3 ms·
A family member of mine with diagnosed Celiac, 50% Dutch 50% German, now dreads his bi-yearly colonoscopies (as he has hit that age) as he has to be fully put u
by jerf 11y ago
A family member of mine with diagnosed Celiac, 50% Dutch 50% German, now dreads his bi-yearly colonoscopies (as he has hit that age) as he has to be fully put under for what is normally an outpatient procedure because his intestines are now unusually long as a result of ~30-50 years of untreated, unknown Celiac. The doctor apparently acted like this is not an unusual thing. No other known factors would produce this result (i.e. my family is not otherwise known for large intestines in the other family members of the colonoscopy age).
This proves nothing specific about the Japanese, but does demonstrate that apparently environmental factors can affect intestine length, and the relevant medical communities consider this boring background knowledge rather than a research topic or urban legend. It is likely in this family member's case that the Celiac only kicked in fully in his 20s, so it is likely all the "environmental factors" occurred in full adulthood (though it is hard to be sure).
(I'm unclear on how long intestines make it harder to digest meat, though. Being overprovisioned for a task does not generally make the task more difficult. I'd find it more likely that it's simply a matter of gut flora adapting to the local diet and not liking deviations. It's the same reason vegetarians can think meat is bad for everybody because when they eat a bit of meat they have a bad, gassy reaction; their gut flora is not adapted for it. (If meat is indeed bad for everyone, that isn't why.) It is easy to be correct about some fact and really, really wrong about the reason behind the fact.)
- gohrt 11y agoNot necessarily relevant to meat, but, if your intestines are too long, then you might be at risk for over-digesting something , dehydrating it into a hard mass that is difficult for the rest of the sytem to process.
- lnanek2 11y agoIt's well established that carnivores have much shorter intestinal tracts. Meat is relatively easy to digest and simply doesn't need a long break down and absorption process. So we know meat eaters don't need long intestines like herbivores. Now, as to your question about long intestines making it harder to digest meat. They don't do that in exclusion, they make living at all more difficult, and digesting meat is a sub task of living. Research a bit on all the digestive troubles of horses and cows, colic and the like, and you'll find out that massive, long systems of intestines and stomachs have a lot that can go wrong and kill the animal. Long intestines let the animal live off easier to catch food, yes, but there are definite drawbacks.