3 ms·
I think you might want to read Outliers by Gladwell. What I don't get about your post is how do you explain the Chinese, Indian and all the other students not
by IgorPartola 17y ago
I think you might want to read Outliers by Gladwell.
What I don't get about your post is how do you explain the Chinese, Indian and all the other students not being disengaged? They apparently found it very stimulating (according to the boston.com article). Do you attribute that to just the language barrier? I came here knowing very little English about 9 years ago. I had 2 months to learn before I went to high school (freshman year). It was brutal, but I did well in school; and I am nearly completely incapable of learning another language (I tried learning Spanish for years).
So what's left? Is it that the foreign students come from a culture where hard work is emphasised more?
- philk 17y agoIt's probably two things: a) The foreign students and their families have had to sacrifice more and faced more uncertainty to get an education in America. When people have to suffer and struggle for something they value it much more than if it's just given to them. b) There's a selection bias too, deadbeats overseas are less likely to have their families spend the time and money necessary to get them a foreign education.
- rdtsc 17y agoWell said. It is amazing how much motivation the danger of a bleak future could be. That is basically my story. In my country (in Easter Europe) there were plenty of dead beats in the school, but they never left the country. Some of them are now in jail, many are living in the proverbial "van down by the river". I made it out not because I was the smartest but because I was persistent. What made the most difference for me personally was: 1. I saw my parents lose their jobs and strugle trying to make ends meet. 2. My parents encouraged me to learn from at very young age. For example: When my father would take the back cover of our old vacuum tube TV to clean it from dust, he would call me over and tell me what each of the components did and how electrons flowed and so on. I thought it was the best thing in the world. Another example: When I was 12 my mom, spent a month of her salary on a ZX Spectrum computer. I didn't ask her to. She just saw the way I looked at it and she knew it would help me to have one. Well, I loved it and I learned English just so I can use my new computer and read all the docs and write BASIC and Z80 assembly. That in turn, helped me pass a series of english proficiency tests need to get a scholarship to come to US. Long story short, I've been living in US ever since, doing what I love --programming. I'll bring my parent over soon as well. Note: School wasn't in my 2 bullet points above. And that is because school is secondary. It will not teach anything if the student doesn't already want to learn. They will provide the tests and homeworks, students will get marks to show they know how to take the particular test or do the particular homework. That is all. To rise above, there has to be an internal motivation.
- ajscherer 17y agoThe article doesn't say foreign students found Ms. Miller's history/rhetoric class stimulating. It says they work harder and take the class more seriously. That certainly matches what I've observed regarding foreign students. Could it be that foreign students (correctly) believe they have more to gain from doing well in Ms. Millers history and rhetoric classes at Babson college? When considering qualifications for jobs or further study, I think that grades are relatively weightier for foreign born students than for American born students. I also think that performance in Ms. Miller's class probably isn't of much long term importance for students not interested in rhetoric or history. If there is a problem with our educational system, it is the fact that these students are wasting their time and money in a class they don't care about and won't use.
- IgorPartola 17y agoI don't believe that most college classes are a waste. Some are, but most will teach you something. The least they will do is to teach you to communicate to people that study the particular discipline. If we were to only learn what was "useful" to our professions, we would not be (1) very happy or (2) very good at what we do. There is a reason why cross discipline education is still around and while some people do a poor job of delivering such education, we should not condemn the whole paradigm. What I find is that the biggest indicator of someone's success is not how well they know the subject matter of any given class, but how hard they try to do something. So doing well in Ms. Miller's class will not give you wads of useful knowledge but it will teach you how to tackle an unfamiliar problem. Doing well in her class will then demonstrate to others that you are willing to do more than your peers to overcome professional challenges, which ultimately translates into being a better professional.