5 ms·
I smell a Blank Slate Fallacy. Math talent, like other intelligence, is inheritable. So until you've pried apart nature and nurture, the simplest assumption is
by BurningFrog 11y ago
I smell a Blank Slate Fallacy.
Math talent, like other intelligence, is inheritable. So until you've pried apart nature and nurture, the simplest assumption is that these kids are bad at math because they don't have much talent for it.
Google Turkheimer's Three Laws of Behavior Genetics for more on this often neglected field.
- Wintamute 11y agoIndeed, well said. Seems just as plausible, if not more so, that the anxiety is a symptom of poor familial aptitude for mathematics than the cause itself. But that's a thoughtcrime these days, so best not mention it ...
- randomnumber53 11y agoAh, but it's only a thoughtcrime if you don't say it, and people call you an idiot for just thinking that.
- dnissley 11y agoBut until we know something provable about genetics and mathematical aptitude this line of thought is just hand-waving. You still don't know any better than anybody else why somebody is having a hard time with math.
- Wintamute 11y agoThat's why I said it seems "just as plausible" as the alternative. Its the article that's making the more definitive statements, not me. Besides, I think there's a reasonable amount of science that makes the argument for genetics over nurture quite compelling, but 20 years of malpractice and misdirection in the social sciences obfuscated that.
- Jarwain 11y agoDoesn't the study control for this? "The more the math-anxious parents tried to work with their children, the worse their children did in math, slipping more than a third of a grade level behind their peers." The implication is that if the math-anxious parents did not work with their children as much, these children did better.
- BurningFrog 11y agoThat just says that if you're bad at math, trying to teach it doesn't help. That's useful "know your limitations" information, but I don't see how it separates nature vs nurture effects.
- grayclhn 11y agoNo, it says that if you're anxious about math, trying to teach it hurts the child's comprehension.
- BurningFrog 11y agoI don't think there is much distinction between "bad at math" and "anxious about math". The article certainly doesn't try to make one.
- grayclhn 11y agoI was making a distinction between "hurts" and "doesn't help."
- BurningFrog 11y agoThen we agree.
- kaitai 11y agoBut what is "mathematical intelligence" or "math talent"? There's a big chunk of my family that didn't get any formal education in mathematics or anything else until very recently, and one of my most recent ancestors didn't exactly finish high school because of what I would retroactively diagnose as some learning disability. (Trouble with symbols & writing.) On the other hand, the same recent ancestor could visualize the way to build just about anything. So here I am, without a great love for algebra or analysis, but a great love for geometry (algebraic, differential, symplectic, etc) and a fine ability to create fitted knit garments and small pieces of furniture (and a PhD in pure math). Perhaps that's inherited, but due to the environment it didn't get anyone in my family past that far in higher education. I still screw up my face in frustration over subtraction problems, too, so do I lack "math talent" after all? Did my recent ancestor who failed high school classes have math talent or not? And did my ancestors who didn't have a high school at all but could build a barn that still stands one hundred years later have math talent or not? How can we even talk about whether this thing is inheritable if we don't define it well and it manifests in such different ways in different environments? The simplest assumption is that these kids are bad at math because math in our elementary and middle schools sucks! Look at the stats for immigrants to the US. If you came from impoverished places without educational opportunities, educational attainment rises over time. If you are a kid who comes from Hungary or Romania or Russia or South Korea, you'll be so much better at math than the US kids that it's not even funny. If your grandparents came from Hungary or Romania or South Korea and kicked ass at math, but your family has been in the US for a few generations, you'll suck as much as any other average American. If you're going to push heritability, you're going to have to face the conclusion that the water and air in America prompt genetic mutations that make people bad at math over a few generations. (I'm so glad I'm first-gen in part, but I fear for potential children.)
- erroneousfunk 11y agoAlso, why is it that when things like "illiteracy rates" come up, no one ever says "well, maybe they just don't have a talent for reading"? Reading and comprehension is a heck of a lot harder than multiplying fractions.
- stdbrouw 11y agoI smell needless dichotomization. I'd rather teachers and parents didn't give up on students just because part of their mathematical aptitude might be genetically determined. Until you've pried apart nature and nurture, give people the benefit of the doubt.