3 ms·
"No, it's because it hasn't actually been tested anywhere." Then it is condemned by that too. If "psuedo-communism" kills millions, real Communism is so imprac
by jerf 11y ago
"No, it's because it hasn't actually been tested anywhere."
Then it is condemned by that too. If "psuedo-communism" kills millions, real Communism is so impractical and unhuman that it collapses so fast into tyranny and despotism that one needs specialized equipment from physics to measure its duration.
This is not to its credit as a practical system to run a country on.
- derefr 11y agoAFAIK, aren't workers' co-op corporations an example of "Real Communism" existing, and thriving, in the small? I would posit that while central allocation may have been discredited as an economic pursuit (outside, perhaps, of being something a Friendly AI might be capable of), the basic concept of earning the spoils of one's own labor is alive and well. Heck, we're moving toward it—fewer large corporations with layers of capital-suckling management, and more tiny networks of startups where each founder retains decent amounts of equity in (i.e. profits off of) their work.
- jerf 11y agoMy last paragraph wasn't extraneous. Many things work in the small that don't work in the large. One of the nice things about capitalism is that unlike ideological Communism, it does not insist that it is The One True System and that not only must the society be run on it but all subcomponents must be run on it. You are free in a properly capitalist society to build a communist commune if you like, or run a company that way, or run a company with competing departments, or anything else, and Capitalism remains pleasingly silent about how to conduct your family affairs. By contrast, Communism sticks its nose in everywhere and insists that it is the answer to everything, from running the entire country to how to raise your child. Unsurprisingly, something that tries to proscribe that much across that many orders of magnitude across that many domains fails miserably. In code terms, Capitalism is an interface; it says how entities interact but doesn't specify the nature of the entities. Communism is a very fragile over-engineered over-implemented "we'll call you" framework that's wrong in numerous ways, but management (literally!) is forcing you to use it.
- jsprogrammer 11y agoDoes Communism really claim to be "The One True System"? I thought the argument is that Communism is just the inevitability of Capitalism?