4 ms·
The Efficient Market Hypothesis should probably be considered more like a Carnot engine than like a real internal combustion engine: some substantial degree of
by icebraining 11y ago
The Efficient Market Hypothesis should probably be considered more like a Carnot engine than like a real internal combustion engine: some substantial degree of inefficiency is probably an inevitable result of operating in the real world.
That's a specious conclusion; the paper explicitly says that the inefficiency is due to the degree of management present in West Germany, which was significant.
It's not like the EMH says the market prices are theoretically perfect; it only says they're better than whatever individual or group can calculate. And the paper you cite provides evidence for that.
"To sum up, the unexpected similarity of overall deviance between actual prices and
eigenprices in East and West does not warrant the conclusion that East German pricing
behaviour was not so bad after all and more or less guided by relative scarcities. In those
sectors where market forces prevail in the West, East German actual prices deviate
significantly more from eigenprices. However, the similarity of the overall indicator
testifies to the fact that a sizeable part of West German GNP is not produced under
competitive market conditions. It obviously is the case in sectors with predominant public
ownership rights and strong government influence."
(Emphasis mine)
https://www.europa-uni.de/de/forschung/institut/institut_fit/publikationen/discussion_papers/1996/96-4-DietzWag.pdf https://www.europa-uni.de/de/forschung/institut/institut_fit...