6ab2fecb-4d9a-4606-8b82-8bcbf2150804 04/08/2015 15:49 bp-f44c1dfa-ceff-4545-9296-497d12150729 29/07/2015 18:13 bp-2666bb07-a39d-43fc-ab4f-e65b62150718 18/07/2015 22:32 bp-8105e9f9-8f75-40bb-bda7-183f32150709 09/07/2015 23:09 bp-6b2109ed-a735-4ba1-9e89-c6aca2150707 07/07/2015 20:43 31FE13CD-B070-45CB-B157-5D04B0CB675F 28/06/2015 11:31 bp-bcc85795-d492-4315-8c2b-43e6e2150627 27/06/2015 16:25 bp-5ea95a70-01c4-4f39-b77f-6eba42150622 22/06/2015 19:21 bp-494b2943-ce7d-41e2-b7d7-75ae42150617 17/06/2015 18:10 bp-8b587d12-1fb5-4a03-91cf-1edd62150616 16/06/2015 19:19 bp-82493a68-01af-4c3c-9249-4853b2150616 16/06/2015 18:08 bp-80e2046a-e546-4a69-981a-776bd2150612 12/06/2015 21:59 bp-033f153d-3fd9-41fb-8b52-b9fdf2150530 30/05/2015 03:25 bp-ae103aba-4db2-40b7-bb09-731d62150528 28/05/2015 17:05 bp-d76b7a06-884c-4c34-9e1e-b40d72150520 20/05/2015 20:33 bp-6e67abea-846e-43e3-9f5d-a3abe2150508 08/05/2015 23:24 Very likely to happen if I've been streaming video for a long period of time (playing YouTube videos, especially long ones).
- _pmf_ 11y ago> The mention that they plan to remove XUL usage within Firefox (which is a good idea) is interesting. It's strange that XUL survives for so long. Adding an additional markup language to CSS, JS and HTML/DOM to be used for extension development has been bold. For some time, they would have had the chance to push XUL for general development (when Qt and WPF/XAML were not yet that much more modern).
- TazeTSchnitzel 11y agoWell, they did try to push it for other things. That was their original intention. Of course, it didn't catch on, so Firefox was stuck with an obscure UI language only it used.