4 ms·
> Also, do you correct for body length, for body volume, or for neither? Start by doing none of the above, but simply measuring the intestines, and recording t
by pavel_lishin 11y ago
> Also, do you correct for body length, for body volume, or for neither?
Start by doing none of the above, but simply measuring the intestines, and recording the data, along with all the things you mentioned above. Statistical analyses can be done after, to see if there's anything interesting in the data at all.
Not sure how to address the tension question; I guess ideally, you'd have someone fly around to Japan and a few other countries, and demonstrate some arbitrary method of measurement. But that starts to get expensive.
- yummyfajitas 11y agoThe statistical analysis to be done should be decided before looking at the data. http://www.stat.columbia.edu/~gelman/research/unpublished/p_hacking.pdf http://www.stat.columbia.edu/~gelman/research/unpublished/p_... Blinding should be pretty easy and cheap - have an assistant cover up the head with a sheet as the measurement is made.
- Someone 11y ago"Blinding should be pretty easy and cheap - have an assistant cover up the head with a sheet as the measurement is made." But you would need to move the body, or have an experimenter who doesn't know whether he is in Japan (using Japanese living abroad or westerners living in Japan for the experiment is for the follow-up study) Also, but that's relatively minor, covering the head is insufficient. There are lots of other cues, such as skin color, tattoos, missing little fingers, body size, etc. that correlate well with being Japanese as opposed to being a westerner. I would have the assistant cut out everything from the stomach down (even though there is a sphincter, if the size difference is small, specifying where the intestines start will be a challenge) and empty it before handing it over to the experimenter (indirectly, to prevent communication between assistant and experimenters)
- yummyfajitas 11y ago"Missing little fingers"? I've never been to Japan, but as far as I know, most folks aren't in the Yakuza. Also, I wouldn't be super worried about blinding in this case - a length measurement is not particularly subjective. I cannot see how unconscious bias would reasonably add 20-50% (postulated effect size) to intestine length. I'd personally consider the results valid even without blinding, provided a rigid procedure was chosen for measuring intestine length.