4 ms·
>So the situation in some cases is far worse already." So, that's the thing, in some ways it's worse. It has more detail, it's voluntary and less intrusive.
by mc32 11y ago
>So the situation in some cases is far worse already."
So, that's the thing, in some ways it's worse. It has more detail, it's voluntary and less intrusive. The one thing which is quite different is it's not a system to control people, by control I mean controlling as in Orwell's vision.
And, for the most part, with few sheepish objections, people are willing to trade in their privacy in exchange for services rendered. People in practice value free resources and services over privacy, else we would have seen a system of micropaymets or economic alternative take root but it has not.
At some point people may change their minds and may want to hold on to their privacy and begin paying for services, maybe, but for most people that is not the case at this time.
- cm2187 11y agoMost of the people I know do not understand/realize the extent to which they are spied on. If GCHQ was opening their paper mail every day and keeping a copy of all their correspondance and they knew it, they would start a revolution.
- mc32 11y agoI don't think that would be the case. At first there would be indignation, but then they'd conclude that despite the pervasiveness nothing bad had come of it to them (hauled down to the met office, say), therefore it cannot actually be bad and that on balance it was probably good since it allows "them" to catch the baddies. It's something akin to the slow boil effect.
- tobltobs 11y agoThey just don't care. Even when Cameron said: “In our country, do we want to allow a means of communication between people which […] we cannot read?” nobody cared. Maybe if they start implanting transponders into peoples heads there would be a small uproar, but forget a revolution in the UK against surveillance, this will never happen.
- JupiterMoon 11y agoThat they "just don't care" is not in my experience true. When it is explained most people I've spoken do care. However, then they ask "and what can we do about it?" and the answer is either "change everything about how you do things" or "not much"... And then they don't care enough to go beyond this stage or they are just confused and scared. Either way back to facebook the next day.
- stevejones 11y ago> So, that's the thing, in some ways it's worse. It has more detail, it's voluntary and less intrusive. The one thing which is quite different is it's not a system to control people, by control I mean controlling as in Orwell's vision. So to start, there's this. http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2011/23/schedule/1 http://www.legislation.gov.uk/ukpga/2011/23/schedule/1 It actually replaced the even worse 2005 act. This is not voluntary, is very intrusive and is exactly a system to control people. But then the actual surveillance, where on earth do you get that it's voluntary. Unless you're suggesting that simply having an Internet connection, a phone or travelling in a town is volunteering to be be surveilled.
- pharrington 11y agoThe term Faustian Bargain comes to mind in regard to paying for commercial services with our privacy. Most people just straight up don't know what advertising is really about. Also, at least in America, we aren't educated about what's happened historically after super powerful institutions invert the privacy/transparency dynamic. Just because the human species hasn't, in the last 15 years, evolved to learn to weigh long term, abstract consequences on an appropriate magnitude with immediate gain does not justify those exploiting this quirk in human decision making. Also, a camera on every street corner and spy agencies spying on you isn't what "voluntary" means.