5 ms·
I can't help but feel like some of this is fear mongering. There are some good features in there that are being disabled for the sake of "privacy" like sharing
by slg 11y ago
I can't help but feel like some of this is fear mongering. There are some good features in there that are being disabled for the sake of "privacy" like sharing of Windows updates with other computers to speed up downloads. And how do we expect things like Windows Defender or Microsoft's handwriting and voice recognition to improve if we refuse to share back any anonymized information with Microsoft?
- mhurron 11y ago> like sharing of Windows updates with other computers to speed up downloads American internet speeds suck enough without Microsoft grabbing some for itself. > Windows Defender They seemed to be able to improve their services before. In fact, I think that's what a Security Researchers job is. MS has several of them. > handwriting and voice recognition Neither of which apply to my desktop, so why do I have to give them any information. Microsoft could have saved a lot of face simply by making all this opt in and off by default.
- slg 11y ago>American internet speeds suck enough without Microsoft grabbing some for itself. Which is why you should only have to download updates once for your entire network and not per device and why you shouldn't waste bandwidth on failed partial updates. This feature fixes both of these issues. >They seemed to be able to improve their services before. In fact, I think that's what a Security Researchers job is. MS has several of them I'm a software developer. My job is to write bug free code. My job would be a lot harder if I couldn't get any debug information from my testers or users. Just because it is possible to do a job without certain information, doesn't mean it is a good idea to intentionally withhold that information. >Neither of which apply to my desktop, so why do I have to give them any information. If you don't use voice or ink, why are you worried about sharing your voice and ink data with Microsoft? >Microsoft could have saved a lot of face simply by making all this opt in and off by default. Because most of these features would have never been turned on by the user. What good is a security setting that is supposed to protect unskilled computer users if it requires in depth knowledge of the OS to turn on in the first place?
- ThatGeoGuy 11y ago> If you don't use voice or ink, why are you worried about sharing your voice and ink data with Microsoft? For what it's worth, I don't think this is a fair assessment. Sure, with ink data, you actually need a tablet or some kind of input device in order for Microsoft to collect and send data. But almost every laptop or off-the-shelf computer nowadays comes with a microphone, and they will be more ubiquitous now that voice recognition and input is becoming more accepted by the general populace. The problem then, is that the microphone is _always_ on, and could potentially send _everything_ you say, or could listen in at any given moment. The problem is that with voice data, the feature 1) can't be inspected and 2) will send data, even if you never use the service. Most important here is the latter point: I shouldn't be subject to the terms and conditions of using a service if I am not using a service. By not agreeing to the terms and conditions, I don't get to use the service (Cortana). If I'm fine with that, and don't want to use that service, then the terms and conditions of my data being sent to Microsoft should not apply to me (i.e. my data should not be sent). Doing otherwise is shady behaviour, regardless of your opinion on the usefulness or nefariousness of the feature in question.
- slg 11y agoThe idea that Microsoft would capture all audio depends on the company being simultaneously malicious enough to bug your computer while being honest enough not to lie about it. The truth is that they would have had the ability to do this type of thing for years. If Microsoft had an intention to do evil things, why would the bring attention to the fact by spelling out the possibility of them doing evil things during installation of their software?
- mhurron 11y ago> Which is why you should only have to download updates once for your entire network and not per device and why you shouldn't waste bandwidth on failed partial updates. This feature fixes both of these issues. There is ONE Windows machine on my network, so there are no other Windows machines to share updates with. There are a tonne on the internet though, I don't care about sharing with them. > My job would be a lot harder It's too bad it was impossible to do before Microsoft was spying on its users. Oh wait, it wasn't. > If you don't use voice or ink, why are you worried about sharing your voice and ink data with Microsoft? I don't want to send anything to Microsoft. > Because most of these features would have never been turned on by the user. There is a reason for that, people don't want it. > What good is a security setting ... These are not security settings. The security comes from turning them off.
- cremno 11y ago>They seemed to be able to improve their services before. Before what? These are no new features.
- mhurron 11y agoYes, they are not new features, so how did they improve them before they spied on everything your system does?
- joesmo 11y ago"And how do we expect things like Windows Defender or Microsoft's handwriting and voice recognition to improve if we refuse to share back any anonymized information with Microsoft?" Exactly by not sharing any information with MS. If they didn't assume that people wanted to share their private information (they don't), they'd create software with proper architecture that doesn't need to connect to the could to do simple things like handwriting analysis and voice recognition.
- Mithaldu 11y ago> simple things like handwriting analysis and voice recognition I honestly can't tell if you actually believe what you are saying, or are just making a really badly told joke.
- joesmo 11y agoI'm not making a joke. There's no need for cloud computing resources for effective voice recognition or handwriting analysis. Therefore, since those applications can run on the device itself, they are rather simple from a network perspective which is what we're discussing here.
- deleted 11y ago[deleted]
- JustSomeNobody 11y agoLittle known fact: Those are not _simple_ things.
- joesmo 11y agoThey are simple enough to run on the hardware itself without needing cloud support.
- MattBearman 11y agoUnless you have an internet connection with an unlimited upstream data allowance you probably should disable sharing updates with other computers
- Someone1234 11y agoOr just enable it for LAN only, an option they provide.
- drdaeman 11y ago> And how do we expect things like Windows Defender or Microsoft's handwriting and voice recognition to improve if we refuse to share back any anonymized information with Microsoft? By opt-in approach and full transparency on what data's sent. Seriously, ask me "hey, can you help us?", provide an option to let me see what data exactly was, being and will be sent (NOT some multi-page legalese with notice that everything in there could change at company's discretion) - and unless you're sending something I really don't want to share (like actual raw texts I typed instead of processed statistical data), you're very likely to have my help. And, given the current situation, even praise the approach and suggest other to help the noble intent. There's a giant difference between this and a pre-installed black box that sends some data which contents I don't even know.
- wldcordeiro 11y agoYou often hear the phrase "It's better to ask for forgiveness than to ask for permission" especially hear on Hacker News and around start-ups. Microsoft is taking the same approach. I agree that opt-in and full transparency would be the best in an ideal world. But the reality is that people don't care enough and most people wouldn't opt-in willingly or wouldn't realize what they could opt-in to.
- dingaling 11y ago> "It's better to ask for forgiveness than to ask for permission" Which works perhaps twice in the corporate world before you're thrown out on the street. In the realm of public opinion sometimes even once is enough to wreck a brand. For the first time ever I have non-tech colleagues asking me about Linux.
- dragonwriter 11y ago> You often hear the phrase "It's better to ask for forgiveness than to ask for permission" The more common phrase is easier rather than better. (Which is why the initialism form is EAFP rather than BAFP.) And it is easier. Also, however, more prone to adverse consequences when the answer to what you ask is "no".
- 11y ago
- dragonwriter 11y ago> Microsoft's handwriting and voice recognition to improve if we refuse to share back any anonymized information with Microsoft? Handwriting and voice recognition software have both been available for decades, and have improved considerably over most of that time without most end-users being required to share data back with the software makers (in many cases, without most users even having a mechanism available to do so.)