3 ms·
This itself explains the worship of the Standard Algorithm, and why people see a New World Order conspiracy behind every attempt to reform math education. Not
by bitwize 11y ago
This itself explains the worship of the Standard Algorithm, and why people see a New World Order conspiracy behind every attempt to reform math education.
Not helping matters is the fact that most of the reformers are themselves ignorant chuckleheads who identify the heuristics that skilled arithmeticians use and codify them as a NEW set of rules to be memorized...
- stdbrouw 11y agoFWIW, this is certainly not what people who do research into how to teach math advocate. In fact, one of the recommendations for teachers is that they should try to get students to come up with the algorithms themselves, or to "guide" them to these algorithms, and then let students use whichever they prefer, because that's the only way to get students to really understand and use them. That said, I've definitely seen some of that "let's just replace method X with method Y" – how harmful that is depends on whether it is just presented as a default or as The New Standard Algorithm, I guess.
- bitwize 11y ago> FWIW, this is certainly not what people who do research into how to teach math advocate. Of course it isn't, because such lunacy wouldn't be supported by competent research. But the people who do education research, the administrators making curriculum decisions, and the concerned parents trolling about the dangers of "Common Core" on Facebook are distinct sets with little overlap.
- milspec 11y agoStandard algorithms are standard for very good reasons. They are 100% reliable and at least reasonably fast, if not the fastest. Failure to learn the standard algorithms impedes progress. You are unlikely to do well in the next course if you are slow and can't handle numerous cases. Learning alternate algorithms is great... once you have the standard algorithms down solid and are ready to prove equivalence.
- keithpeter 11y agoConcrete illustrations based on things in your world -> procedural methods (your algorithms) -> formal proof seems to work in my teaching of basic maths to adults. Have a look at the sample chapter from David Tall's book... https://homepages.warwick.ac.uk/staff/David.Tall/themes/three-worlds.html https://homepages.warwick.ac.uk/staff/David.Tall/themes/thre...